Are kids who take music lessons different from other kids?

by Mark Witten
Are kids who take music lessons different from other kids?

(Medical Xpress)—Research by U of T Mississauga psychology professor Glenn Schellenberg reveals that two key personality traits – openness-to-experience and conscientiousness—predict better than IQ who will take music lessons and continue for longer periods.

Another intriguing finding is that when personality traits and like parents' education are considered, the link between cognitive ability and music training disappears.

Schellenberg's study calls into question the widely held view that music makes kids smarter. "The prevailing bias is that music training causes improvements in intelligence. But you can't infer causation simply because children with music training have higher IQs than children who haven't had music training," says Schellenberg, a specialist in the Department of Psychology.

The research paper, "Music training, cognition and personality," is published in a recent issue of Frontiers in Psychology.

Ever since a 1993 University of California study claimed that people performed better on tests of after listening to music composed by Mozart, the idea that music makes you smarter has been embedded in the public consciousness. Moms have been playing "Baby Mozart" CDs to give their kids an intellectual edge, and researchers have been studying and reporting positive associations between music and intelligence.

But Schellenberg's previous research has shown that the "" is a myth. People do just as well on spatial tests after listening to a narrated story as a Mozart sonata, and in both cases better than after sitting in silence. "Their performance is better because the music and story are more arousing and enjoyable, and the effect has little to do with Mozart in particular or music in general," he explains.

In this study, Schellenberg gave the theory that music training makes kids smarter a reality check by asking whether pre-existing differences in personality could explain why musically trained children have substantially higher IQs and perform better in school than other kids. "I wanted to stop this madness of making exaggerated claims about the intellectual benefits of music training," he says.

In separate groups of 167 10- to 12-year-olds and 118 university undergraduates, he looked at how individual differences in cognitive ability and personality predict who takes music lessons and for how long. The study measured the Big Five personality dimensions: openness-to-experience, conscientiousness, agreeableness, extraversion and neuroticism.

Among the children, openness-to-experience and conscientiousness predicted the likelihood of taking music lessons and persisting, while openness-to-experience was the best predictor of involvement in music lessons. Those personality traits also helped to explain why musically trained children tend to earn higher grades in school than peers without music training, and do better academically than would be expected from their IQ scores.

Among undergraduates, those with higher levels of openness-to-experience studied music longer during childhood and adolescence.

Schellenberg's findings highlight that there are significant pre-existing personality differences between kids who take music lessons and those who do not. "The differences in personality are at least as important as cognitive variables among adults, and even more important among children in predicting who is likely to take music lessons and for how long," he says.

His research raises questions about virtually all previously reported research correlations between music training and that failed to account for differences in . "Much previous research may have overestimated the effects of music training and underestimated the role of pre-existing differences between children who do and do not take music lessons," he says.

"Children who take may have relatively high levels of curiosity, motivation, persistence, concentration, selective attention, self-discipline and organization," says Schellenberg. While he acknowledges that may offer a slight cognitive benefit, he suggests that ambitious parents should not make kids learn a musical instrument solely for any expected intelligence benefits.

Learning a musical instrument is worthwhile for the musical skills and knowledge that a child will develop, and for the enjoyment of playing music. "Nobody says you need to study biology because it increases your reading ability. Like all the arts, music is one of those things that makes us human and is worth doing in its own right," says Schellenberg.

Related Stories

Feeling chills in response to music

Dec 07, 2010

Most people feel chills and shivers in response to music that thrills them, but some people feel these chills often and others feel them hardly at all. People who are particularly open to new experiences are most likely to ...

Major health benefits of music uncovered

Mar 28, 2013

(Medical Xpress)—In the first large-scale review of 400 research papers in the neurochemistry of music, a team led by Prof. Daniel J. Levitin of McGill University's Psychology Dept. has been able to show ...

Adolescents involved with music do better in school

Feb 10, 2009

A new study in the journal Social Science Quarterly reveals that music participation, defined as music lessons taken in or out of school and parents attending concerts with their children, has a positive effect on readin ...

Recommended for you

"Body recognition" compares with fingerprint ID

12 hours ago

(Medical Xpress)—University of Adelaide forensic anatomy researchers are making advances in the use of "body recognition" for criminal and missing persons cases, to help with identification when a face ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Tonya1026
not rated yet May 23, 2013
I'm not sure if I believe that kids are different but I do believe that having the exposure is extremely beneficial. I think it sets the stage for various types of learning.
Tonya Simmons
smartandsnazzykids.com

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.