A story that doesn't hold up: Research casts doubt on key aspect of dissociative identity disorder
“Ultimately, this disorder is a way of expressing distress,” said Harvard Professor of Psychology Richard McNally. “What we have shown is that a fundamental idea behind the concept of DID — that there is amnesia between identities — there’s no convincing evidence for that.” Image: Kris Snibbe/Harvard Staff Photographer
Its one of the most common plot twists in Hollywood caught red-handed, the murderer claims to suffer from multiple personality disorder, says he has no memory of the crime, and points the finger at an alternate personality.
A new study, however, suggests such a scenario belongs strictly to the realm of fiction.
The study conducted by Harvards Richard J. McNally, Rafaele Huntjens of the University of Groningen, and Bruno Verschuere of the University of Amsterdam casts doubt on the amnesia barrier that has long been a hallmark of what is now called dissociative identity disorder (DID) by demonstrating that patients do have knowledge of their other identities. Huntjens was lead author of the study, which was reported in a paper published in PLoS ONE on July 17.
Ultimately, this disorder is a way of expressing distress, said McNally, a professor in the Department of Psychology. What we have shown is that a fundamental idea behind the concept of DID that there is amnesia between identities theres no convincing evidence for that.
About a century ago, Morton Prince, a Harvard-educated neurologist working in the Boston area, coined the phrase multiple personality disorder to describe the case of Sally Beauchamp, an Arlington woman who appeared to have two personalities.
Reports of DID, which is sometimes confused with schizophrenia, were rare in the 20th century, with only a few dozen cases appearing in the literature. With the publication of Sybil (1973), however, the condition entered the mainstream. The story of Sybil Dorsett, a woman who claimed to have as many as a dozen personalities, became an international sensation. There were two film adaptations.
Diagnoses of DID rose sharply through the next two decades. In addition to raising the public profile of the disorder, the book also marked the first suggestion that alternate personalities were created as a way to wall off traumatic memories of physical or sexual abuse, and that those memories could be recovered with the help of a therapist.
The idea at the time was that the mind locks these memories away, but with the help of a therapist, and through hypnosis or the use of drugs like Sodium Pentothal, these memories could become accessible, McNally said.
To understand whether there truly is an amnesia barrier between a DID patients identities, McNally and colleagues conceived a unique experiment.
Where earlier studies had simply asked questions, with no way to be sure the answers were truthful, the test described by McNally was intentionally designed to fool patients, making fakery nearly impossible.
Called a concealed information task, the tests goal is ostensibly simple: identify words as they flash on a computer screen. If one of a small set of randomly selected target words appears, press yes. For all other words, press no. The catch, McNally said, is that while many of the words hold no meaning for the patients, a small subset of the non-target words are taken from two autobiographical questionnaires patients fill out at the start of the test one while inhabiting one personality, the second in another.
When one of those personally relevant words such as a best friends name, favorite food, or favorite sport appears on screen, McNally said, most patients first impulse is to press the yes button. Within moments, however, they realize the word doesnt appear on the target list, and they eventually give the correct answer by pressing no.
Its that processing lag measured in milliseconds that demonstrates patients know a word is personally relevant, McNally said. If the amnesia between identities were real, that lag the time it takes to recognize a word, realize it is not on the target list, and press the correct button should all but disappear.
The results showed just the opposite.
As expected, the lag appeared for words that were relevant to the personality taking the test. All participants showed a nearly identical lag for words that were relevant to their alternate personalities, McNally said, suggesting that the information wasnt locked away in a separate identity.
For DID patients, the increase in reaction time was noticeable, McNally said. This shows that this information is leaking across the so-called amnesic barrier. The issue here is whether one identity is genuinely amnesic for information that is supposedly only accessible to the other identity, and the answer appears to be no.
McNally said that those who claim to be suffering from the disorder may be reacting more to cultural expectations than psychological realities.
For people who suffer from it, this disorder is ultimately a way to express distress, McNally said. Cultures provide certain envelopes for people to express suffering or psychological pain and DID is one such cultural trope. In the 19th century, women would do that by getting the vapors and swooning you dont see that anymore. Quite frankly, I dont think much would be lost if the diagnosis were eliminated from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual people will simply begin expressing their suffering in different ways that are more tractable to treatment.
