Homophobia in sport: Sporting identity, authoritarian aggression, and social dominance

Homophobia exists in many areas of life. It also seems to be particularly entrenched in sport, exercise and physical education (PE) settings of all kinds. But why is this the case?

To find out, an international trio of have become the first to examine the relationship between investment in physical/sporting identity, certain psychological attributes, and homophobia in PE/sport participants.

The authors, Kerry S. O'Brien, Heather Shovelton and Janet D. Latner, whose pioneering work appears in the International Journal of Psychology, had two goals in mind. First, they wanted to address the lack of quantitative work on homophobia in PE and sport settings. Second, they wanted to examine the role played by established sociological constructs in homophobia. Since other forms of bias such as racism are associated with conservative ideologies and such as authoritarianism and orientation (SDO - a preference for social hierarchies), the authors wanted to see whether such traits were also associated with homophobia.

Because heterosexual and physical identity are defined by physical attributes for both men and women (which and lesbians are often seen as threatening), the authors also explored the relationship between 'sporting identity and athletic self-concept related constructs' and homophobic attitudes. The authors posited that individuals who identify strongly as members of a physically oriented group (such as PE/sport ), place a high value on physical attributes, abilities and appearance (such as strength or skill), or have more conservative ideologies, or may hold more towards those whose beliefs and attitudes differ from their own.

The conclusions bore out the researchers' hypothesis: anti-gay and anti-lesbian prejudice was greater in PE students than non-PE students, and males had greater anti-gay, but not anti-lesbian, prejudice than females. The differences between the two groups appear to be explained by differences in the conservative psychological traits; higher scores for authoritarianism and SDO were significant predictors. In addition, physical identity and athletic attributes based around masculine ideals also appear related to prejudice in males.

The authors conclude that sport settings may benefit from 'prejudice reduction initiatives that address the overinvestment in and masculine ideas' and which reinforce social equality and diversity. Such initiatives also need to address the contextual and psychosocial factors that underpin homophobia. While there is of course no suggestion that sportiness itself encourages prejudice, the authors warn that the high levels of anti-gay and anti-lesbian sentiment they found 'may be due to the contextual influences that enhance or support the expression of homophobia'. In other words, prejudice can become entrenched in a group over time, in accordance with social identity theory (SIT).

The findings presented in this ground-breaking study provide vital new quantitative evidence to support qualitative and anecdotal reports that homophobia is higher in sport and PE than in other settings, making it essential reading for the educators, coaches and sporting professionals who must work together to root it out.

More information: O'Brien, K., et al., Homophobia in physical education and sport: The role of physical/sporting identity and attributes, authoritarian aggression, and social dominance orientation, International Journal of Psychology, DOI:10.1080/00207594.2012.713107

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

New study suggests gender gap around homophobic bullying

Apr 26, 2012

A new study from Educational and Psychological Measurement (published by SAGE) found that when it comes to homophobic bullying, there could be a gender gap. While male victims are more likely to be bullied by male homoph ...

Physiological impacts of homophobia

Feb 02, 2011

Young adults who are lesbian, gay or bisexual (LGB) are at far higher risk for severe mental health problems than their heterosexual peers. New research from Concordia University suggests that the stress of being rejected ...

Recommended for you

Bilingualism over the lifespan

1 hour ago

It's a scene that plays out every day in Montreal. On the bus, in schools, in the office and at home, conversations weave seamlessly back and forth between French and English, or one of the many other languages represented ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

freethinking
1 / 5 (3) Nov 20, 2012
Yes sports need more prejudice reduction initiatives. That way more boys can be made sensivitve to homosexual sex..

http://www.suntim...ual.html

Hey, we need prejudice reduction according to Jerry Sandusky according to him there is a lot of prejudice against men showering with and wrestling with little boys.

theskepticalpsychic
not rated yet Nov 20, 2012
The bonding and affection that members of male sports teams often feel with one another violates the Western cultural stereotype that the only feelings a macho guy has the right to feel are aggressiveness on the playing field and sexual attraction to women. So any time a sportsman feels affection for a guy, the unconscious assumption is that it is somehow erotically based, and that violates the taboo. And where else in Western culture do hetero males commonly take off their garments in one anothers' presence except in sports locker room contexts?
alfie_null
1 / 5 (1) Nov 21, 2012
Yes sports need more prejudice reduction initiatives. That way more boys can be made sensivitve to homosexual sex..

http://www.suntim...ual.html

Hey, we need prejudice reduction according to Jerry Sandusky according to him there is a lot of prejudice against men showering with and wrestling with little boys.

You are intentionally trying to confuse pederasty with homosexuality. Why? I've got a guess, but perhaps you can enlighten me further.
freethinking
1 / 5 (1) Nov 21, 2012
alfie, pederasty and homosexuality are linked. % of homosexuals who are pedophiles is much higher than % of heterosexuals. Also homosexual pedophiles have many more victims than heterosexuals.

Currently the media turn the other way when a homosexual teacher, public official, entertainer, etc is accused of pedophilia.
Eric_B
not rated yet Nov 26, 2012
all football players start out tight ends and end up wide-receivers.

there is a difference between homophobia and supporting the development of healthy hetrosexual relationships.

one major difference is that homophobia creates the closet in which the J.S.s of the world can hide their deeds while the victims hide their shame, too guilt tripped by the pseudo-freethinkers of the world to make accusations public.

same deal with male-against-male rape... why don't those crimes get reported, freestinker?