Some with Alzheimer's find care in far-off nations

by Denis D. Gray
In this photo taken Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2013, a Thai caretaker, right, consoles Elizabeth, an Alzheimer patient from Switzerland, at Baan Kamlangchay care center in Chiang Mai province, northern Thailand. Thailand is poised to attract more Alzheimer's sufferers from the Alpine country and elsewhere. In this pleasant city of Chiang Mai ringed by mountains "Baan Kamlangchay" will be followed by a $10 million dollar, holiday-like home scheduled to open before mid-2014 and a small Alzheimer's unit within a retirement community set on the grounds of a former four-star resort. (AP Photo/Apichart Weerawong)

Residents of this facility for people with Alzheimer's disease toss around a yellow ball and laugh under a cascade with their caregivers, in a swimming pool ringed by palm trees and wind chimes. Susanna Kuratli, once a painter of delicate oils, swims a lap and smiles.

Watching is her husband, Ulrich, who has a heart-rending decision: to leave his wife of 41 years in this facility 9,000 kilometers (5,600 miles) from home, or to bring her back to Switzerland.

Their homeland treats the elderly as well as any nation on Earth, but Ulrich Kuratli says the care here in northern Thailand is not only less expensive but more personal. In Switzerland, "You have a cold, old lady who gives you pills and tells you to go to bed," he says.

Kuratli and his family have given themselves six months to decide while the retired software developer lives alongside his 65-year-old wife in Baan Kamlangchay—"Home for Care from the Heart." Patients live in individual houses within a Thai community, are taken to local markets, temples and restaurants, and receive personal around-the-clock care. The monthly $3,800 cost is a third of what basic institutional care would cost in Switzerland.

Kuratli is not yet sure how he'll care for Susanna, who used to produce a popular annual calendar of her paintings. But he's leaning toward keeping her in Thailand.

"Sometimes I am jealous. My wife won't take my hand but when her Thai carer takes it, she is calm. She seems to be happy," he says. "When she sees me she starts to cry. Maybe she remembers how we were and understands, but can no longer find the words."

Relatives in Western nations are increasingly confronting Kuratli's dilemma as the number of Alzheimer's patients and costs rise, and the supply of qualified nurses and facilities struggles to keep up. Faraway countries are offering cheaper, and to some minds better, care for those suffering from the irreversible loss of memory.

The nascent trend is unnerving to some experts who say uprooting people with Alzheimer's will add to their sense of displacement and anxiety, though others say quality of care is more important than location. There's also some general uneasiness over the idea of sending ailing elderly people abroad: The German press has branded it "gerontological colonialism."

Germany is already sending several thousand sufferers, as well as the aged and otherwise ill, to Eastern Europe, Spain, Greece and Ukraine. Patients are even moving from Switzerland, which was ranked No. 1 in health care for the elderly this year in an index compiled by the elderly advocacy group HelpAge International and the U.N. Population Fund.

The Philippines is offering Americans care for $1,500 to $3,500 a month, well below U.S. rates. About 100 Americans are currently seeking care in the Philippines, says J.J. Reyes, who is planning a retirement community near Manila.

Facilities in Thailand also are preparing to attract more Alzheimer's sufferers. In Chiang Mai, a pleasant city ringed by mountains, Baan Kamlangchay will be followed by a $10 million, holiday-like home scheduled to open before mid-2014. Also on the way is a small Alzheimer's unit within a retirement community set on the grounds of a former four-star resort.

The U.K.-based Alzheimer's Disease International says there are more than 44 million Alzheimer's patients globally, and the figure is projected to triple to 135 million by 2050.

In this photo taken Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2013, Susanna Kuratli, 65, an Alzheimer patient from Switzerland, swims at Baan Khamlangchai care center in Chiang Mai province, northern Thailand. Thailand is poised to attract more Alzheimer's sufferers from the Alpine country and elsewhere. In this pleasant city of Chiang Mai ringed by mountains "Baan Kamlangchay" will be followed by a $10 million dollar, holiday-like home scheduled to open before mid-2014 and a small Alzheimer's unit within a retirement community set on the grounds of a former four-star resort. (AP Photo/Apichart Weerawong)

A number of European countries have generous national health insurance, but these generally do not cover treatment abroad. Kuratli says the Swiss government would cover two-thirds of the bill for his wife's care if she stays in Switzerland, but since high-end private clinics there can cost $15,000 or more per month, he could still end up paying more there than he would in Thailand.

Baan Kamlangchay was established by Martin Woodtli, a Swiss who spent four years in Thailand with the aid group Doctors Without Borders before returning home to care for his Alzheimer's-diagnosed mother.

He brought his mother to Chiang Mai, where she became the home's first "guest." Woodtli never uses the word "patient."

Over the next 10 years, the 52-year-old psychologist and social worker purchased or rented eight two-story houses where 13 Swiss and German patients now reside.

On most afternoons, the group gathers at a private, walled park to swim, snack and relax on deck chairs. Regular outside activities are organized because Woodtli believes these stimuli may help delay degeneration.

