Why are asthma rates higher among children now than in the past?

November 12, 2012, Tufts University
Until we understand why asthma is becoming more common, we are seriously limited in what we can do to prevent children from developing the disease, says Doug Brugge. Credit: iStock

(Medical Xpress)—Doug Brugge, a professor of public health and community medicine at Tufts, assesses the possible reasons.

It is true that asthma prevalence has been rising in the and many other parts of the world. The reasons for this are not yet clear, although there are some hypotheses that are supported by at least some evidence. Understanding the increase in asthma, particularly in , is terribly important. Preventing asthma in the first place is what we call primary prevention in . Until we understand why asthma is becoming more common, we are seriously limited in what we can do to prevent children from developing the disease.

Most people think that the rapid rise in asthma cannot be due to genetics, because take many generations. This may be true, but I am not as certain. Imagine that from , which were common in the past, were dramatically reduced. It seems to me that you would then have a pool of children, rarely surviving in the past, now living through childhood, perhaps with weaker respiratory systems.

Another possibility is that doctors are simply diagnosing more asthma today than before. According to this line of thinking, milder cases of asthma, which would have been ignored a few decades ago, now get attention and treatment. While I suspect this may influence the rise in , I am skeptical that it could account for most of the change. Many children with asthma today have moderate to severe asthma, which would have been readily apparent in the past.

For me, the environmental hypotheses are the most likely explanations and most interesting, because we potentially could do something about them. There is evidence that and from traffic increase asthma risk.  But because of some work I have done, I am particularly interested in what is called the "."

This hypothesis is poorly named in my opinion because it suggests excessive cleanliness.  To me the core idea has more to do with basic sanitation, our microbiome (the microorganisms that live on and in our body in mostly helpful ways) and infectious diseases, including viruses, bacteria and parasites. People who have more infections and different beneficial microbes appear to be less likely to develop asthma, allergies and autoimmune diseases, suggesting that there is something different about their immune system.

I became interested in the hygiene hypothesis when then Tufts medical student Robyn Matloff, A03, M07, MPH07, and then Tufts undergraduate Angie Lee, A07, MPH10, were surveying children from Chinese immigrant families for asthma. Working with Professor Mark Woodin, we found that foreign-born children were far less likely to have asthma than those born in the United States. A later survey, led by TJ Schuch, another MD/MPH student, found a similar pattern among black residents in Dorchester that resulted in a Boston Globe cover story after we published it. This semester another undergraduate working with me, Laura Corlin, A13, has looked at older adult Chinese immigrants and found that they too are much less likely to have asthma than white non-immigrants.

In many ways, being born in a less-developed country today is similar to being born in the United States in the past. In both cases, the biological influences on the developing immune system are quite different from what most of us experience today.

Does this mean the hygiene hypothesis is correct? Not necessarily. I think we need more and better studies to rule it in—or out. There are other possibilities which also need to be investigated. One notable one is the vitamin D hypothesis. Most people in lower-income countries also live in sunnier places and spend more time outdoors wearing less clothing than we do in Boston. Vitamin D deficiency is widespread at northern latitudes, and there are some indications of associations with asthma and immune function.

It is disappointing that we do not know more about how to prevent in children. But this gap in our knowledge also provides an opportunity to do research that has the potential to bring about truly new knowledge that might provide meaningful public health benefits.

Explore further: Increased risk of developing asthma by age of 3 after cesarean section

Related Stories

Increased risk of developing asthma by age of 3 after cesarean section

January 10, 2012
A new study supports previous findings that children delivered by cesarean section have an increased risk of developing asthma. The study from the Norwegian Mother and Child Cohort Study (MoBa) suggests that children delivered ...

Recommended for you

Chronic inflammation causes loss of muscle mass during aging

January 12, 2018
People start losing muscle mass at the age of 40—about some 10 percent of the total muscle mass for each 10-year period, which may lead to fall-related injuries, slowing metabolism and reduced quality of life. Today, very ...

Breathing exercises help asthma patients with quality of life

December 13, 2017
A study led by the University of Southampton has found that people who continue to get problems from their asthma, despite receiving standard treatment, experience an improved quality of life when they are taught breathing ...

Study highlights the need for research into prevention of inflammatory bowel disease

December 7, 2017
Countries in Africa, Asia, the Middle East and South America have seen a rise in incidence of inflammatory bowel disease as they have become increasingly industrialised and westernised, a new study has found.

Air pollution can increase asthma risk in adults, even at low levels

November 24, 2017
Living close to a busy road can be bad for your respiratory health if you are middle aged, new Australian research has found.

Evidence found of oral bacteria contributing to bowel disorders

October 20, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—An international team of researchers has found evidence that suggests certain types of oral bacteria may cause or exacerbate bowel disorders. In their paper published in the journal Science, the group describes ...

New compound discovered in fight against inflammatory disease

September 22, 2017
A 10-year study by University of Manchester scientists for a new chemical compound that is able to block a key component in inflammatory illness has ended in success.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.