Doctors communicate with man assumed to be in vegetative state using fMRI

fMRI
Credit: National Institute of Mental Health

(Medical Xpress)—Doctors in Canada claim they have opened a communication channel, using fMRI, with a man assumed to be in a vegetative state for over twelve years. By asking the patient to envision two different types of mental exercises and assigning a value of yes or no respectively to each, while undergoing a brain scan, they believe car accident patient Scott Routley has informed them that he is not experiencing any pain.

Routley was severely injured in a car accident in 2000. Subsequent tests indicated that his brain was in a vegetative state, which is described as one where the patient is incapable of displaying any signs of consciousness and shows no signs of responsiveness to . The brain of such a patient is not considered to be dead however, as EEGs continue to show activity.

To try to communicate with Routley, doctors asked him to try to visualize himself playing tennis and recorded the way his brain responded using fMRI. They then asked him next to try to visualize himself walking around in his house and recorded the way his brain responded to that exercise as well. Then, they asked Routley to use the visualizations as a means of responding to questions – to visualize the tennis match as a means of answering yes to a question, for example. The doctors note that different are used to conjure up the two different types of thought processes making them easy to tell apart on fMIR scans. In interviews with the BBC, which is making a documentary about using fMRI to communicate with those thought to be in a , team lead Prof Adrian Owen, said tests were run multiple times using the same question and answer process and he reports that the results indicate that Routley was definitely communicating with him and his team.

Not everyone agrees with the results of course as reading results is still part art as well as science. Also, such research raises the possibility that science will discover that some people have been left to lie immobile for years under the assumption that they are unaware of the reality of their situation – a situation that would have to be addressed if it's determined that they are and have been, capable of conscious thought.


Explore further

How the brain processes humour helps us understand emotions felt by vegetative state patients

More information: via BBC

© 2012 Medical Xpress

Citation: Doctors communicate with man assumed to be in vegetative state using fMRI (2012, November 14) retrieved 18 October 2019 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2012-11-doctors-assumed-vegetative-state-fmri.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Nov 14, 2012
Wow! Really incredible. This will cause people to rethink their relationships and attitudes towards loved ones who are in such a state.


Yes. They will probably ask to die.

Nov 14, 2012
Organ vampires would want this research to go away.

Nov 15, 2012
Yeah, remind me to update my advance directive to account for this... I'd love to see a long list of questions asked, his responses, and a repeat of this on others.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more