$1,000-a-pill Sovaldi jolts US health care system (Update)

by Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar
This undated handout photo provided by Gilead Sciences shows the Hepatitis-C medication Sovaldi. Sovaldi, a new pill for hepatitis C, cures the liver-wasting disease in 9 of 10 patients, but treatment can cost more than $90,000. Leading medical societies recommend the drug and patients are clamoring for it. But insurance companies and state Medicaid programs are gagging on the price. In Oregon, officials propose to limit how many low-income patients can get it. (AP Photo/Gilead Sciences)

The latest pill for hepatitis C sounds like a difficult choice. Sovaldi cures the liver-wasting disease in 9 of 10 patients, but treatment can cost more than $90,000.

Leading medical societies recommend the drug as a first-line treatment, and patients are clamoring for it. But insurance companies and state Medicaid programs are gagging on the price. In Oregon, officials propose to limit how many low-income patients can get Sovaldi.

Yet if Sovaldi didn't exist, insurers would still be paying in the mid-to-high five figures to treat the most common kind of hepatitis C, a new pricing survey indicates. Some of the older alternatives involve more side effects, and are less likely to provide cures.

So what's a fair price?

The cost of this breakthrough drug is highlighting cracks in the U.S. health care system at a time of heightened budget concerns. The Obama administration has a huge political stake in controlling treatment costs, but its critics may cry rationing.

"People are going to want to try to dodge this hot potato," says economist Douglas Holtz-Eakin.

For insurers, there's a frustrating twist: For each middle-aged person they pay to cure with Sovaldi, any financial benefits from preventing liver failure are likely to accrue to Medicare, not to them.

More than 3 million Americans carry the hepatitis C virus, and many don't realize it. It's a public health concern since the disease can be transmitted by contact with infected blood, and sometimes through sexual activity. Health officials advise all baby boomers to get tested.

This undated handout photo provided by Gilead Sciences shows the Hepatitis-C medication Sovaldi. Sovaldi, a new pill for hepatitis C, cures the liver-wasting disease in 9 of 10 patients, but treatment can cost more than $90,000. Leading medical societies recommend the drug and patients are clamoring for it. But insurance companies and state Medicaid programs are gagging on the price. In Oregon, officials propose to limit how many low-income patients can get it. (AP Photo/Gilead Sciences)

The illness is complex, with distinct virus types requiring different treatments. While it progresses gradually, it can ultimately destroy the liver, and transplants average $577,000.

An estimated 15,000 people died from hepatitis C in the U.S. in 2007, when it surpassed AIDS as a cause of death.

"If it's going to get me the medicine, I'll put my hand out there with a tin cup," said Stuart Rose, a hepatitis C patient in New York City. His insurance would pay only $4,000 a year for medications, but Rose was able to get assistance from charitable foundations. He recently started taking Sovaldi.

Until the drug's approval late last year, standard treatment for the most common type of the disease required daily pills and extended use of interferon, an injection that can produce debilitating flu-like symptoms. "Brain fog," said Rose.

Taken once a day for 12 weeks, Sovaldi greatly reduces the length of interferon treatment, making things more tolerable for patients. Now, many more people might want to try the cure.

A similar drug, Olysio, also approved last year, is priced a bit lower.

The nation's largest care provider for chronic hepatitis C, the federal Veterans Administration, sees promise. With 175,000 patients, the VA has started more than 1,850 of them on Sovaldi.

"After 20 years in infectious diseases, I never thought we would be in a position to cure this disease," said Dr. David Ross, head of the VA's program.

By law, the VA gets drug discounts of over 40 percent. Will the agency break even by avoiding the disease's worst complications?

Not necessarily, said Ross. "If it leads to cost benefits in the long run, that's gravy."

Private insurers will probably introduce Sovaldi gradually. "Not everybody is going to get this all at once," said former Medicare administrator Mark McClellan.

Drug maker Gilead Sciences, Inc., reported Sovaldi sales of $2.3 billion worldwide in just the first three months of this year. Gilead will not disclose its pricing methods, but vice president Gregg Alton said the drug's high cure rate makes it "a real huge value."

In many countries, the government sets drug prices. In the US, insurers negotiate with drug companies. Medicare, the government health program for the elderly, is forbidden from bargaining, a situation that critics say saddles U.S. patients with high costs while subsidizing the rest of the world.

4.7 /5 (6 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Medical groups question price of new hep C drug

Mar 11, 2014

An innovative hepatitis C drug that was only recently hailed as a breakthrough treatment is facing skepticism from some health care experts, as they consider whether it is worth the $1,000-a-pill price set by manufacturer ...

Merck to pay $3.85B for hepatitis C drug developer

Jun 09, 2014

Merck & Co. will spend about $3.85 billion for Idenix Pharmaceuticals Inc., a small company developing hepatitis C medicines that, together with Merck's experimental drugs, could produce lucrative combo therapies ...

US approves breakthrough hepatitis C drug (Update)

Dec 06, 2013

U.S. health officials have approved a highly anticipated hepatitis C drug from Gilead Sciences Inc. that is expected to offer a faster, more palatable cure to millions of people infected with the liver-destroying virus.

Doctor details two new hepatitis C drugs

Dec 20, 2013

In the last three weeks, the Food and Drug Administration has approved two new drugs that are expected to dramatically improve treatment of chronic hepatitis C, a liver-damaging viral infection that afflicts more than 3.2 ...

Recommended for you

Seaweed menace may yield new medicines

11 hours ago

An invasive seaweed clogging up British coasts could be a blessing in disguise. University of Greenwich scientists have won a cash award to turn it into valuable compounds which can lead to new, life-saving drugs.

Supercomputers link proteins to drug side effects

Oct 20, 2014

New medications created by pharmaceutical companies have helped millions of Americans alleviate pain and suffering from their medical conditions. However, the drug creation process often misses many side ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Shootist
5 / 5 (1) Jun 17, 2014
treatment costs more that $90,000


Why?

Because it can.
eric_in_chicago
5 / 5 (1) Jun 17, 2014
It's the miracle of supply and demand.

If you would like a supply of this drug to save your life, I demand your life savings or f#ck off and die.
break_thru_99
5 / 5 (2) Jun 18, 2014
Medicare/medicaid should pick up the price of this medication. As a nurse who has worked in long term care for years and taken care of several Hep C positive residents I can attest that the price of simply taking care of these people at the end of their lives far exceeds the price of the treatment. On average I'd say they live at least a couple years past admission and all of their needs during that time are payed by the system to begin with.
alfie_null
3 / 5 (1) Jun 22, 2014
I wonder how many years remain of patent protection for this medicine? Before a generic version can be had. Maybe not many. Part of the high price has to be a reflection of the manufacturer's desire to amortize the cost of bringing it to market.
zaxxon451
5 / 5 (1) Jun 22, 2014
Greed is an ugly thing...
tekram
5 / 5 (1) Jun 22, 2014
This is not a complex chemical. Take the formula to India and it will drop in price by 100 fold ... and it is going to, according to wikipedia:

As of January 2014 Gilead was reported to be in discussions with several Indian generics manufacturers to make sofosbuvir available in India at a price below that of existing generic products.[30][31] The company has stated that it expects the price of treatment with sofosbuvir-based regimens to be in the "high hundreds to low thousands" in developing markets.[29]
http://en.wikiped...fosbuvir