Imaging may unlock new mental illness diagnosis options

by Adela Talbot

(Medical Xpress)—Imagine suffering from a mental illness and waiting up to a decade to get a proper diagnosis, all the while taking the wrong medications. This is an unfortunate reality for some patients suffering from bipolar disorder (BD) and major depressive disorder (MDD), said Dr. Elizabeth Osuch, a researcher at Western's Lawson Health Research Institute and a psychiatrist at the London Health Sciences Centre.

The problem is, diagnosis isn't an exact science, she noted, being heavily weighted on patient observation and history. BD and MDD are two commonly misdiagnosed disorders in psychiatry.

"The diagnostic criteria are inadequate for the task. They're not about pathophysiology – there's no lab tests, no imaging tests to test for these things," Osuch explained, noting psychiatrists mostly rely on set descriptions of ailments when diagnosing .

But, as with any medical condition, mental illnesses can sometimes present themselves differently, varying from patient to patient, so misdiagnosis is a frequent risk. That's where Osuch's work comes in.

In a recent test group of 30 young patients, 15 diagnosed with MDD and 15 with BD, Osuch found a biomarker in the brain of patients with BD. She imaged the brain with (MRI), looking for a region that corresponded with the bipolarity index, a diagnostic tool that encompasses varying degrees of BD.

The MRI tests revealed an activation of the putamen, a round structure at the base of the forebrain, which has a positive correlation with BD – and what could be the differentiating factor between BD and MDD.

"In young people, BD presents differently than in an older adult. Sometimes you see mixed states, so you can mistake BD for MDD," she said.

"The first thing you have to keep in mind is these illnesses present themselves in adolescents and young adults, and if someone is malfunctioning in their later high school and university years, that's messed up their life pretty seriously," Osuch continued.

This is why it is so important to get a proper diagnosis – the earlier the better – and treat the ailment appropriately from the start.

"If you treat somebody with MDD as if they have and you give them a mood stabilizer, when they need an antidepressant, you're overmedicating them and giving them adverse affects," Osuch said. The same is true when mistaking BD for MDD and prescribing an antidepressant.

Her recent study is unique in the field, as she is not looking at patient diagnoses or mood states of the individual, but instead at the dimensional aspects of the patients. She plans to continue this study with a larger sample group, looking for the same findings.

"We're looking for what really is going on here at the level of pathophysiology, to help better find these (diagnoses). What I published is one piece of the puzzle. The distinction (between BD and MDD) is really quite important and coming up with a better distinction would be great," Osuch said.

She added this is the ideal case scenario, and a possibility, in psychiatry, helping doctors to effectively and rapidly diagnose and treat patients.

"Looking to pathophysiology for diagnoses rather than descriptions would be great."

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

A better way of estimating blood loss

Mar 05, 2013

Research suggests that there may be a better way of measuring blood loss due to trauma than the current method, finds an article in BioMed Central's open access journal Critical Care. The study shows that base deficit (BD) i ...

Study: Many physicians not using established criteria

Feb 02, 2010

A new study led by Mark Zimmerman, MD, of Rhode Island Hospital indicates that a majority of non-psychiatrist physicians and a substantial minority of psychiatrists reported that they often do not use the criteria outlined ...

Recommended for you

Controlling childbirth pain tied to lower depression risk

5 hours ago

Controlling pain during childbirth and post delivery may reduce the risk of postpartum depression, writes Katherine Wisner, M.D., a Northwestern Medicine® perinatal psychiatrist, in a July 23 editorial in Anesthesia & An ...

How children categorize living things

15 hours ago

How would a child respond to this question? Would his or her list be full of relatives, animals from movies and books, or perhaps neighborhood pets? Would the poppies blooming on the front steps make the list or the oak tree ...

Preschoolers can reflect on what they don't know

15 hours ago

Contrary to previous assumptions, researchers find that preschoolers are able to gauge the strength of their memories and make decisions based on their self-assessments. The study findings are published in ...

User comments