Soldiers who kill in combat less likely to abuse alcohol

Soldiers who kill in combat less likely to abuse alcohol
New research coauthored by Kogod professor Cristel Russell shows that soldiers who kill in combat are less likely to abuse alcohol

It's no secret that combat experiences are highly stressful and can contribute to instances of post-traumatic stress disorder and depression among soldiers post-deployment. It also comes as no surprise that many soldiers afflicted with these conditions abuse alcohol in an attempt to self-medicate.

But new research coauthored by Cristel Russell, an associate professor of marketing with American University's Kogod School of Business, and researchers with the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research finds that the most traumatic of all combat experiences, killing, is less likely to lead to abuse.

The study, titled "Changes in Alcohol Use after Traumatic Experiences: The Impact of Combat on Army National Guardsmen" and published in the June issue of the journal Drug and Alcohol Dependence, runs contrary to previous research.

"We were very surprised by the findings. Most previous research supported the prediction that more would lead to more negative health outcomes, such as ," said Russell. "We found the opposite —that the most traumatic experiences of killing in combat actually led to a decrease in alcohol abuse post-deployment."

Mortality Salience

Why would killing in combat, thought to be one of the most difficult stressors, cause to become less likely to abuse alcohol?

Russell and her colleagues believe that killing experiences may cause soldiers to have an increased sense of mortality and vulnerability that triggers a focus on self-preservation, which manifests itself in reduced high-risk alcohol consumption.

"We reason that a possible explanation may be that soldiers who experience killing during combat become more aware of their own vulnerability to death. Mortality salience is known to have effects on decisions that people make including, in our case, the decision to not take risks and abuse alcohol, presumably to live longer," said Russell. "This is a post hoc explanation and our future research is going to try and explore this intriguing explanation further."

Comparing Pre-and-Post Deployment Data

The study is also one of the first to compare pre-and post- deployment data.

Russell and her colleagues used this approach to better identify the associations between different types of combat experiences and changes in alcohol consumption.

For the study, Russell and her fellow researchers surveyed 1,397 members of an Army National Guard Infantry Brigade Combat Team three months before and three months after their deployment to Iraq in 2005. Members of the unit completed anonymous surveys regarding behavioral health and alcohol use and, in the post-survey, the combat experiences they had during deployment.

Aside from the stunning revelation that soldiers who kill in combat are less likely to abuse alcohol post-deployment, survey results revealed that the prevalence of alcohol use increased from 70.8% pre-deployment to 80.5% post-deployment and that alcohol misuse more than doubled, increasing from 8.51% before deployment to 19.15% after deployment.

Next Steps

This study acknowledges that future research is needed on this complex topic. Russell and her colleagues plan to explore the influence has on soldiers who have killed while in combat in further detail.

"It is important for healthcare providers and researchers to better understand and account for the fact that do not necessarily result in a negative outcome and that positive outcomes can in fact be born from traumatic events," said Russell. "Building on these findings, future research should take into account the degree to which individuals are equipped to deal with stressful situations and assess how coping strategies may affect their behavioral response to potentially traumatic events. There may be ways to promote coping pre- or post-traumatic experiences."

More information: Paper: www.drugandalcoholdependence.c… (14)00779-0/abstract

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

UK military personnel at increased risk of violent offending

Mar 14, 2013

Most strikingly, the study found that the proportion of young servicemen (under 30 years old) with a conviction for violent offending was much higher than among men of a similar age in the general population (20.6% vs 6.7%).

Recommended for you

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

RobertKarlStonjek
1 / 5 (1) Jun 11, 2014
Fear of killing is a human instinct and extremely intense. It does not persist after a person kills. Soldiers often speak of feeling liberated after their first kill.

This can be compared to the tension that can build up when we hesitate even with a simple task like jumping off the diving board into the pool for the first time. Getting close many times but not actually doing it can build up the tension. getting in the water relieves it. Killing is magnitudes greater.
dsf2130
not rated yet Jun 11, 2014
I would also recommend reviewing our recent publication this month that shows based on Rotter's locus of control theory that persons scoring higher on "active exposure," defined as combat exposures soldiers reported related to being actively engaged in combat action (e.g., directing fire, clearing buildings, responsible for death of combatants) and appear akin to having a high internal locus of control, have lower likelihood of PTSD, although not alcohol misuse. There is more to be explored here, but I believe this hypothesis is reasonable given the other experiences that cluster with killing an enemy combatant.

Gallaway MS, Mitchell M, Fink DS et al. (2014). Combat exposure factors associated with the likelihood of behavioral and psychiatric issues. Military Behavioral Health, 2:2, 138-146
RobertKarlStonjek
not rated yet Jul 05, 2014
I suppose whoever gave me a 1/5 score would also score the well researched book 'On Killing' by Lt.col. Dave Grossman a 1/5 as well.

Reality really annoys some people.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.