Mentally ill threat in nursing homes

March 22, 2009 By CARLA K. JOHNSON , AP Medical Writer
ADVANCE FOR MONDAY, MARCH 23; graphic shows the rise of mentally ill residents in nursing homes from 2002 to 2008; includes breakdown by state

(AP) -- Ivory Jackson had Alzheimer's, but that wasn't what killed him. At 77, he was smashed in the face with a clock radio as he lay in his nursing home bed.

Jackson's roommate - a man nearly 30 years younger - was arrested and charged with the killing. Police found him sitting next to the nurse's station, blood on his hands, clothes and shoes. Inside their room, the ceiling was spattered with blood.

"Why didn't they do what they needed to do to protect my dad?" wondered Jackson's stepson, Russell Smith.

Over the past several years, have become dumping grounds for young and middle-age people with mental illness, according to Associated Press interviews and an analysis of data from all 50 states. And that has proved a prescription for violence, as Jackson's case and others across the country illustrate.

Younger, stronger residents with schizophrenia, depression or are living beside frail senior citizens, and sometimes taking their rage out on them.

"Sadly, we're seeing the tragic results of the failure of federal and state governments to provide appropriate treatment and housing for those with and to provide a safe environment for the frail elderly," said Janet Wells, director of public policy for the National Citizens' Coalition for Nursing Home Reform.

Numbers obtained through the Freedom of Information Act and prepared exclusively for the AP by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services show nearly 125,000 young and middle-aged adults with serious mental illness lived in U.S. nursing homes last year.

That was a 41 percent increase from 2002, when nursing homes housed nearly 89,000 mentally ill people ages 22 to 64. Most states saw increases, with Utah, Nevada, Missouri, Alabama and Texas showing the steepest climbs.

Younger mentally ill people now make up more than 9 percent of the nation's nearly 1.4 million nursing , up from 6 percent in 2002.

Several forces are behind the trend, among them: the closing of state mental institutions and a shortage of hospital psychiatric beds. Also, nursing homes have beds to fill because today's elderly are healthier than the generation before them and are more independent and more likely to stay in their homes.

No government agency keeps count of killings or serious assaults committed by the mentally ill against the elderly in nursing homes. But a number of tragic cases have occurred:

- In 2003, a 23-year-old woman in Connecticut was charged with starting a fire that killed 16 fellow patients at her Hartford nursing home. A court guardian said Leslie Andino suffered from multiple sclerosis, dementia and depression. She was found incompetent to stand trial and committed to a mental institution.

- In 2006, 77-year-old Norbert Konwin died at a South Toledo, Ohio, nursing home 10 days after authorities said his 62-year-old roommate beat him with a bathroom towel bar. Sharon John Hawkins was found incompetent to stand trial.

- In January, a 21-year-old man diagnosed with bipolar disorder with aggression was charged with raping a 69-year-old fellow patient at their nursing home in Elgin, near Chicago. A state review found that Christopher Shelton was admitted to the nursing home despite a history of violence and was left unsupervised even after he told staff he was sexually frustrated.

Jackson's roommate was 50 and had a history of aggression and "altered mental status," according to the state nursing home inspector's report. Solomon Owasanoye wandered the streets before he came to All Faith Pavilion, a Chicago nursing home, and he yelled, screamed and kicked doors after he got there.

On May 30, 2008, he allegedly picked up a clock radio, apparently while Jackson slept, and beat him into a coma. Exactly what set him off is unclear. Jackson died of his injuries less than a month later. Owasanoye pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, and after a psychiatric review was ruled unfit to stand trial. He now lives in a state mental hospital.

All Faith Pavilion co-owner Brian Levinson said his staff is trained to deal with aggressive behavior, and he disputed state findings that Owasanoye had a history of aggression. The for-profit nursing home was fined $32,500 for failing to prevent the assault.

Under federal law, nursing homes are barred from admitting a mentally ill patient unless the state has determined that the person needs the high level of care a nursing home can provide. States are responsible for doing the screening. Also, federal law guarantees nursing home residents the right to be free from physical abuse.

Families have sued in hopes of forcing states to change their practices and pressuring nursing homes to prevent assaults. Advocates say many mentally ill people in nursing homes could live in apartments if they got help taking their medication and managing their lives.

