Collagenase for Dupuytren's contracture: Added benefit not proven

July 12, 2012

Collagenase extracted from Clostridium histolyticum (trade name: Xiapex) was approved in the beginning of 2011 for the treatment of people with Dupuytren's contracture. In an early benefit assessment pursuant to the "Act on the Reform of the Market for Medicinal Products" (AMNOG), the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) examined whether collagenase offers an added benefit in comparison with conventional regimens. However, such an added benefit cannot be inferred from the dossier, as the drug manufacturer presented either no data or unsuitable data.

Collagenase is to break down thickened connective tissue fibres

Dupuytren's contracture is a disorder of the hand in which fibres in the palmar side of the hand (fasciae) thicken and harden. As a result, one or several fingers become permanently bent and can no longer be straightened. Collagenase is injected into the to break down the thickened connective tissue fibres. One day later, the rupture of these fibres through passive digital extension is attempted in order to restore the stretching ability of the affected finger.

G-BA specifies different comparator therapies depending on disease stage

When specifying the appropriate comparator therapy, the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) assumed that the choice of (conventional) treatment depends on how severely the function of the fingers and hand is impaired.

Hence, the G-BA stipulates four treatment alternatives and assigns them to different disease stages. The appropriate comparator therapies are specified as follows:

  • no treatment" in stage N, where no contracture yet exists;
  • percutaneous needle fasciotomy" (PNF), a minimally , in stages N/I, I and II;
  • partial fasciectomy" (PF), of the hand, in stages III and IV.

If PF is not suitable for advanced-stage patients, a PNF can be performed.

No assessment performed for three of four possible comparisons

However, the manufacturer deviated from the G-BA's specifications and chose PF as a comparator therapy for the whole indication. IQWiG regards this deviation to be insufficiently justified.

Regarding the G-BA's first, second and fourth research questions (patients with stage N, stages N/I, I and II, as well as patients with advanced stages for whom PF is not an option), the manufacturer neither performed any assessment nor indicated studies for such comparisons in the study list.

An added benefit for these three sub-indications is thus not proven.

Requirements for an indirect comparison not fulfilled

For the third research question (patients with stage III or IV without contraindications for PF), the manufacturer met the G-BA's specifications in the submitted dossier, choosing PF as the comparator therapy. However, there is no study available that directly compares PF and collagenase. As an alternative, the manufacturer presented data from an indirect comparison.

The legal ordinance on AMNOG explicitly allows for the option that added benefit may also be proven by means of such indirect comparisons. However, certain preconditions apply here, which the manufacturer did not fulfil. Due to a lack of suitable data, an added benefit is therefore not proven for this research question either.

G-BA decides on the extent of added benefit

The procedure for inferring the overall conclusion on the extent of added benefit is a proposal from IQWiG. The G-BA, which has opened a formal commenting procedure, decides on the extent of added benefit.

Explore further: Added benefit of linagliptin is not proven

Related Stories

Added benefit of linagliptin is not proven

January 6, 2012
Linagliptin (trade name: Trajenta) has been approved since August 2011 to improve blood glucose control ("glycaemic control") in adults with type 2 diabetes mellitus whose elevated blood glucose levels are inadequately controlled ...

Abiraterone: Indication of considerable added benefit in certain patients

January 6, 2012
Abiraterone (trade name: Zytiga) has been approved since September 2011 for men with metastatic prostate cancer that is no longer responsive to hormone therapy and progresses further during or after therapy with the cytostatic ...

Cabazitaxel can offer an advantage in certain patients

May 29, 2012
Cabazitaxel (trade name: Jevtana) has been approved since March 2011 in men with metastatic prostate cancer who no longer respond to conventional therapy with hormone blockers and have already been pre-treated with the cytostatic ...

Ticagrelor: Considerable added benefit for specific patients

October 11, 2011
Since the start of 2011, the active ingredient ticagrelor can be prescribed in Germany in addition to acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) to avoid blood clots in patients with acute ischaemia of the cardiac muscle. The German Institute ...

Fingolimod: 'Hint' of advantages in a small group of patients

July 5, 2012
The immunosuppressive drug fingolimod (trade name: Gilenya) is approved for the treatment of highly-active relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) in adults. In an early benefit assessment pursuant to "Act on the Reform ...

Pirfenidone: Extent of added benefit assessed

January 3, 2012
Pirfenidone inhibits the development of inflammation and scarring (fibrosis) in pulmonary tissue and has been approved for the treatment of mild to moderate idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) since the beginning of 2011. ...

Recommended for you

Four simple tests could help GPs spot pneumonia and reduce unnecessary antibiotics

November 23, 2017
Testing for fever, high pulse rate, crackly breath sounds, and low oxygen levels could be key to helping GPs distinguish pneumonia from less serious infections, according to a large study published in the European Respiratory ...

New approach to tracking how deadly 'superbugs' travel could slow their spread

November 22, 2017
Killer bacteria - ones that have out-evolved our best antibiotics—may not go away anytime soon. But a new approach to tracking their spread could eventually give us a fighting chance to keep their death toll down.

Research points to diagnostic test for top cause of liver transplant in kids

November 22, 2017
Biliary atresia is the most common cause of liver transplants for children in the United States. Now researchers report in Science Translational Medicine finding a strong biomarker candidate that could be used for earlier ...

Metabolites altered in chronic kidney disease

November 22, 2017
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) affects 1 in 7 people in the United States, according to the U.S. National Institute of Diabetes & Digestive & Kidney Diseases (NIDDK). These individuals have a very high risk of cardiovascular ...

Rainfall can indicate that mosquito-borne epidemics will occur weeks later

November 22, 2017
A new study demonstrates that outbreaks of mosquito-borne viruses Zika and Chikungunya generally occur about three weeks after heavy rainfall.Researchers also found that Chikungunya will predominate over Zika when both circulate ...

Alcohol consumption and metabolic factors act together to increase the risk of severe liver disease

November 22, 2017
A new study provides insights into the interaction between alcohol consumption and metabolic factors in predicting severe liver disease in the general population. The findings, which are published in Hepatology, indicate ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.