More information: www.plosone.org/ar… pone.0040580
Journal reference: PLoS ONE
Provided by Harvard University
- Fragmented sleep, fragmented mind: A new theory of sleep disruption and dissociation Feb 14, 2012 | not rated yet | 0
- Is there a hidden bias against creativity? Nov 18, 2011 | not rated yet | 0
- Patients with disassociative identity disorder do remember separate identity Jul 25, 2012 | not rated yet | 0
- The kids are alright May 26, 2011 | not rated yet | 0
- When making meaning of the world, the brain is a multi-tasker Jan 23, 2012 | not rated yet | 0
- Motion perception revisited: High Phi effect challenges established motion perception assumptions Apr 23, 2013 | 3 / 5 (2) | 2
- Anything you can do I can do better: Neuromolecular foundations of the superiority illusion (Update) Apr 02, 2013 | 4.5 / 5 (11) | 5
- The visual system as economist: Neural resource allocation in visual adaptation Mar 30, 2013 | 5 / 5 (2) | 9
- Separate lives: Neuronal and organismal lifespans decoupled Mar 27, 2013 | 4.9 / 5 (8) | 0
- Sizing things up: The evolutionary neurobiology of scale invariance Feb 28, 2013 | 4.8 / 5 (10) | 14
Pressure-volume curve: Elastic Recoil Pressure don't make sense
May 18, 2013 From pressure-volume curve of the lung and chest wall (attached photo), I don't understand why would the elastic recoil pressure of the lung is...
If you became brain-dead, would you want them to pull the plug?
May 17, 2013 I'd want the rest of me to stay alive. Sure it's a lousy way to live but it beats being all-the-way dead. Maybe if I make it 20 years they'll...
MRI bill question
May 15, 2013 Dear PFers, The hospital gave us a $12k bill for one MRI (head with contrast). The people I talked to at the hospital tell me that they do not...
Ratio of Hydrogen of Oxygen in Dessicated Animal Protein
May 13, 2013 As an experiment, for the past few months I've been consuming at least one portion of Jell-O or unflavored Knox gelatin per day. I'm 64, in very...
Alcohol and acetaminophen
May 13, 2013 Edit: sorry for the typo in the title , can't edit I looked around on google quite a bit and it's very hard to find precise information on the...
Marie Curie's leukemia
May 13, 2013 Does anyone know what might be the cause of Marie Curie's cancer
- More from Physics Forums - Medical Sciences
More news stories
Patients with treatment-resistant major depression saw dramatic improvement in their illness after treatment with ketamine, an anesthetic, according to the largest ketamine clinical trial to-date led by researchers from the ...
Psychology & Psychiatry 20 hours ago | 4.8 / 5 (4) | 0 |
The latest makeover to a massive psychiatric tome honored by some, reviled by others and even called the "Bible" of mental disorders is being released Saturday with a host of new changes.
Psychology & Psychiatry May 18, 2013 | not rated yet | 1
(HealthDay)—Most Medicare beneficiaries treated in inpatient psychiatric facilities (IPFs) exhibit characteristics associated with hospital readmission, according to a report prepared for the National Association ...
Psychology & Psychiatry May 17, 2013 | not rated yet | 0
Skydivers show the same level of physical stress before every jump whether a first-timer or experienced jumper, say Northumbria researchers.
Psychology & Psychiatry May 17, 2013 | not rated yet | 0 |
Children of depressed parents pick up on their parents' sadness—whether mom or dad realizes their mood or not.
Psychology & Psychiatry May 17, 2013 | 4.5 / 5 (2) | 1 |
Researchers at the University of Wisconsin have identified a potential new risk factor for obstructive sleep apnea: asthma. Using data from the National Institutes of Health (Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute)-funded Wisconsin ...
7 hours ago | not rated yet | 0 |
In their quest to learn more about the variability of cells between and within tissues, biomedical scientists have devised tools capable of simultaneously measuring dozens of characteristics of individual ...
8 hours ago | 5 / 5 (2) | 0 |
Scientists at Johns Hopkins have turned their view of osteoarthritis (OA) inside out. Literally. Instead of seeing the painful degenerative disease as a problem primarily of the cartilage that cushions joints, ...
8 hours ago | 5 / 5 (3) | 0 |
A new study looking at sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) and markers for Alzheimer's disease (AD) risk in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and neuroimaging adds to the growing body of research linking the two.
8 hours ago | 5 / 5 (1) | 0 |
The hunt for an HIV vaccine has gobbled up $8 billion in the past decade, and the failure of the most recent efficacy trial has delivered yet another setback to 26 years of efforts.
12 hours ago | not rated yet | 0
Gourmands and foodies everywhere have long recognized ginger as a great way to add a little peppery zing to both sweet and savory dishes; now, a study from researchers at Columbia University shows purified components of the ...
7 hours ago | not rated yet | 0