Combative Obama warns Supreme Court on health law

by Stephen Collinson

US President Barack Obama on Monday challenged the "unelected" Supreme Court not to take the "extraordinary" and "unprecedented" step of overturning his landmark health reform law.

Though Obama said he was confident the court would uphold the law, the centerpiece of his political legacy, he appeared to be previewing campaign trail arguments should the nine justices strike the legislation down.

In a highly combative salvo, Obama also staunchly defended the anchor of the law -- a requirement that all Americans buy health insurance -- as key to giving millions of people access to treatment for the first time.

"Ultimately, I am confident that the Supreme Court will not take what would be an unprecedented, extraordinary step of overturning a law that was passed by a strong majority of a democratically elected Congress," Obama said.

Pointed comments from Supreme Court justices last week during three days of compelling hearings have convinced many commentators that the court, expected to rule in June, will declare the law, dubbed ObamaCare, unconstitutional.

Such a move would electrify the White House race, puncture Obama's claims to be a reformer in the grand political tradition, and throw the US health care industry into chaos.

Obama noted that for years, conservatives had been arguing that the "unelected" Supreme Court should not adopt an activist approach by making rather than interpreting law, and held up the health legislation as an example.

"I am pretty confident that this court will recognize that and not take that step," Obama said during a press conference in the White House Rose Garden with the leaders of Canada and Mexico in his first comments on last week's hearings.

Obama's comments will be seen as a warning shot to the court, one of the three branches of the US government, and could draw complaints from critics that he is trying to influence the deliberations.

The health care case is the most closely watched Supreme Court deliberation since a divided bench handed the 2000 presidential election to George W. Bush over Al Gore, and could have far reaching political implications.

Obama also argued there was a "human element" to the health care battle, as well as legal and political dimensions.

He said that without the law, passed after a fierce battle with Republicans in 2010, several million children would not have health care, and millions more adults with pre-existing conditions would also be deprived of treatment.

Opponents of the health care law argue that the government has overreached its powers by requiring all Americans to purchase health insurance.

But supporters say that the government is within its rights to regulate the health industry as it has the power to oversee commerce across state borders.

Without the mandate, they say, the costs of insuring an extra 32 million Americans would be prohibitive to the private health insurance industry.

The Affordable Care Act is highly polarizing in US politics as the election approaches and Obama is yet to get a political dividend for the huge expenditure of political capital required to pass the legislation.

If the court upholds the law, and he wins reelection in November, the legislation will likely stand for years, as it will be fully implemented by 2014, two years before his second term draws to a close.

But Republicans running to replace him in the November 6 election have all vowed to repeal ObamaCare.

"I think it's important... to remind people that this is not an abstract argument," Obama said.

"The law that's already in place has already given 2.5 million young people health care that wouldn't otherwise have it.

"There are tens of thousands of adults with preexisting conditions who have health care right now because of this law."

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Obama defends health care, mum on court case

Mar 30, 2012

President Barack Obama defended his signature health care reform Friday, without discussing a Supreme Court case that could spell its end ahead of November's presidential elections.

US Supreme Court sets hearings on Obama health reform

Dec 19, 2011

The US Supreme Court will hear evidence challenging President Barack Obama's health care reform -- which has come under fire from Republicans -- over three days in March, a spokeswoman said Monday.

Obama asks Supreme Court to rule on health care

Sep 28, 2011

President Barack Obama's administration Wednesday asked the US Supreme Court to uphold his historic health care law, likely sparking an explosive legal showdown in the heat of the 2012 election.

Rejecting 'Obamacare' would be 'grave and profound'

Mar 25, 2012

Neal Katyal, who as acting US Solicitor General defended the constitutionality of President Barack Obama's flagship health reform in lower courts, has warned in an interview with AFP of "grave" and "profound" consequences ...

Recommended for you

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

210
1 / 5 (1) Apr 02, 2012
OH YEAH!!!! I post FIRST!! Let the fighting, snarling hate-filled posts BEGIN!!!!!

You go 'Bama' the man who got OSAMA and his Mama...!

word-to-ya-muthas
Smashin_Z_1885
1 / 5 (1) Apr 03, 2012
That sorry excuse for a president is full of BS!!! Because, the Democrats have been appointing liberal judges who have been making law by "un-elected process" for over 40 years now. So his argument is BULLSHIT !!! PURE BULLSHIT !!! He is not even an American. He is not even an African-American. He does NOT descend from Africans of American Descent. He hates our country and is TRYING TO DESTROY IT. . WAKE THE F*** UP DAMNIT!~!!
Smashin_Z_1885
1 / 5 (1) Apr 03, 2012
FURTHERMORE, in 1885 we would have NEVER accepted such tyranny within the government. It was corrupt, yes, but not like this, at all. I guess it just continues the parabolic curve, exponentially increasing in stupidity on one end, and exponentially increasing in power on the other end. I hope at least someone in this day understands the implications of this.
210
1 / 5 (1) Apr 03, 2012
That sorry excuse for a president is full of BS!!! Because, the Democrats have been appointing liberal judges who have been making law by "un-elected process" for over 40 years now. So his argument is BULLSHIT !!! PURE BULLSHIT !!! He is not even an American. He is not even an African-American. He does NOT descend from Africans of American Descent. He hates our country and is TRYING TO DESTROY IT. . WAKE THE F*** UP DAMNIT!~!!

Hey...HEYYY! Okay...so, just for the record....and let me get this straight, okay, just....work with me here, please. Am I to understand, and are you saying, you do not, NOT
like Democrats or Barack Obama...huh?

word-
JRDarby
not rated yet Apr 05, 2012
Smashin_Z, there is obviously nothing anyone can say to persuade you against the views you expressed, so I won't bother responding to what should otherwise be harshly rebuked.

As to Obama's comments, he's apparently forgotten, I don't know, everything he learned in Constitutional Law. How can you forget Marbury? Sheesh.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.