Researcher says for 2-year-olds, touch screens may trump TV

by Hayley Kuepers
Credit: iStock Photo

(Medical Xpress)—Smartphones and tablets may be better learning tools for toddlers younger than 2 1/2 years old than "Sesame Street" and other educational TV programs, according to a researcher in the UW-Madison School of Human Ecology.

"Some of our research is starting to show that even a young 2-year-old might be able to learn from interactive screens," says Heather Kirkorian, assistant professor of human development and family studies. "Just as 'Sesame Street' has closed education gaps for low-income children during the preschool years, we might be able to benefit even younger if we can use interactive media in the same way."

Kirkorian conducts eye-tracking research to understand how children learn from screen media. Her research often takes place in a small room with a TV on a desk with small cameras in front of the TV and pointed at the viewer. The cameras record reflections off the cornea and retina, which track and register where the eyes look on the screen.

In some of Kirkorian's studies, children are watching "Sesame Street" and other shows to determine how viewers of different ages watch television. In other studies, children watch simple displays created in the lab, such as an adult hiding a sticker on a felt board—either on TV or in person. Later, the researchers ask the children to find the sticker.

Another focus of her research is on learning from interactive versus non-interactive video.

"We're using touch screens to manipulate whether kids just watch a video presentation or whether they have to interact with it in some way to see what happens next," Kirkorian says.

Kirkorian, who directs the Cognitive Development & Media Learning Lab, aims to link attention while kids are viewing to their subsequent learning. The questions specifically behind this research are: While a 2-year-old is watching a video, what are they looking at; and does that predict what they learn from that video?

Young children do not watch TV the same way that adults do, Kirkorian says.

"Adults are very systematic when they watch television. They look at the same thing as each other. That's a bit less true for 4-year-olds and very much less true for infants."

The video deficit, which Kirkorian defines as "a very robust phenomenon that until about 2 1/2 to 3 years of age, kids learn much less from video than a real-life demonstration," ties these two areas of research together.

"Even though my research is very basic, I'm addressing big research questions, so it's very applicable," Kirkorian says.

Her work has gained attention in the National Journal and The Atlantic, and a paper she co-authored, "The Effects of Background Television on the Toy Play Behavior of Very Young Children," was downloaded more than 3,000 times.

Media producers and educators are only two of the potential users of this research. "We hope that parents can use this research to decide whether, how, and how often they choose to use media in the home," Kirkorian says. "We also hope that policymakers might use this research to inform their decisions."

The effectiveness of her research relies on extensive interaction with and students, and for Kirkorian that is the best part of her job.

"One of the things that is most rewarding is just being able to work with kids in the lab and being able to see what they do," Kirkorian says. "It always becomes much more meaningful when research comes to life and you see what kids are actually doing. Related to that is working with students—both grad and undergrad—in my lab for the same reason. It allows me as an instructor to bring research to life for them."

Related Stories

Toddlers getting more tablet use, study finds

date Oct 28, 2013

The craze for tablets and smartphones is spreading to ever younger users. A new study of American households found 38 percent of toddlers and infants under the age of two have used a mobile device such as ...

Managing children's screen time: What parents need to know

date Oct 17, 2013

In our increasingly fast-paced world, the Internet, video games, smartphones and TV programs are continually competing for consumers' attention. But what are the effects of screen media on infants and young children, when ...

Recommended for you

Are our schools damaging children's eyes?

date Mar 24, 2015

Shockingly, research has shown a dramatic increase in the number of students leaving secondary school with short-sightedness, or myopia, and a new study published in the Journal Perspectives in Public Health, published by SAG ...

Vitamin D vital for gene expression in developing brains

date Mar 24, 2015

Vitamin D deficiency in mothers leading up to and during pregnancy has fundamental consequences for their offspring's brain development, researchers from University of Western Australia and the Telethon Kids ...

Chef-enhanced school meals increase healthy food consumption

date Mar 23, 2015

Schools collaborating with a professionally trained chef to improve the taste of healthy meals significantly increased students' fruit and vegetable consumption, according to a new study led by researchers from Harvard T.H. ...

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.