Research says 'evolutionary glitch' could be cause of childhood ear infections

Researchers at King's College London have uncovered how the human ear is formed, giving clues as to why children are susceptible to infections such as glue ear. The work was funded by the UK Medical Research Council and published today in the journal Science.

It is estimated that one in five children around the age of two will be affected by , a build-up of fluid in the middle ear chamber. This part of the ear contains three tiny bones that carry from the to the inner ear. When fluid builds up in the chamber, this prevents the three bones from moving freely so they cannot pass sound vibrations to the inner ear, causing temporary hearing loss. Until now, little was known about why some children appear much more prone than others to developing chronic ear problems, with repeated bouts of glue ear.

Carrying out studies in mice, scientists have discovered the cells that line the middle ear cavity originate from two different tissue types – 'endoderm' and '' cells. The part of the lining that originates from the endoderm is covered in a lawn of cilia (hairs) that help to clear debris from the ear, but the lining derived from neural do not have cilia. This makes that part of the middle ear less efficient at cleaning itself, leaving it susceptible to infection.

Interestingly, the process of the middle ear transforming into an air-filled space during development appears to be different in birds and reptiles, which have just one little ear bone. Mammals may have evolved this new mechanism for creating an air-filled space to house the additional bones. This indicates that the process of two distinct cell types to create the lining of the middle ear cavity may be linked to the evolution of the three tiny sound-conducting bones.

Dr Abigail Tucker from the Department of Craniofacial Development at King's College London's Dental Institute, said: 'Our study has uncovered a new mechanism for how the middle ear develops, identifying a possible reason for why it is prone to infection. The process of making up part of the middle ear appears fundamentally flawed as these cells are not capable of clearing the ear effectively. While this process may have evolved in order to create space in the ear for the three little bones essential for hearing, the same process has left mammals prone to infection – it's an evolutionary glitch.

'These findings are contrary to everything we thought we knew about the development of the ear – in all the textbooks it describes that the lining of the middle ear is made of endodermal cells and formed from an extension of another part of the – the Eustachian tube. The textbooks will need to be re-written!'

Explore further

Potential new treatments for a common childhood hearing disorder

Journal information: Science

Citation: Research says 'evolutionary glitch' could be cause of childhood ear infections (2013, March 21) retrieved 20 June 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 22, 2013
The authors seem to have forgotten that the three ear bones evolved from the jaw and that birds must have lost some of these bones. The implication is that mammals multiplied them which appears to be in error. Reptiles have the same number of ear bones as mammals...

See, for instance:

Mar 23, 2013
Noo... The Theobald source (I don't get the use of an intermediary ref) clearly shows one bone free to move in reptiles (stapes), which is presumably the one they are mentioning with respect to reptiles and birds. The other two homologs are still fixated in the jaw, and the series of transitional forms to early mammals shows how they are freed.

Mar 23, 2013
The lack of choline in the diet leads to glue ear.
"children with a cleft are more likely to develop glue ear"
"During pregnancy, women in the lowest quartile of dietary choline intake had a higher risk of having a baby with a neural tube defect (NTD)3 or cleft palate"

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more