'Prewashed' Salad Still Needs Cleaning

March 11, 2010
Salad greens

(PhysOrg.com) -- For people trying to get in their recommended daily servings of fruits and vegetables, prepackaged green salads are an easy way to start a meal. But there’s growing concern that these convenient items aren’t as ready to eat as advertised.

In an article in this month’s Consumer Reports, investigators at Consumers Union, publishers of the magazine, report finding high levels of certain bacteria in common brands of prepackaged salads.

Investigators had an outside lab test more than 200 containers from 16 brands of prepackaged salad greens sold in New York, New Jersey and Connecticut last summer.

They assessed for several types of "indicator bacteria” that can serve as indicators of and inadequate sanitation.

The test found no evidence of three , including E. coli and salmonella, which have resulted in foodborne illness. But they did find that 39 percent of samples exceeded an "unacceptable level” for total coliforms and 23 percent for enterococcus, bacteria often found in the digestive tract of humans and other animals.

Among other findings, the report found that produce labeled "organic” was just as likely to have high levels of bacteria as other samples. Consumers Union scientists report that the indicator bacteria generally do not make healthy people sick, but are advocating for stricter produce safety standards from the .

According to University of Cincinnati (UC) associate clinical professor of nutritional sciences Rebecca Smith, MEd, RD, it’s not unusual to have bacteria on all kinds of produce, which is why it’s so important to wash all produce before you eat it.

"I think most consumers get a false sense of security when they buy packaged, prewashed salad greens and other vegetables because they believe prewashing removes all contaminants,” she says.

Smith says the bacteria found in the Consumers Union test can come from several sources, including farm workers who don’t have access to adequate bathroom facilities or runoff from streams and other water sources on the fields.

Though greens and other produce grown close to the ground would be more susceptible to water runoff contamination, Smith says any or vegetable can be contaminated during the packaging process, either from human contact or improperly cleaned equipment.

Transportation of the produce can also result in increased bacterial growth.

"Although bagged salad greens are kept refrigerated during transportation, storage and display in the supermarket, the bags provide a moist environment where bacteria can multiply. If the bagged salad is not held at below 40 degrees F, the bacteria will multiply even in a refrigerated environment,” she says.

"Most of the emphasis on food safety, until recently, has been placed on meat, poultry and dairy products,” says Smith. "However, the majority of the recent national outbreaks of foodborne illness have been caused by fruits and vegetables, because they aren’t as carefully regulated.”

But that doesn’t mean you should eliminate salads and greens from your diet. Smith said washing fruits and vegetables before use can not only reduce pesticide contamination from conventional produce, but also contamination from microorganisms that cause foodborne illness.

She says there are several rules for everyone to keep in mind to reduce exposure to :

• Wash all fresh fruits and before using them, even prepackaged items and produce with skins that are not eaten. This includes produce from supermarkets and from local farmers’ markets.

• Buy packages far from their use-by date and keep greens refrigerated.

• Prevent cross-contamination by keeping all produce away from raw meat and poultry. Use different cutting boards and utensils when preparing produced and raw meat.

Related Stories

Recommended for you

Vitamin D supplements could help pain management

May 23, 2017

Vitamin D supplementation combined with good sleeping habits may help manage pain-related diseases. This paper published in the Journal of Endocrinology, reviews published research on the relationship between vitamin D levels, ...

Recommended daily protein intake too low for the elderly

May 23, 2017

You can find the recommended dietary allowance (RDA) on the nutrition labels of all your processed food. Food manufacturers are obliged to list the nutritional value of their products, and therefore must mention the percent ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Mar 11, 2010
If pre-washing is not perfectly effective then why would post-washing be any more effective?

Practicing some post-modern form of 'kosher' is ignorant. Either keeping kosher is effective or it is not. Maybe Moses was correct.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 11, 2010
This article assumes washing is effective. What constitutes adequate washing, a rinse under a tap or a 5 mins scrub with a brush. We are not told.

Other research indicates that children who play with soil have stronger immune systems.
not rated yet Mar 11, 2010
Yeah really. How do you wash broccoli? I think machines could do a better job of it than me.
IRRADIATE EVERYTHING. Then we won't have to worry will we?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.