Hearing metaphors activates brain regions involved in sensory experience

February 3, 2012 by Quinn Eastman

When a friend tells you she had a rough day, do you feel sandpaper under your fingers? The brain may be replaying sensory experiences to help understand common metaphors, new research suggests.

Linguists and have debated how much the that mediate direct sensory experience are involved in understanding . George Lakoff and Mark Johnson, in their landmark work 'Metaphors we live by', pointed out that our daily language is full of metaphors, some of which are so familiar (like "rough day") that they may not seem especially novel or striking. They argued that metaphor comprehension is grounded in our sensory and motor experiences.

New imaging research reveals that a region of the brain important for sensing texture through touch, the parietal operculum, is also activated when someone listens to a sentence with a textural metaphor. The same region is not activated when a similar sentence expressing the meaning of the metaphor is heard.

The results were published online this week in the journal Brain & Language.

"We see that metaphors are engaging the areas of the cerebral cortex involved in sensory responses even though the metaphors are quite familiar," says senior author Krish Sathian, MD, PhD, professor of neurology, rehabilitation medicine and psychology at Emory University. "This result illustrates how we draw upon sensory experiences to achieve understanding of metaphorical language."

Sathian is also medical director of the Center for Systems Imaging at Emory University School of Medicine and director of the Rehabilitation R&D Center of Excellence at the Atlanta Veterans Affairs Medical Center.

Seven college students who volunteered for the study were asked to listen to sentences containing textural metaphors as well as sentences that were matched for meaning and structure, and to press a button as soon as they understood each sentence. Blood flow in their brains was monitored by functional magnetic resonance imaging. On average, response to a sentence containing a metaphor took slightly longer (0.84 vs 0.63 seconds).

In a previous study, the researchers had already mapped out, for each of these individuals, which parts of the students' brains were involved in processing actual textures by touch and sight. This allowed them to establish with confidence the link within the brain between metaphors involving texture and the sensory experience of texture itself.

"Interestingly, visual cortical regions were not activated by textural metaphors, which fits with other evidence for the primacy of touch in texture perception," says research associate Simon Lacey, PhD, the first author of the paper.

The researchers did not find metaphor-specific differences in cortical regions well known to be involved in generating and processing language, such as Broca's or Wernicke's areas. However, this result doesn't rule out a role for these regions in processing metaphors, Sathian says.

Also, other neurologists have seen that injury to various areas of the brain can interfere with patients' understanding of metaphors.

"I don't think that there's only one area responsible for metaphor processing," Sathian says. "Actually, several recent lines of research indicate that engagement with abstract concepts is distributed around the brain."

"I think our research highlights the role of neural networks, rather than a single area of the brain, in these processes. What could be happening is that the brain is conducting an internal simulation as a way to understand the metaphor, and that's why the regions associated with touch get involved. This also demonstrates how complex processes involving symbols, such as appreciating a painting or understanding a metaphor, do not depend just on evolutionarily new parts of the brain, but also on adaptations of older parts of the brain."

Sathian's future plans include asking whether similar relationships exist for other senses, such as vision. The researchers also plan to probe whether magnetic stimulation of the brain in regions associated with sensory experience can interfere with understanding metaphors.

More information: S. Lacey, R. Stilla and K. Sathian. Metaphorically Feeling: Comprehending Textural Metaphors Activates Somatosensory Cortex. Brain & Lang. (2012).

Related Stories

To 'think outside the box', think outside the box

January 19, 2012

(Medical Xpress) -- Want to think outside the box? Try actually thinking outside of a box. In a study to be published in an upcoming issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, ...

Recommended for you

Surprising similarity in fly and mouse motion vision

July 29, 2015

At first glance, the eyes of mammals and those of insects do not seem to have much in common. However, a comparison of the neural circuits for detecting motion shows surprising parallels between flies and mice. Scientists ...

Research grasps how the brain plans gripping motion

July 28, 2015

With the results of a new study, neuroscientists have a firmer grasp on the way the brain formulates commands for the hand to grip an object. The advance could lead to improvements in future brain-computer interfaces that ...

New research rethinks how we grab and hold onto objects

July 28, 2015

It's been a long day. You open your fridge and grab a nice, cold beer. A pretty simple task, right? Wrong. While you're debating between an IPA and a lager, your nervous system is calculating a complex problem: how hard to ...

It don't mean a thing if the brain ain't got that swing

July 27, 2015

Like Duke Ellington's 1931 jazz standard, the human brain improvises while its rhythm section keeps up a steady beat. But when it comes to taking on intellectually challenging tasks, groups of neurons tune in to one another ...

5 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Cynical1
5 / 5 (1) Feb 03, 2012
What dies it mean when just about everything you see hear, touch or imagine, you consider a metaphor (for everthing ELSE)?
Tausch
5 / 5 (1) Feb 04, 2012
Yes.
Whatever association is needed:

To associate the following words;

'meaning' and 'understanding'

with - always in the final analysis -
another absolute word/sound association;

'physical' - The word, the sound(!), - a 'label' of science.

A twist of logic that the 'sound' of all languages ALWAYS self references the physical.

Extent Leonardo di ser Piero da Vinci Adage:

All perceptual is knowledge.

with...

All knowledge - for humans - is physical.

Careful - this has nothing to do with naive realism.

Kudos colleagues. Kudos C1.
kochevnik
not rated yet Feb 04, 2012
What dies it mean when just about everything you see hear, touch or imagine, you consider a metaphor (for everthing ELSE)?
Hardly for EVERYTHING. Rather, sensory modalities that integrate and spike neural net growth are metaphors. Behaviors and thoughts that increase bindings (white matter?) BETWEEN systems are ASSOCIATIONS.

Man takes the raw mental product of the physical sensory world and creates associative scaffolding to weave his persona. Or, in the case of religious lunatics, to copy the persona from other hiveminds.

This reality is mirrored in object oriented computer languages, with inheritance building metaphors while references build associations.
Cynical1
not rated yet Feb 05, 2012
I just meant to say that when I see a physical object, I build/see a metaphor that relates it to any number of other physical objects or actions or theories or thoughts.
Kinda like the "gyre" structures posited by Erik Andrulis. They are inherently fractal/ergodic and as such - metaphoric in nature.
Tausch
not rated yet Feb 05, 2012
Strange.

Sheer endless are the physical sources to support what we have come to label 'Consciousness' - in the broadest sense of the word.

Math is in it's infancy. Perfection can not be geometrical.
The physical is beyond perfection. You can see this belligerence and rebellion against perfection:

Symmetry breaking is the darling of all science.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.