Soda wars fizz in New York after proposed ban

by Brigitte Dusseau

A soda war fizzed in New York on Tuesday as the city health department began to consider a proposal by health-conscious Mayor Michael Bloomberg to ban super-sized soft drinks.

Bloomberg's proposal on May 31 triggered a wave of reactions from the media, shop keepers, anti-obesity campaigners and New Yorkers who say they are tired of the mayor's alleged "nanny state" tendencies.

On Tuesday, a full page ad in the commuter free sheet Metro showed a 32 oz soda cup of the kind popular in and alongside this 26 packets of sugar. "Your kid just ate 26 packs of sugar," the ad stated, before warning that "sugary drinks can bring on obesity, and heart disease."

But in the same paper a letter from a home machine company denounced the threat of new rules. "New York doesn't need this legislation. Let the people choose." Meanwhile, advertisements in the subway trains herald the soft drinks industry's efforts to give consumers plenty of choice.

The mayor is accused, among other things, of hypocrisy, since he is against some like smoking and heavy drinking of , but supports eat-a-thons like the annual Coney Island hotdog competition.

Without going as far as those who call him a "big brother" or "super nanny," Coca Cola talks of an "arbitrary mandate" against big drinks, while McDonalds said it was a "misguided ban."

"His attack on this industry has been incredible," Rick J. Sampson, head of the New York state restaurant association, said.

Local NY1 television has done a poll that found 53 percent of residents opposed the ban, 42 percent were in support. More than half thought such a measure would do nothing to help combating obesity.

It's "a ban too far," The said in an editorial. "Too much nannying with a ban might well cause people to tune out."

Bloomberg is pressing his point home too. Almost daily his office issues statements of support from public figures and .

"Sugary drink consumption is a key driver of the obesity epidemic in the US and in New York. And it is an epidemic. Nearly 60 percent of adult New Yorkers and 40 percent of our children are overweight or obese," Bloomberg said. "Each year, an estimated 5,800 New Yorkers die because they are overweight or obese."

The prohibition, which would not need city council approval, would restrict soda drink servings to no more than 16 ounces. That's more than a normal can, but only half the size of the biggest, bucket-like container that patrons commonly guzzle from in cinemas, sports arenas and other outlets.

The measure would target fast-food and other restaurants, delis, and places of public entertainment like stadiums. It would not cover drinks sold in supermarkets, or any diet, fruit, dairy or alcoholic drinks.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

NY proposes ban on sale of oversized sodas (Update 3)

May 31, 2012

(AP) — New York City's mayor is proposing an unprecedented ban on the sale of large sodas and other sugary drinks in the hopes of combating obesity — an expansion of efforts to encourage healthy ...

Feds oppose ban on food stamps for sodas in NYC

Aug 20, 2011

(AP) -- A plan by New York City to combat obesity by restricting the purchase of sugary drinks with foods stamps would be too large and complex, federal officials said Friday.

NY seeks to ban sugary drinks from food stamp buys

Oct 07, 2010

(AP) -- New Yorkers on food stamps would not be allowed to spend them on sugar-sweetened drinks under an obesity-fighting proposal being floated by Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Gov. David Paterson.

Recommended for you

Preterm children's brains can catch up years later

15 hours ago

There's some good news for parents of preterm babies – latest research from the University of Adelaide shows that by the time they become teenagers, the brains of many preterm children can perform almost as well as those ...

Mortality rates increase due to extreme heat and cold

15 hours ago

Epidemiological studies have repeatedly shown that death rates rise in association with extremely hot weather. The heat wave in Western Europe in the summer of 2003, for example, resulted in about 22,000 extra deaths. A team ...

User comments