BreastScreen: balancing benefits and harms

New research has questioned the relative impact of mammographic screening in reducing deaths from breast cancer, concluding that it is not responsible for most of the recent reduction in mortality rates and may in fact cause unnecessary surgery through over-diagnosis.

The Federal Government launched Breastscreen Australia, a free program for women over 40 in 1991. In the twenty years since the program was implemented, for breast cancer have declined by 28 per cent.

In research published in and Treatment Monash University researchers concluded that the majority of that reduction cannot be attributed to earlier through mammographic screening, but is the result of improvements in treatment.

Monash University researchers, Associate Professor Robin Bell, Women’s Health Program, with Professor Robert Burton, Dr. Geetha Thiagarajah, and Dr. Christopher Stevenson of the Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine analysed data from BreastScreen Australia and the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.

Associate Professor Bell said that almost 60 per cent of the decline in mortality rates occurred before BreastScreen could have had an effect.

“Additionally, the age group showing the greatest decline in mortality over the study period had the lowest participation rates in BreastScreen,” Associate Professor Bell said. 

“When you drill down further into the data, the group with the highest screening participation rate showed no significant reduction in mortality in the period when BreastScreen should have been making an impact.

“Evidence suggests that the welcome decline in mortality rates probably results from increased use of adjuvant therapies to surgery and radiotherapy, such as chemotherapy and endocrine therapy. It’s not that we’re finding cancers earlier, it’s that we’re getting much better at treating them.”

The concern about over-diagnosis has been echoed internationally with one study finding that one in three cancers are over-diagnosed. 

“Mammographic screening is able to detect cancers before they exhibit symptoms, which can be very helpful. However, not all cancers are lethal. In some cases, they are indolent and were women not screened, they would live healthy, happy lives never knowing that they had cancer,” Associate Professor Bell said. 

“Doctors of course, cannot know which cancers will develop into a health threat, so all detected cancers are treated. This is an important area for research for the future so we get much better at determining which cancers are likely to progress.

“Women need to be better informed about the full implications of breast , and of undergoing treatment for asymptomatic cancer,” she said.

"We need to be able to clearly communicate these issues to women so they are able to make an informed choice."

Related Stories

Stress wrongly blamed for breast cancer

date Mar 23, 2011

Australian breast cancer survivors mistakenly see stress as the cause of their cancer while vastly underestimating the possibility that an unhealthy lifestyle may have been a contributing factor.

Women with breast cancer continue to smoke, drink

date Sep 29, 2011

New research shows that Australian women are prepared to make lifestyle changes, such as altering  their diet, following diagnosis with breast cancer, however they are unwilling to give up alcohol and cigarettes - increasing ...

Mammography rates declining in the United States

date May 14, 2007

Since 2000 mammography rates have declined significantly in the United States, according to a new study. Published in the June 15, 2007 issue of CANCER, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Cancer Society, the study by ...

Recommended for you

Cancer prevention efforts in the US a mixed bag

date 9 hours ago

While there has been substantial progress in some cancer control efforts in the past several decades, like reductions in smoking and increased utilization of cancer screening, progress in some areas is lagging, according ...

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.