Using songs and shame to restore India's gender balance

July 25, 2012 by Ammu Kannampilly

The no-frills maternity ward in Nawanshahr district public hospital offers a rare sight in India; parents cooing over newborn girls -- lots of them.

In 2004, Nawanshahr in the northern state of Punjab was notorious for its abysmal sex ratio, recording just 795 for every 1,000 annually.

The last eight years have witnessed a radical turnaround with Nawanshahr recording 949 female births for every 1,000 male births in 2011, just shy of the naturally occurring rate of 952:1,000.

The striking success in restoring the gender balance has been built on a twin-pronged strategy of strict -- and, some critics argue, intrusive -- monitoring of pregnancies and a colourful, grassroots awareness-raising campaign.

As a first step in 2005, the district's top , Krishan Kumar, pushed a crackdown on pre-natal sex determination tests which are illegal in India but widely available given the prevalence of .

In two years, nearly two-thirds of all ultrasound scan centres in Nawanshahr were shut down or forced to suspend operations for violating the law.

In three instances, officials ran sting operations in which doctors were filmed on hidden camera offering sex-selection procedures to pregnant women posing as patients.

The cases are currently under trial.

Traditionally, married women in India have faced huge pressure to produce male heirs who are seen as breadwinners, family leaders and carers when parents age.

The development of cheap, mobile, ultrasound equipment -- now available in even remote villages -- saw this manifest itself in a surge in the abortion of female foetuses, or "female foeticide."

Alarming census figures released last year showed new-born girls had never been so outnumbered by boys in India since independence in 1947.

As well as targetting illicit ultrasound testing, officials in Nawanshahr also employ pressure tactics against expectant parents, creating a computerized database to keep track of pregnancies.

Health workers go door-to-door recording new pregnancies and return around the scheduled date of delivery to check on the outcome.

If the family refuses to answer questions or says the woman miscarried, officials make enquiries locally to establish if the foetus was aborted because it was female.

Jaspal Singh Gidda, who heads the Upkar Coordination Society, a local NGO which works with the district administration, said the aim was to publicly shame couples who opt for abortions on gender grounds.

Twice, when officials uncovered evidence of sex-selective abortions, Gidda and other Upkar volunteers held a day-long ceremony outside the family's home to mourn the lost foetus.

"We help generate community pressure against female foeticide by doing all this," Gidda said.

-- Unethical tactics? --

Nawanshahr's success has brought it national attention, but some activists are unsure that the means justify the end.

Prominent Indian anti-sex selection campaigner Sabu George sees an uncomfortable level of coercion that amounts to "a gross violation of privacy."

"The administration has good intentions but their tactics are totally unethical, totally wrong," George told AFP.

"They have heaped tremendous pressure on women, who already face terrible pressure from their families," he said.

But doctors like Usha Kiran, who works in the maternity ward of the district hospital, argue that firm intervention is the only way forward.

"Unless the government steps in people won't change. Otherwise those who wanted sons would have just continued to get scans done and practise sex selection," Kiran said, as she checked on her new mothers and infants.

"Earlier people used to come here and say, 'we want a son'.

"No one has come to me recently and said they want a son. These days I deliver as many female as male babies," she said.

--- A 'flood' of boys --

Upkar's Gidda said the birth sex ratio in Nawanshahr had become so dramatically skewed by 2004, that urgent action yielding tangible short-term results had to be adopted.

"The destruction had already hit us by then -- it was like a flood, like a natural disaster. By the time we woke up, we had to make a real effort," he said.

At the same time, longer-term awareness-raising programmes have also been introduced to spread the anti-foeticide message at the grassroots level.

A recent Sunday morning saw around 50 Upkar volunteers descend on the small village of Jasso Majara, singing songs with lyrics such as: "Daughters are born to rule, not to be slaughtered" and "Don't murder unborn girls".

As the group walked past green sugarcane fields, with little boys and girls carrying banners against the aborting of female , sleepy villagers emerged in the dawn light to watch the procession pass by.

Some joined in, while others watched quietly, cleaning their teeth while sitting on the doorsteps of their homes.

In Kiran's maternity ward, there is substantial evidence that traditional mindsets are being changed, not just in terms of the growing numbers of girl infants but also in the obvious joy they bring.

"I am just thrilled...there is nothing sons can give you which daughters can't," said new grandmother Ranjit Kaur as she cradled her two-day-old granddaughter Gudiya.

Pooja Dheer, a 24-year-old graduate student expecting her first child in August said no one in her family was concerned over whether she will give birth to a boy or a girl.

"They are both equal. Girls can work, they can do anything," she said firmly.

"A woman should be given every right to have a daughter."

Explore further: Significantly more boys born to Indian mothers in Canada than to Canadian-born mothers

Related Stories

Significantly more boys born to Indian mothers in Canada than to Canadian-born mothers

April 16, 2012
Mothers born in India but living in Canada are significantly more likely to have male babies for their second and third births compared with women in Canada, found a new study of male:female ratios in CMAJ (Canadian Medical ...

Ultrasounds worsen Asia women shortage: UN

October 6, 2011
Increased access to technology that allows parents to know the sex of their foetus has left Asia short of 117 million women, mostly in China and India, the UN said Thursday.

Abortion curb restores birth sex ratio in Taiwan

January 31, 2012
Taiwanese health authorities said Tuesday that tougher checks on illegal gender-selective abortions prevented nearly 1,000 terminations of female foetuses last year.

Recommended for you

One in five patients report discrimination in health care

December 14, 2017
Almost one in five older patients with a chronic disease reported experiencing health care discrimination of one type or another in a large national survey that asked about their daily experiences of discrimination between ...

Your pets can't put your aging on 'paws'

December 14, 2017
(HealthDay)—In a finding that's sure to ruffle some fur and feathers, scientists report that having a pet doesn't fend off age-related declines in physical or mental health.

Searching for a link between achy joints and rainy weather in a flood of data, researchers come up dry

December 13, 2017
Rainy weather has long been blamed for achy joints. Unjustly so, according to new research from Harvard Medical School. The analysis, published Dec. 13 in BMJ, found no relationship between rainfall and joint or back pain.

Mistletoe and (a large) wine: Seven-fold increase in wine glass size over 300 years

December 13, 2017
Our Georgian and Victorian ancestors probably celebrated Christmas with more modest wine consumption than we do today - if the size of their wine glasses are anything to go by. Researchers at the University of Cambridge have ...

How well can digital assistants answer questions on sex?

December 13, 2017
Google laptop searches seem to be better at finding quality online sexual health advice than digital assistants on smartphones, find experts in the Christmas issue of The BMJ.

Healthy eating linked to kids' happiness

December 13, 2017
Healthy eating is associated with better self-esteem and fewer emotional and peer problems, such as having fewer friends or being picked on or bullied, in children regardless of body weight, according to a study published ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.