In this photo taken Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2013, Marc H. Dumur, a Swiss national and veteran hotelier who will manage a new Swiss-owned, 3.5-hectare (8.7-acre) resort-like facility for Alzheimer's patients, poses in front of the under construction main building of the $10-million care project in Chiang Mai province, northern Thailand. The project is scheduled to open before mid-2014 as Thailand is poised to attract more Alzheimer's sufferers from Switzerland and elsewhere. (AP Photo/Apichart Weerawong)

He says his guests "cannot explain it, but I think they feel part of a family, a community, and that is very important."

Sabine Jansen, head of Germany's Alzheimer Society, says that while some with Alzheimer's may adjust to an alien place, most find it difficult because they live in a world of earlier memories.

"They are better oriented in their own living places and communities," she says. "Friends, family members, neighbors can visit them. Also because of language and cultural reasons, it is best for most to stay in their home country."

Angela Lunde of the U.S.-based Mayo Clinic says that generally the afflicted do better in a familiar environment, but over time, even those with advanced stages of the disease can adjust well. "I think a positive transition has less to do with the move itself and more with the way in which the staff and new environment accommodates the person living with dementia," she says.

Woodtli says people who have traveled widely and are accustomed to change can probably adapt.

In this photo taken Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2013, Alzheimer patients from Switzerland are cared by Thai caretakers during afternoon activities at Baan Kamlangchay care center in Chiang Mai province, northern Thailand. Thailand is poised to attract more Alzheimer's sufferers from the Alpine country and elsewhere. In this pleasant city ringed by mountains "Baan Kamlangchay" will be followed by a $10 million dollar, holiday-like home scheduled to open before mid-2014 and a small Alzheimer's unit within a retirement community set on the grounds of a former four-star resort. (AP Photo/Apichart Weerawong)

"One of our guests sometimes wakes up in the morning and says, 'Where am I?' But she would do the same if she was in a care center in Switzerland," he says. "One guest thinks she is in a schoolhouse at Lake Lucerne."

At the swimming pool, Madeleine Buchmeier snaps photos and laughs as she watches a caregiver take her smiling husband's hands to twirl around together in a dance out of childhood.

"It's a miracle," she says. Geri used to bang his head against the walls of a care facility in Switzerland, she says, "as if he wanted to do something, get somewhere."

He would sink when entering water. In the three weeks since they arrived, he has calmed down and can swim again, all while his medicine is being sharply reduced.

Like Kuratli, Buchmeier is deciding whether her 64-year-old husband, a former Ford Motor Co. employee, should stay or go back to Switzerland.

In this photo taken Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2013, Ulrich Kuratli, right, talks with his wife, Susanna, center, an Alzheimer patient from Switzerland as she is escorted by a Thai caretaker, left, at Baan Kamlangchay care center in Chiang Mai province, northern Thailand. Thailand is poised to attract more Alzheimer's sufferers from the Alpine country and elsewhere. In this pleasant city of Chiang Mai ringed by mountains "Baan Kamlangchay'' will be followed by a $10 million dollar, holiday-like home scheduled to open before mid-2014 and a small Alzheimer's unit within a retirement community set on the grounds of a former four-star resort. (AP Photo/Apichart Weerawong)

Nearby, Manfred Schlaupitz, a former Daimler-Benz engineer in his 70s, lies back in a deck chair, cradling a stuffed toy lamb. His caregiver, Kanokkan Tasa, sits on the grass beside him, gently massaging his legs and tickling his chin. She has been with him for six years.

"If you think of it as a job it's very difficult," she says, "but if it comes from the heart, it is easy."

Like a number of Alzheimer's victims, Schlaupitz responds well to music. Sometimes they sing one of his favorite songs: "Yesterday."

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

For Alzheimer's caregivers, a much-needed break

Jun 07, 2013

(HealthDay)—Day care centers for people with Alzheimer's disease can give their spouses and other family caregivers a much needed source of stress relief, a new study suggests.

A third of US seniors die with dementia, study finds

Mar 19, 2013

(HealthDay)—There's more troubling news for America's aging population: A new report finds that one in every three seniors now dies while suffering from Alzheimer's or another form of dementia.

Recommended for you

Study links enzyme to Alzheimer's disease

Jul 21, 2014

Unclogging the body's protein disposal system may improve memory in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD), according to a study from scientists at Kyungpook National University in Korea published in The Jo ...

AAIC: A healthy lifestyle may deflect dementia

Jul 17, 2014

(HealthDay)—Seniors at risk for dementia may help safeguard their memory and ability to think by adopting a healthier lifestyle, a new study from Finland suggests. The study findings were presented this ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

katesisco
not rated yet Dec 30, 2013
Personal as opposed to place: let's look at the long term results. IS there improvement? Is there a plateau? If the stress is significantly less not only for the ill but for the families and for the caregiver in a unique setting? If it is less for all involved is this not a good thing?