Can nudging help fight the obesity epidemic?

With obesity rates soaring, the government has been promoting nudge – a strategy that does not tell people how to live but encourages them to make healthy choices in respect of diet and exercise.

Experts in the British Medical Journal this week go head to head over whether nudge is an effective way to tackle obesity.

Professor Tim Lang and Dr Geof Rayner, both from the Centre for Food Policy at City University in London, say that nudge is not new and that it is "a smokescreen for, at best, inaction and, at worst, publicly endorsed marketing."

They argue that the nudging strategy portrays governments in a soft light and allows them to shy away from taking tough action that can be unpopular – for example introducing more regulation, higher taxes and legislation that restricts or bans unhealthy habits.

The responsibility deals with industry that were formalised in the 2010 public health white paper add further concern to the use of nudging, they say.

Finally, they also worry that nudge "becomes collusion between the state and corporations to hoodwink consumers."

But Dr Adam Oliver from the London School of Economics and Political Science in London, argues that there is a lot of ignorance about what nudge actually means. He says that nudge should not be seen as a replacement for stricter forms of food regulation but rather as "an additional tool to complement regulation by moving society incrementally in a direction that might benefit all of us."

Oliver says that, while nudging is at an initial development stage and that little evaluation has taken place, "the beauty in the approach in that almost everyone can think up and pilot financially costless initiatives in their households or workplaces."

He concludes that, "in tackling , the nudge approach will be no substitute for regulation of the food and drinks industry, but it may nonetheless serve the social good."

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Physical activity by stealth NOT health

Apr 07, 2011

The Government sees active travel to work as a convenient way of building activity into lifestyle and an important public health strategy. A new study suggests that transport plans aimed at reducing car usage ...

Recommended for you

How physicians are adapting to payment reform

4 hours ago

Private and public healthcare providers in the U.S. are increasingly turning to the "pay-for-performance" model, in which physicians and hospitals are paid if they meet healthcare quality and efficiency targets. ...

Patients at emergency departments regarded as 'symptoms'

5 hours ago

The healthcare work of providing care at Emergency departments is medicalized and result-driven. As a consequence of this, patients are regarded as "symptoms", and are shunted around the department as "production units". ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Arkaleus
5 / 5 (2) Apr 15, 2011
Living room scene, London, 2017 6:45 am:

Having just stumbled out of his bed and into the telescreen room, Winston squints at the immaculately trim activity manager leading the morning exercise for his sector.

"Number 64825, you're not touching your toes all the way," She scolded as Winston came into view.

"Yes ma'am," Winston sheepishly replied, grunting as his fingers met the floor.

For all the efforts of the UK's public health protection services, Winston always seemed to tuck away a few more calories than his carbon ration card allowed. This made morning activities a little more strenuous than it perhaps could have been.

"Overeating is a crime, number 64825. You'll need to watch those meat rations if you ever hope to pass medicals this quarter."

Winston pulled his standard issue sweatpants up and looked at his feet. "Yes ma'am, I understand."

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.