Mastectomy debate: Much-needed information or fueling hysteria?

June 21, 2013 by Katie Humphrey, Star Tribune (Minneapolis)

There was a time when breast cancer was discussed in whispers. Mastectomies, hardly at all. Not anymore.

Awareness of the disease and one of its most drastic treatment options rocked Facebook this week when the social bowed to public pressure and allowed post-mastectomy photographs on the site.

Coming on the heels of 's revelation that she had a preventive double mastectomy, talk of the very personal procedure has never been so public.

Yet some are wondering if the increased exposure is providing much-needed information or fueling hysteria about .

"The pendulum may have swung a little bit too much from awareness to paralyzing fear," said Dr. Todd Tuttle, chief of at the University of Minnesota.

Breast cancer survivor Denise Blumberg-Tendle, of Plymouth, Minn., thinks otherwise. "I really believe knowledge is power," she said.

Without a doubt, breast cancer is a deadly disease. The estimates that more than 234,000 Americans will be diagnosed with breast cancer this year, and 40,000 will die from the disease.

Research has shown, however, that women overestimate their risk of developing breast cancer, Tuttle said.

His own study revealed that when told they had a risk factor in one breast, women increasingly opted for preventive double mastectomies. The number of women choosing the procedure jumped 188 percent from 1998 to 2005.

"I worry that a lot of women may choose to do irreversible surgical procedures because of this unrealistic fear," he said.

The photos that spurred a New York to petition Facebook - ultimately garnering more than 20,000 signatures on - are tasteful but jarring images taken by fashion photographer David Jay. He founded the SCAR Project to show the effects of breast cancer.

He posted a set of the photos on Facebook after Jolie's announcement, only to have Facebook remove them.

Scorchy Barrington, the woman battling Stage IV breast cancer who launched the petition, applauded Facebook's newly clarified nudity policy and emphasized the awareness raised by the SCAR Project.

"We want the world to know that breast cancer is not a pink ribbon - it is traumatic, it is life-changing, and it urgently needs a cure," she said in a written statement.

In announcing the policy, Facebook said that post-mastectomy photos have always been permitted, but nudity is not. The issue has come up before when the social network and its users sparred over breastfeeding photographs.

The new policy says "photos with fully exposed breasts, particularly if they're unaffected by surgery, do violate Facebook's terms. These policies are based on the same standards which apply to television and print media, and that govern sites with a significant number of young people."

Even while Blumberg-Tendle, who works for the Susan G. Komen affiliate in Minnesota, applauds the conversation around breast cancer, genetic testing and treatment, she questioned the effectiveness of graphic photos, especially in an era when many people turn to the Internet after a diagnosis.

"Not everybody is ready to see something like that," she said. "When you start reading about every side effect and outcome, sometimes it's not healthy because it's almost too much information."

Dr. Farris Timimi, medical director of the Mayo Clinic Center for Social Media, hopes that striking images on social media will prompt patients to ask more questions of their doctors.

"Conversations are occurring between a provider and their patients that may not have occurred without that kind of knowledge and awareness," he said.

Karen Wilcox, an oncology nurse with Health East, agreed. She said online stories, images and discussions can spark important discussions about family health history before someone gets sick.

"Oftentimes that doesn't come up until it needs to, and then we ask the questions," she said.

"When you get that diagnosis of cancer, your whole world is changed upside down," Wilcox said. "It helps that they can connect to others who have been through that journey."

Sher Noot of Roseville, Minn., looked for pictures online before she had a double mastectomy and reconstruction a couple of years ago after being diagnosed with breast cancer.

"I think it satisfies curiosity," she said. "You want to know what it's going to look like."

Yet Noot said she would never share photographs of her own breasts. Still, she's surprised at how open the discussion of has become. Some family members and friends have asked to see her reconstructed breasts.

"I say, 'If you didn't know them intimately before, you're not going to know them intimately now,'?" she said, laughing.

But she's happy to speak with people who connect with her via CaringBridge, the site she used to share her treatment and recovery with family and friends.

Timimi of Mayo Clinic said that sense of online community has brought solace and strength to many struggling with breast cancer and the difficult choices it requires.

"Knowing that others face the same challenges and do so with dignity and courage - that's a powerful message for anyone to see and receive," Timimi said.

Explore further: Young breast cancer patients often opt for mastectomy

Related Stories

Young breast cancer patients often opt for mastectomy

May 30, 2013
A new study of young women with breast cancer has found that most chose to have a mastectomy rather than a surgical procedure that would conserve the breast, researchers will report at the 49th Annual Meeting of the American ...

Most women who have double mastectomy don't need it, study finds

November 27, 2012
About 70 percent of women who have both breasts removed following a breast cancer diagnosis do so despite a very low risk of facing cancer in the healthy breast, new research from the University of Michigan Comprehensive ...

What is BRCA1?

May 15, 2013
Actress Angelina Jolie has today written an op-ed in the New York Times explaining that she has opted to have a double mastectomy because she carries the hereditary BRCA1 gene, which she says increases her risk of breast ...

ASPS supports new legislation to ensure women are aware of all breast cancer treatment options

May 14, 2013
The American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) today announced its strong support of the "Breast Cancer Patient Education Act" (S. 931). This bipartisan legislation is being introduced today, coinciding with National Women's ...

Angelina Jolie says she had double mastectomy

May 14, 2013
Angelina Jolie says that she has had a preventive double mastectomy after learning she carried a gene that made it extremely likely she would get breast cancer.

Women have more options for breast cancer surgery (Update 2)

May 14, 2013
One of the world's most glamorous women had an operation that once was terribly disfiguring—removal of both breasts. But new approaches are dramatically changing breast surgeries, whether to treat cancer or to prevent it ...

Recommended for you

Researchers release first draft of a genome-wide cancer 'dependency map'

July 27, 2017
In one of the largest efforts to build a comprehensive catalog of genetic vulnerabilities in cancer, researchers from the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard and Dana-Farber Cancer Institute have identified more than 760 genes ...

Cancer-death button gets jammed by gut bacterium

July 27, 2017
Researchers at Michigan Medicine and in China showed that a type of bacterium is associated with the recurrence of colorectal cancer and poor outcomes. They found that Fusobacterium nucleatum in the gut can stop chemotherapy ...

Long-sought mechanism of metastasis is discovered in pancreatic cancer

July 27, 2017
Cells, just like people, have memories. They retain molecular markers that at the beginning of their existence helped guide their development. Cells that become cancerous may be making use of these early memories to power ...

Blocking the back-door that cancer cells use to escape death by radiotherapy

July 27, 2017
A natural healing mechanism of the body may be reducing the efficiency of radiotherapy in breast cancer patients, according to a new study.

Manmade peptides reduce breast cancer's spread

July 27, 2017
Manmade peptides that directly disrupt the inner workings of a gene known to support cancer's spread significantly reduce metastasis in a mouse model of breast cancer, scientists say.

Glowing tumor technology helps surgeons remove hidden cancer cells

July 27, 2017
Surgeons were able to identify and remove a greater number of cancerous nodules from lung cancer patients when combining intraoperative molecular imaging (IMI) - through the use of a contrast agent that makes tumor cells ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.