French study suggests maggots may clean wounds faster than surgery

by Bob Yirka report
maggots
Image: National Institutes of Health

(Medical Xpress) -- For thousands of years, people have used maggots to clean out wounds, particularly in battlefield situations when there were few other options. Use of maggots (fly larvae) virtually disappeared in the modern world though once antibiotics arrived on the scene, but that may change as a new study conducted by a team in France has shown that at least for some types of wounds, maggots may be the preferential form of treatment. The team, made up of doctors and researchers from various facilities in France, conducted a study with elderly male volunteers who had lower leg wounds or skin ulcers that weren’t healing well, and as they describe in their study published in Archives of Dermatology, the patients that were treated with maggots, fared better, at least in the first week, than did those treated with conventional surgical procedures.

In order to reproduce, flies lay their eggs in the carcasses of dead animals. The eggs develop into maggots which eventually grow into adults by eating the meat in which they exist. To accomplish this feat they secrete a substance into the dead tissue that helps to break it down first. The maggots then simply eat the result. When introduced into injured human flesh, the maggots perform the same trick, eating dead flesh while leaving healthy flesh alone, though not necessarily in the same fashion. In the wild, as anyone that has stumbled upon the carcass of a dead animal and found it literally crawling with the small rice looking knows, it’s a truly stomach retching sight. In a medical environment, on the other hand it can be a truly innocuous experience.

In the study, the team split up a group of 119 men into two groups of close to 50 each; one group received conventional surgery to repair their wound, while the other received maggot therapy. Both were kept in the hospital for two weeks and both were blindfolded during treatment.

In the surgical procedure, a scalpel is used to cut away dead flesh, along with some that is not dead. The maggot procedure is done by pressing a bag that has sterile maggots in it against a wound which has first been covered by a thin film to protect against infection. Thus, the maggots are not free to crawl around inside of the patient.

Afterwards, in looking at the results, the team found that those patients that had received maggot therapy, for the most part, showed better results at the end of the first week. After that, there was no discernible difference in the two procedures. In this context, better results meant there was less slough (dead matter) in the wound (54.5% vs 66.5%) and more apparent healing.

The team noted that roughly half of the people in both groups reported a crawling-around feeling in the wound, and most agreed the pain involved was minimal.

This one study suggests that more research needs to be done regarding the use of in healing wounds, because despite the ick factor; people should have access to the best possible treatment. Thus far, little has been done though. In the United States, for example, despite the fact that the FDA gave approval for use of maggot therapy back in 2004, little testing, research or actual procedures have been carried out and some patients, such as those with diabetes or those that cannot abide anesthesia, have likely suffered for it.

More information: Maggot Therapy for Wound Debridement, Arch Dermatol. Published online December 19, 2011. doi:10.1001/archdermatol.2011.1895

Abstract
Objective  To study the efficacy of bagged larvae on wound debridement compared with conventional treatment.
Design  Randomized, multicenter, controlled, prospective phase 3 trial with blinded assessment of outcome measures by a single observer.
Setting  Two hospital referral centers in Caen and Lyon, France.
Patients  Random sampling of 119 patients with a nonhealing, sloughy wound 40 cm2 or smaller, less than 2 cm deep, and an ankle brachial index of 0.8 or higher.
Intervention  During a 2-week hospital stay, patients received either maggot debridement therapy (MDT) or conventional treatment. At discharge, conventional dressings were applied and a follow-up visit occurred at day 30.
Main Outcome Measure  Percentage of slough in wounds at day 15.
Results  There was a significant difference between groups at day 8 (54.5% in the MDT group and 66.5% in the control group) (P = .04). The mean percentage of slough at day 15 was 55.4% in the MDT group and 53.8% in the control group (P = .78).
Conclusions  Although MDT shows no significant benefit at day 15 compared with conventional treatment, debridement by MDT is significantly faster and occurs during the first week of treatment. Because there is no benefit in continuing the treatment after 1 week, another type of dressing should be used after 2 or 3 applications of MDT.
Trial Registration  clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT01211236

Related Stories

Researchers use maggots to heal diabetic wounds

Sep 27, 2011

(Medical Xpress) -- At the recent Interscience Conference on Anti-Microbial Agents and Chemotherapy, Dr. Lawrence Eron from the University of Hawaii presented his results on the use of maggots to heal diabetic ...

Bacteria toxic to wound-treating maggots

Feb 04, 2010

Bacteria that infect chronic wounds can be deadly to maggot 'biosurgeons' used to treat the lesions, show researchers writing in the journal Microbiology. The findings could lead to more effective treatment of wounds and th ...

Maggots make a comeback in Mexico

Mar 26, 2007

Doctors in Mexico are beginning to use a centuries-old and cost effective treatment for the healing of wounds -- maggot therapy.

Recommended for you

New malaria vaccine candidates identified

9 hours ago

Researchers have discovered new vaccine targets that could help in the battle against malaria. Taking a new, large-scale approach to this search, researchers tested a library of proteins from the Plasmodium fa ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

axemaster
not rated yet Dec 21, 2011
This really ought to be investigated further... for all we know, scientists could breed special "optimized" maggots that clean wounds even better than normal ones!
neulabs
not rated yet Dec 21, 2011
This really ought to be investigated further... for all we know, scientists could breed special "optimized" maggots that clean wounds even better than normal ones!


for sure we need special maggot for this, it for medical purpose
Pyle
1 / 5 (3) Dec 21, 2011
God's Gift Maggots!
Isaacsname
4 / 5 (1) Dec 21, 2011
I thought it was a common medical practice in antiquity.

Idk though,...a crawling sensation in the wounds ?

*shriek of terror*
Shifty0x88
not rated yet Dec 21, 2011
I thought they still use it in burn victims, simply because it won't take away any healthy flesh that may not have been burned, which helps to lower the number of skin grafts required to cover the person.

Maybe it is an outdated practice, but I thought it was still a viable solution.
SgntZim
not rated yet Dec 21, 2011
Nothing new in this. Prisoners in the Japanese POW camps used this method.
Telekinetic
not rated yet Dec 21, 2011
Thanks for the maggots, Doc. While I'm here, I'd like to have my blood drained by leeches.
HealingMindN
not rated yet Dec 22, 2011
Thanks for the maggots, Doc. While I'm here, I'd like to have my blood drained by leeches.


Since you mention it, medical leech therapy is yet another practice for painless drainage of bruises, contusions, and different swellings like gout, etc.
Pyle
not rated yet Dec 22, 2011
Ultimately I would think we would try to create a synthetic treatment that mimics the maggots and leeches, rather than actually using the little critters, be they sterile or not.

(I am shocked no body got the Skinny Puppy reference in my previous post.)
Msean1941
not rated yet Dec 22, 2011
Thanks for the maggots, Doc. While I'm here, I'd like to have my blood drained by leeches.


Aren't leeches used in situations such as reattachment of a finger due to their secretions that keep the blood from clotting?

LuckyBrandon
not rated yet Dec 23, 2011
hell this goes back a long long way....I was actually taught this in the Army over a decade ago as well.
But even if it works, I would rather take a few days longer to heal than to have maggots on me, period. Call it the germiphobe in me or whatever, but I personally could never allow it while awake.