Who's wealthy? Beyond net worth, asset and debt levels change our perceptions

By Divya Menon

(Medical Xpress) -- Will borrowing money to buy a new car make you feel richer? It depends on your net worth, says a new study in Psychological Science, a journal published by the Association for Psychological Science. “People’s perceptions of wealth vary not only as a function of their net worth, but also of the amount of assets and debt they have,” says Princeton University psychology graduate student Abigail B. Sussman, who wrote the study with Princeton professor Eldar Shafir. In fact, increasing your assets by taking on debt affects perceived wealth in opposite ways for people who are in the red (their debt outweighs their assets), or in the black (their assets outweigh their debt).

The studies recruited participants from the online platform Mechanical Turk. All were U.S. residents, average age 36, with average household incomes from $50,000 to $75,000. In six experiments, subjects considered pairs of financial profiles. In each pair, both profiles had equal positive or negative net worth, but one indicated lower and lower assets, while the other had relatively higher debt and assets. The first experiment tested perceptions: Participants were asked which person or household was financially better off. Whether shown brief, hypothetical descriptions or the detailed finances of actual households—including stocks, home values, student loans, and mortgages—the results were the same. When net worth was positive, more respondents called those with less debt wealthier than those with higher debt and more assets. By contrast, those in the red were perceived as wealthier when they had higher assets, even though accompanied by higher debt.

Do such perceptions lead to different decisions? Considering similar profile pairs, subjects were asked whether they’d borrow to buy something they couldn’t pay for outright—a luxury like a motorcycle or a necessity like bathroom repairs—or whether, as a loan officer, they’d lend to someone to do so. Again, positive-net-worth people with low debt and negative-net-worth people with high assets were more likely to borrow or be seen as credit worthy.

Why these fickle responses?  “People generally like assets and dislike debt, but they tend to focus more on one or the other depending on their net worth,” says Sussman.  “We find that if you have positive net worth, your attention is more likely to be drawn to debt, which stands out against the positive background.” On the other hand, “when things are bad, people find comfort in their , which get more attention.”

These findings challenge classical theories that net worth matters most in people’s feelings about their financial situations. And, says Sussman, understanding the nuances the study reveals can help predict economic behavior that otherwise appears puzzling.  A person deep in debt may borrow to buy a new car, while a person with positive net worth may skip the loan and the car.  And both are likely to feel wealthier for doing so.

Provided by American Psychiatric Association

4.3 /5 (3 votes)

Related Stories

Did watching television put Americans in debt?

Nov 18, 2011

A new study conducted by researchers at Hunter College reveals that the role of advertising in household consumption and debt may be greater than suggested by existing research. Drs. Matthew Baker and Lisa George (Economics) ...

Recommended for you

YouTube as peer support for severe mental illness

Oct 17, 2014

People with severe mental illness such as schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder or bipolar disorder use a popular social media website like YouTube to provide and receive naturally occurring peer support, Dartmouth researchers ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

drel
5 / 5 (2) Jan 10, 2012
"A person deep in debt may borrow to buy a new car, while a person with positive net worth may skip the loan and the car. And both are likely to feel wealthier for doing so."

Or is it that a person IS deep in debt BECAUSE they would borrow to buy a new car, while a person HAS a positive net worth BECAUSE they would skip the loan and the car?
antialias_physorg
5 / 5 (1) Jan 10, 2012
Will borrowing money to buy a new car make you feel richer?

Depends on how much at ease you feel at paying such a loan back (or whether you plan to pay it back at all).

In each pair, both profiles had equal positive or negative net worth, but one indicated lower debt and lower assets, while the other had relatively higher debt and assets.

Debt seems to be normal? Is this really so widespread?

A person deep in debt may borrow to buy a new car, while a person with positive net worth may skip the loan and the car. And both are likely to feel wealthier for doing so.

Seems like the basic observation that humans aren't good at making linear judgments. The difference between borrowing 100 or 1000 dollars seems significant to most - whereas the difference between borrowing 100100 dollars and 101000 dollars seems negligible.

In for a penny - in for a pound.
Xbw
2 / 5 (3) Jan 10, 2012
If debt = wealth, I am Donald Trump.
AWaB
5 / 5 (1) Jan 10, 2012
Or is it that a person IS deep in debt BECAUSE they would borrow to buy a new car, while a person HAS a positive net worth BECAUSE they would skip the loan and the car?


I think you're on to something, drel. I think many people, along w/ the researchers and article's author, fail to understand the correct cause-and-effect sequence.