Vaccination isn't just for kids – a guide for over-65s

by Raina Macintyre
More than 90% of kids are vaccinated compared with 74% of adults aged over 65 years. Credit: Shutterstock

We live in an ageing society, with the global median age rising steadily. Australia's economic viability will increasingly rely on retaining older people in the workforce for longer. This, of course, relies on keeping older people healthy into old age – and immunisation can play an important role.

Free vaccinations

The recommends Australians 65 years old and over be vaccinated against influenza and pneumococcal disease – common illnesses that pose a higher risk of complications and in . These vaccines are fully subsidised for over-65s and other high-risk groups.

Yet compared with children, who are also eligible for free vaccinations, elderly vaccination rates are low. More than 90% of children are vaccinated age appropriately compared with 74% of adults aged over 65 years.

This could be because doctors don't value vaccines for over-65s as highly as vaccines for children because older people have weaker immune responses and generally cannot respond as well to vaccines.

Weakening immunity

When babies are vaccinated, the immune system matures and strengthens with each dose. But the starts to decline around the age of 50.

Countering this progressive loss of immunity with vaccination requires novel approaches to boosting of immune responses. This can include giving extra doses, using adjuvants (extra substances) and using different modes of vaccine delivery such as injecting into the skin rather than the muscle, which stimulates a higher .

Despite weaker immunity, most vaccines still have significant benefit in older age. Recent research shows that even those with no immunity to pneumococcal vaccines can mount a robust immune response once vaccinated.

Unequal burden of disease

Older people have a far higher risk of contracting vaccine-preventable infections and severe complications than younger people. Influenza, (a common cause of pneumonia) and herpes zoster (shingles), for instance, are much more common in older age.

Other diseases such as whooping cough (pertussis) are now also causing illness and even death in older people.

Nursing homes and long-term residential facilities also suffer a disproportionate burden of severe outbreaks of infectious diseases such as gastroenteritis and influenza. Research shows that vaccinating nursing home residents is highly effective at preventing outbreaks. Yet vaccination rates are suboptimal, among both residents and staff.

There is also growing evidence that influenza vaccination prevents heart attacks, because infection is a risk factor for acute clotting and blockage of arteries. But again, many patients at risk of heart attacks are under-vaccinated.

Disease burden vs immune response

The impact of vaccines is not only a factor of immune response to the vaccines, but also to burden of disease.

If there are 100 cases of disease X in people aged 20 to 50 years, for example, and the vaccine is 90% effective, we could prevent 90 cases of disease. In contrast, if there are 1,000 cases of disease X in people aged over 65 years, but the is less effective in older adults – say 60% instead of 90% – we would be able to prevent 600 cases of disease.

In terms of population health benefit, then, it's better to vaccinate older people who have a higher burden of disease but reduced ability to respond to vaccines, than to vaccinate younger people who have a lower burden of disease and better ability to respond to vaccines: 600 cases prevented versus 90.

Because of this lower efficacy, health-care providers often dismiss vaccination for older people as worthless. But compared with other preventive health measures – such as statins for prevention of heart attacks, which are approximately 25% effective – most vaccines for over-65s are far more effective.

Ageism, ethics and value judgements

"Pneumonia is the old man's friend" is a common saying, laden with value judgement. This implies that old people shouldn't bother with treatment – or prevention. It also assumes have less rights to autonomy and self-determination, and that they are at the mercy of others when they are vulnerable and ill.

Research shows that people over 80, nursing homes residents and those with conditions such as dementia are less likely to get vaccinated. Yet these same people are likely to be admitted to hospital when they develop acute infections.

Prevention with vaccination is a better option than treatment after the event, from any perspective: cost-effectiveness, use of health-care resources, risk to others, and ethics. If we're serious about healthy ageing, we need to address the pervasive ageism in health care and ensure people of all ages have the opportunity to prevent illness through vaccination.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Fresh hope for preventing pneumonia in the elderly

Apr 24, 2014

There are calls for the frail and elderly not be be overlooked for vaccines against pneumonia this winter, with UNSW research challenging conventional wisdom on immunisation effectiveness in older patients.

Measles outbreaks underscore need for vaccination

Jun 16, 2014

With the number of measles cases in the United States hitting a 20-year high, pediatric infectious disease specialist Christina Hermos, MD, is frustrated by the "anti-science" movement against vaccination that underlies the ...

Explainer: What strains does the 2014 flu vaccine protect against?

Mar 17, 2014

Influenza affects up to 15% of adults and 30% of children each flu season and early indications suggest we could be facing a severe season. The 2014 seasonal influenza vaccination is available from today. So, what strains does it protect against and who should b ...

Recommended for you

Ebola death toll rises to 5,459: WHO

35 minutes ago

The World Health Organization said Friday that 5,459 people had so far died of Ebola out of a total 15,351 cases of infection in eight countries since late December 2013.

Flu season off to a slow start ... for now

3 hours ago

(HealthDay)—This year's flu season is off to a slow but detectable start. And it appears to be a typical one that's likely to peak in January or February, a leading U.S. health official says.

Update on new treatments for liver diseases

4 hours ago

Cirrhosis and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) are two serious liver conditions with limited pharmacological treatments. The December issues of AGA's journals—Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology and Gastro ...

Amateur photographers aid in remote skin sore trial

5 hours ago

Paediatric infectious disease specialists are bringing novel skin sore research methods to WA in the form of a protocol allowing non-professional photographers to capture high-quality images of skin sores ...

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.