When physicians report unfit drivers, crash rates go down, study shows

by Margarita Gallardo

(Medical Xpress)—Mandatory physician reporting of patients who may be medically unfit to drive led to a substantial decrease in serious road crashes, according to a new study from the School of Medicine and the University of Toronto.

"We found that these warnings are more powerful than warnings about smoking, diet and exercise, and about two times larger than the combined effects of modern at saving people's lives," said Donald Redelmeier, MD, professor of medicine at the University of Toronto and lead author of the study published in the Sept. 26 issue of the . Robert Tibshirani, PhD, professor of and policy and of statistics at Stanford, is a co-author.

For this study, Redelmeier, Tibshirani and their colleagues examined 100,075 in Ontario, Canada, over the age of 18 who received such medical warnings from over a four-year period from 2006-10. Their analysis indicated a 45 percent reduction in the risk of resulting in emergency department visits in the year following the warnings.

"The data suggest that practicing physicians may be able to help prevent serious trauma from road crashes," write the paper's authors. The results show, added Tibshirani, that "medical warnings about driving are taken seriously by patients."

An estimated 1.2 million people die from worldwide each year, and one-third of drivers involved in serious crashes suffer from a . Requirements that physicians report to authorities when a patient has a condition that may make driving hazardous were introduced in Ontario in 1968, and were enacted in 2006 to encourage physicians to report such drivers. (Physicians are paid $36.25 in Canadian dollars per warning.)

Mandatory reporting is also the law in six U.S. states including California, though the states' approaches vary in terms of disorders covered, legal protections for physicians and administrative requirements. In general, physicians must notify the department of motor vehicles, which then decides whether any action is needed. Such reports sometimes lead to licenses being revoked.

In the study, 95 percent of those patients who received warnings had at least one of the 20 most common diagnoses that may indicate problems with driving, and 21 percent had at least five of the diagnoses that justified a warning. Those diagnoses include alcoholism, epilepsy, dementia, stroke and sleep apnea.

The study showed a marked decrease in the number of car crashes as a result of the physicians' reports. Prior to warnings, the patients had a total of 1,430 crashes over a three-year period, averaging about 466 per year. In the year post-warnings, the rate dropped to about 273 road crashes. Redelmeier described the decrease as "immediate, profound and sustained," particularly among drivers who had multiple diagnoses.

The study also showed that medical warnings might be effective and also save money. "Road crashes are an enormous drain on the U.S. economy," said Redelmeier. "Perhaps about $200 million might be saved each year by the crashes prevented through physician warnings to patients about driving." (In Ontario, he estimates about $7 million is saved each year by preventing crashes.)

While medical warnings may potentially protect patients from road crashes, the researchers also found an associated increase in depression among the patients who had received the warnings, as well as fewer patient visits to the responsible physician. The changes amounted to about a 25 percent increase in the number of patient visits involving depression, and about a 30 percent reduction in return visits in the year after the warning.

Redelmeier emphasized that the patients' dissatisfaction around medical warnings "doesn't mean that doctors should stay silent about the situation. Physicians need to be sensitive, compassionate and prepared to address adverse consequences in the aftermath of a warning."

Related Stories

Fatal crashes fall among teen drivers

date Apr 07, 2011

Programs that create some common-sense restrictions when young drivers get behind the wheel have helped cut the rate of deadly crashes by more than half. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) looked at fatal ...

In defense of older drivers

date Apr 02, 2012

The notion that senior drivers have higher rates of crashes because they are poorer drivers is largely a misconception, according to a commentary in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).

Recommended for you

Research letter: Indoor tanning rates drop among US adults

date 36 minutes ago

Indoor tanning rates dropped among adults from 5.5 percent in 2010 to 4.2 percent in 2013, although an estimated 7.8 million women and 1.9 million men still engage in the practice, which has been linked to increased cancer ...

Stunting remains a challenge in South Africa

date 1 hour ago

Stunting remains stubbornly persistent in South Africa, despite economic growth, political and social transitions, and national nutritional programmes, says a Wits-led research team.

What's next for California's contentious vaccine law

date 12 hours ago

Gov. Jerry Brown on Tuesday signed a hotly contested California bill to impose one of the strictest school vaccination laws in the country in the wake of an outbreak of measles at Disneyland late last year.

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.