Court blocks California law banning gay therapy

by Lisa Leff

(AP)—A federal appeals court on Friday put the brakes on a first-of-its-kind California law that bans therapy aimed at turning gay minors straight.

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued an emergency order putting the law on hold until the court can hear full arguments on the measure's constitutionality. The law was set to take effect Jan. 1.

Licensed counselors who practice so-called "reparative therapy" and two families who say their teenage sons have benefited from it sought the injunction after a lower court judge refused the request.

The law, which was passed by the Legislature and signed by Gov. Jerry Brown this fall, states that therapists and counselors who use " change efforts" on clients under 18 would be engaging in and subject to discipline by state licensing boards.

The appeals court's order prevents the state from enforcing the law, SB1172, while a different three-judge panel considers if the measure violates the of therapists and parents.

Liberty Counsel President Mathew Staver, whose Christian legal aide group is representing reparative therapy practitioners and recipients in a lawsuit seeking to overturn the law, applauded the court's decision to grant his request to delay its implementation.

"This law is politically motivated to interfere with counselors and clients. Liberty Counsel is thankful that the 9th Circuit blocked the law from going into effect," Staver said. "This law is an astounding overreach by the government into the realm of counseling and would have caused irreparable harm."

Backers of the ban say the state is obligated to outlaw reparative therapy because the practice puts young people at risk and has been rejected by every mainstream mental health association. After signing SB1172, the governor called the therapies it would outlaw "quackery" that "have no basis in science or medicine."

Shannon Minter, legal director for the National Center for Lesbian Rights, which helped fight for the law's passage, said the measure's supporters shouldn't read too much into Friday's order.

"It's disappointing because there shouldn't even be a temporary delay of this law, but this is completely irrelevant to the final outcome," Minter said.

The brief order issued Friday did not explain the panel's thinking. The 9th Circuit has requested briefs on the case's broader constitutional issues but has not scheduled arguments.

"California was correct to outlaw this unsound and harmful practice, and the attorney general will vigorously defend this law," said Lynda Gledhill, press secretary to Attorney General Kamala Harris.

Earlier this month, two federal trial judges in California arrived at opposite conclusions on whether the law violates the Constitution.

On Dec. 4, U.S. District Judge Kimberly Mueller refused to block the law after concluding that the plaintiffs represented by Staver were unlikely to prove the ban on "conversion" therapy unfairly tramples on their civil rights and should therefore be overturned.

The opponents argued the law would make them liable for discipline if they merely recommended the therapy to patients or discuss it with them. Mueller said they didn't demonstrate that they were likely to win, so she wouldn't block the .

Mueller's decision came half a day after U.S. District Judge William Shubb handed down a somewhat competing ruling in a separate lawsuit filed by a psychiatrist, a licensed counselor and a former patient who is studying to practice gay conversion therapy.

Shubb said he found the First Amendment issues presented by the ban to be compelling. He ordered the state to temporarily exempt the three people named in the case before him.

3 /5 (2 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Backers aim to widen ban on gay conversion therapy (Update)

Oct 01, 2012

(AP)—Gay rights advocates are making plans to get other states to join California in banning psychotherapy aimed at making gay teenagers straight, even as opponents prepared Monday to sue to overturn the first law in the ...

Judge grants injunction vs new Mass. obscenity law

Oct 28, 2010

(AP) -- A federal judge has granted a preliminary injunction sought by free-speech advocates who argued that a new Massachusetts law aimed at protecting children from online sexual predators effectively bans from the Internet ...

US appeals court upholds Obama's health care law

Jun 29, 2011

A US federal appeals court in Ohio upheld the constitutionality of President Barack Obama's controversial health care law Wednesday in the first rejection of several challenges at the appeals court level.

Recommended for you

Uruguay opens bidding for marijuana plots

1 hour ago

Uruguay, the first country to fully legalize the production, sale and distribution of marijuana, called for bids Friday from private growers who want to farm cannabis in a public field.

Patient-centered medical homes reduce costs

19 hours ago

The patient-centered medical home (PCMH), introduced in 2007, is a model of health care that emphasizes personal relationships, team delivery of care, coordination across specialties and care settings, quality ...

New mums still excessively sleepy after four months

20 hours ago

(Medical Xpress)—New mums are being urged to be cautious about returning to work too quickly, after a QUT study found one in two were still excessively sleepy four months after giving birth.

It's time to address the health of men around the world

20 hours ago

All over the world, men die younger than women and do worse on a host of health indicators, yet policy makers rarely focus on this "men's health gap" or adopt programs aimed at addressing it, according to an international ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Tom_Hennessy
1.6 / 5 (7) Dec 22, 2012
The government had to take the LBGTQ's to court to stop them from running naked in the streets in Castro , California. That courtcase made most people aware of the mental illness rampant in the LBGTQ community and what will happen if allowed to have full reign of their true nature. People running naked in the streets.
rwinners
3 / 5 (1) Dec 23, 2012
Hmmm... do a search on Mathew Staver. That will fill you in.
rwinners
3 / 5 (1) Dec 23, 2012
Well, you can always use 'them' for target practice, Tom....

or simply avert your eyes....
Husky
5 / 5 (1) Dec 26, 2012
if reparative therapy is covered by obamacare and includes free champaigne and hookers, then where do I sign up?
zaxxon451
2 / 5 (4) Dec 27, 2012
This kind of "therapy", promoted by the ignorant, is simply a legal form of child abuse and should be banned in all states.
freethinking
1 / 5 (4) Dec 27, 2012
So the gay lobby is trying to stop people from leaving their lifestyle. So Progressives say that people can't change? So Progressives believe people cannot choose who to have sex with? They want to ban this and think this is child abuse, yet think it's ok to raise gender nutral kids, and allow and even encourage boys to wear dresses to school. Progressives think it's normal for some guys to want to cut off their penis so that they can call themselves women.

zaxxon451
4 / 5 (4) Dec 27, 2012
So the gay lobby is trying to stop people from leaving their lifestyle. So Progressives say that people can't change? So Progressives believe people cannot choose who to have sex with? They want to ban this and think this is child abuse, yet think it's ok to raise gender nutral kids, and allow and even encourage boys to wear dresses to school. Progressives think it's normal for some guys to want to cut off their penis so that they can call themselves women.



Were you trying for irony when you chose your username?
freethinking
1 / 5 (2) Dec 29, 2012
Freethinker, someone who does not repeat lies progressives keep repeating.
Freethinker, someone that doesn't kiss Obama and other progressives rear end.
Freethinker, someone who believes, prove all things.