Australian court defers ruling on tobacco packaging

Australian judges hearing a legal challenge to new laws requiring plain packaging for cigarettes deferred their decision Thursday until a later date, yet to be decided.

Four cigarette companies, led by British American (BAT), have contested the new law in a High hearing, claiming it infringes their by banning brands and trademarks from packets.

The government has said it is confident it will see off the challenge to the legislation, which will see all cigarettes sold in the same drab olive-green packets and graphic from December 1.

Chief judge Robert French said the court would retire to consider its position and return judgement in the closely-watched case at a future date. It was not clear when the decision could be expected.

Closing arguments in the case saw lawyers acting for Japan Tobacco International (JTI) producing a packet of in court, saying warnings for the toxic substance were modest compared with those planned for cigarettes.

Government lawyers had argued that the new laws were similar to the regulation of other such as rat-killer.

Australia is the first country to mandate plain-packaging, but the ground-breaking move is being closely watched by other countries considering similar approaches, including Britain and Canada.

New Zealand said Thursday it had agreed "in principal" to go ahead with laws mandating similar plain packaging, subject to public consultation later this year as part of a wider strategy to stamp out smoking in the country by 2025.

Canberra says its plan is aimed at reducing smoking-related deaths, but JTI, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Philip Morris have argued that it infringes their trademark rights.

Australia estimates it has 15,000 deaths each year from tobacco-related illnesses.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Australia takes on big tobacco firms in court

Apr 17, 2012

Australia said it was confident of seeing off a court challenge Tuesday by big tobacco firms over plain-packaging for cigarettes, in a test case being watched by governments around the world.

Philip Morris challenges plain packs in Australia

Dec 20, 2011

Global tobacco giant Philip Morris Tuesday stepped up its legal campaign against an Australian law banning logos and branding from cigarette packs, saying it had taken its case to the High Court.

Australia cigarette plan facing new legal threat

Jul 02, 2011

A second global tobacco giant has flagged legal action over Australia's plain packaging plan for cigarettes, warning of violations of its intellectual property rights, a report said Saturday.

Plain-packet cigarettes delayed in Australia

Nov 02, 2011

Australia's world-first plan for plain packaging on cigarettes has been delayed, giving tobacco firms extra time to prepare, the government said Wednesday, with the first sales now due in December 2012.

Recommended for you

Study: Americans endure unwanted care near death

10 hours ago

Americans suffer needless discomfort and undergo unwanted and costly care as they die, in part because of a medical system ruled by "perverse incentives" for aggressive care and not enough conversation about what people want, ...

Failed Medicare payments law remains relevant

11 hours ago

In a new commentary in the journal JAMA Surgery, Dr. Eli Adashi recounts what he and other advocates saw as merits of the originally bipartisan Sustainable Growth Rate Repeal and Medicare Provider Paymen ...

User comments