Self-evaluation of menopausal symptoms underestimates true burden, study finds

Physicians should consider a more in-depth evaluation of their menopausal patients' symptoms, as current approaches might not accurately reflect the number of hot flashes and night sweats each woman experiences, a new University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine study finds.

Patients tend to underestimate how often they have hot flashes and night sweats, clinically known as (VMS), particularly if they suffer from anxiety, and overestimate nighttime VMS if they experience sleep disturbances, according to the study published today in the journal Menopause. New studies designed to treat VMS rely on patients reporting their symptoms, so improving their accuracy directly impacts patient care.

"We think physicians may want to consider probing deeper when evaluating their menopausal patients, to determine if anxiety or sleep problems might be influencing the way they perceive their VMS," said Rebecca Thurston, Ph.D., associate professor of and and director of the Women's Biobehavioral Health Laboratory at the University of Pittsburgh, the study's primary investigator. "Typically we use end-of-the-day and morning diaries to measure VMS, but these may not be the best approaches to testing how well our treatments reduce VMS, particularly if the treatments impact anxiety or sleep."

Dr. Thurston's study evaluated three different types of VMS reporting. Women were asked to either record their symptoms at the end of each day and in the morning upon waking, or to report their symptoms at the time of VMS occurrence. At the same time, their symptoms were monitored via a portable hot flash monitor worn around the waist that continuously measures skin conductance, a validated biological measure of hot flashes.

"We found that when women recorded their symptoms at the end of the day, they tended to underestimate the number of VMS they experienced, particularly if they were anxious. Conversely, when women woke up in the morning and were asked to recall how many VMS they had overnight, they tended to overestimate how many VMS they experienced, particularly if they had poor sleep," said Dr. Thurston. "These disparities are important because accurate measurement of VMS is instrumental to adequately testing treatment options.

Hot-flashes and night sweats are among the most common menopausal symptoms that women discuss with their doctors. Women with these symptoms visit their doctors more frequently than those who don't experience them.

"While very common in menopausal women, hot flashes and night sweats can disrupt a woman's quality of life significantly," added Dr. Thurston. "We are eager to develop new treatments for VMS. Women deserve a range of safe and effective treatment options for their VMS, and we are not there yet. In order to test new treatments, we need to be sure we are assessing a woman's VMS as accurately as possible."

The study is part of the Study of Women's Health Across the Nation (SWAN), a multisite, multiethnic, longitudinal study that aims to characterize biological and psychosocial changes during the menopausal transition. At their 10th annual visit for SWAN, a subset of women (25 African-American women and 27 white ) from the Pittsburgh site were invited to participate in this ancillary study.

These findings reveal:

  • End of the day and morning diaries may not precisely assess the number of VMS a woman is having;
  • Mood and sleep may impact the way a woman perceives and reports her VMS, and
  • Clinicians and researchers should consider assessing sleep and mood to better understand how a woman is experiencing her VMS.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

High blood pressure in pregnancy may spell hot flashes later

Apr 03, 2013

Women who have hypertensive diseases during pregnancy seem to be at higher risk of having troublesome hot flashes and night sweats at menopause, report researchers from the Netherlands in an article published online today ...

Hot flashes take heavier toll on women with HIV

Jul 03, 2013

Women with HIV are living longer, so more are entering menopause. As they do, they suffer more severe hot flashes than women without HIV, and their hot flashes take a heavier toll on their quality of life and daily functioning, ...

Hot flashes? Active days bring better nights

Mar 27, 2013

Getting a good night's sleep isn't always easy for women at menopause. Exercise may help, but women can have a tough time carving out leisure time for it. The good news from a study published online today in Menopause, the jo ...

Hot flashes can come back after SSRI

Oct 24, 2012

Hot flashes and night sweats can return after women stop using escitalopram—an antidepressant—to treat these menopause symptoms, according to a study published online this month in Menopause, the journal of the North ...

Hot flashes before menopause? It can happen

Jun 12, 2013

More than half of middle-aged women who still have regular cycles have hot flashes. Asian and Hispanic women are less likely to have them than white women, but compared with previous studies, the figures are surprisingly ...

Recommended for you

Lack of sleep increases risk of failure in school

2 hours ago

A new Swedish study shows that adolescents who suffer from sleep disturbance or habitual short sleep duration are less likely to succeed academically compared to those who enjoy a good night's sleep. The ...

Life, liberty, and the pursuit of healthcare?

2 hours ago

"Obamacare"—was signed into law in 2010 and promised the largest overhaul of the U.S. healthcare system since the 1960s. Designed to provide medical care to uninsured Americans, it has been widely decried ...

Health woes to worsen due to climate change, study warns

3 hours ago

(HealthDay)—Coupled with worldwide marches demanding action on climate change, a new study warns that rising temperatures and altered weather patterns in the United States may soon exacerbate many existing ...

User comments