The problem has its roots in the 1960s, when deplorable conditions, improved drug treatments and civil rights lawsuits led officials to close many state mental hospitals. As a result, some states have come to rely largely on nursing homes to care for mentally ill people of all ages.

Also, mixing the mentally ill with the elderly makes economic sense for states. As long as a nursing home's mentally ill population stays under 50 percent, the federal government will help pay for the residents' care under Medicaid. Otherwise, the home is classified a mental institution, and the government won't pay.

In Missouri, more than 4,400 younger mentally ill people are living in nursing homes, in part because of a state program that helps the elderly stay in their own homes longer.

Nursing homes "are looking at 60 to 70 percent occupancy, and the statistics tell us they've got to be in the 90s to operate successfully," said Carol Scott, the state long-term care ombudsman for 20 years. "They're going to take anybody they can."

Gaps in staff training leave the homes inept at handling the delusions and aggression of the mentally ill, said Becky Kurtz, the state long-term care ombudsman in Georgia, where nearly 3,300 younger mentally ill people live in nursing homes.

"Often they'll say, 'I hate it there. I'm angry. I don't want to be there.' Sometimes the behavioral issues are the result of being ticked off you're in a nursing home," Kurtz said.

Pat Willis of the Center for Prevention of Abuse said she has seen elderly residents terrified by younger, mentally ill residents who scream and yell, day and night. "The senior residents are afraid," Willis said. "They would prefer to sit in their rooms now and keep the doors shut."

Nursing home operators say protections against frivolous transfer or discharge keep the homes from throwing out some mentally ill residents.

"Many times, the nursing home's only option becomes dialing 911," said Lauren Shaham, a spokeswoman for the American Association of Homes and Services for the Aging.

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Related Stories

Recommended for you


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (2) Mar 23, 2009
Good to learn that schizophrenic, bipolar, and depressed people are dangerous, unpredictable individuals who might "take their rage" out on the rest of us. Too bad that there weren't any statistics to highlight the threat! Why, I bet an analysis of the incidence of violent crime in retirement homes would show that a disproportionate number of these crimes were committed by the mentally ill! After all, all three of the anecdotes taken from over the last five years involve mentally ill people. What are the odds of that?

In all seriousness, those who require institutionalized care because of geriatric conditions should not, if possible, be required to live alongside those who require institutionalized care because of psychiatric conditions. The potential for distress would seem to be high, and it is certainly newsworthy that states are using nursing homes as impromptu long-term psychiatric wards. However, this article plays upon the fears of the mentally ill rather shamelessly, perpetuates the notion that the mentally ill are more violent than those who are not, and does not contain any actual scientific information; rather, in seeking to persuade by anecdote, it shows itself to be fundamentally detached from scientific ethics and epistemology. To put it bluntly, it should not be here.
2.3 / 5 (3) Mar 23, 2009
This is the inevitable result of Jimmy Carter's lovely wife pushing to close "insane asylums" back in the '70s. Lack of treatment facilities, attempting to "help these people" by requiring self medication (a version of treat and release), and believing that living in a public park is superior to living in a facility hasn't solved the problem of the mentally challenged. Rather, it has mad the problem worse. Like the mentally ill patients, liberal policy makers frantically try to apply failed methods with increasing frequency and increasing power. Despite adding money to their failed policies the policies continue to fail. The difference between those in need of help and the liberal helper is that it's acceptable to be crazy as a congressman.
3.7 / 5 (3) Mar 23, 2009
Smellyhat, in general I agree with you. However, the mentally ill that are NOT dangerous are rarely institutionalized. States are "caring" for the mentally ill by medicating them and putting them on the street. A lot of these folks get along somehow. Some hold jobs. Some evoke frequent encounters with the police. The law enforcement system pushes them into "managed care facilities" rather than jail (that should be good). In the vast majority of communities such facilities are nursing homes. Nursing homes are the only facilities left that have the legal ability to administer meds. The result of this system, which is after all built on liberal political principles not sound psychological science, is what we read in the above article. Powerful liberals will not admit, nor allow dissenting views, that their policies are flawed. I'm a psychologist who has seen these policies in action since the '70s (I'm now retired). It's going to take a large scale tragedy for folks, Conservatives would rather ignore this issue, to force policy change. A treatment facility for adolescents just a few miles from my home was just closed. I was a "substitute high school teacher" there. Some of these kids need long term care. I wonder where they are now?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.