Behavioral measures of product use didn't measure up in VOICE HIV prevention trial

March 4, 2014, Microbicide Trials Network

A new analysis by researchers from the U.S. National Institutes of Health-funded Microbicide Trials Network (MTN) confirms what they and many others had already assumed: The behavioral measures used for assessing adherence in the VOICE study – an HIV prevention trial that involved more than 5,000 women in sub-Saharan Africa – did not provide accurate information about women's use and nonuse of the products being tested. Their results, which were reported at the 21st Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections (CROI) in Boston today, found these tools were not much better than chance at being able to predict adherence to product use.

"In settings where VOICE was conducted, asking a participant whether or not she is taking her tablets or using her gel provided little insight into her actual behavior. Of course, it's critical to understand the reasons why chose to say one thing and do another, and in that regard, conducting interviews and other socio-behavioral assessments will remain extremely important," said Ariane van der Straten, Ph.D., M.P.H., of the RTI International/Women's Global Health Imperative (RTI/WGHI) program in San Francisco, the lead behavioral scientist for the VOICE study team.

"However, for assessing adherence to product use in the context of an HIV prevention trial, our data is very persuasive that biological measures can provide a more accurate picture," she added.

VOICE – Vaginal and Oral Interventions to Control the Epidemic – evaluated different antiretroviral (ARV)-based approaches for preventing HIV among 5,029 women from 15 sites in South Africa, Uganda and Zimbabwe between 2009 and 2012. The study's primary results, which were presented at last year's CROI meeting, found none of the products tested (tenofovir tablets, Truvada® tablets and tenofovir vaginal gel) was effective in preventing HIV among the study's , who were asked to use their assigned product daily. Although the behavioral measures of adherence indicated that 90 percent of the women had followed the daily regimens, tests of stored conducted at the end of the trial revealed that only 25 percent had actually used product regularly.

With such disparate findings, the researchers decided to evaluate the predictive value of the methods they had used to measure adherence. These included a questionnaire that was administered by staff at every monthly visit asking about product use within the last seven days; and at quarterly visits, use of a computer-based system called Audio Computer-Assisted Self Interview (ACASI) that asked many of the same questions. Because the greater privacy afforded to participants, it was envisioned ACASI would allow for more honest responses about product use than perhaps women would be be willing to give in face-to-face interviews. Records were also kept of the number of leftover pills and unused applicators participants returned each month. Objective measurements involved analysis of stored biological samples at the end of the study to detect the presence of drug – a clear indication whether or not product had been used. All participants had blood samples drawn at their quarterly study visits, and participants assigned to use gel also had vaginal fluid samples taken every six months.

For their analysis, the researchers examined data from a cohort of 472 women who had been assigned to use an active product and had available from at least one follow-up visit both their responses to ACASI questions and drug level results. The cohort comprised 312 women who had been assigned to take an oral tablet (157 in each the tenofovir tablet and Truvada tablet groups) and 158 women who had been assigned to use .

Based on the ACASI data, 91 percent of the women in the oral tablet groups and 90 percent of the women in the vaginal gel group reported using their assigned product at least once in the week prior to the study visit. In these same women, however, blood tests indicate that 31 percent of women had used the tablets at least once within the past week and, similarly, tests of vaginal fluid show 36 percent of the women had recently used the gel.

The analysis did not seek to explain why so many women had not used the study products or why so few women were able or willing to admit nonuse. However, two social and behavioral research sub-studies of VOICE – VOICE C and VOICE D – were designed to address these and similar questions. Although VOICE D is ongoing and not expected to report results until later this year, the first set of results coming out of VOICE C were recently published in the online journal PLOS ONE.

VOICE C, also known as MTN-003C or the Community and Adherence Sub-study, was conducted in parallel with VOICE and designed to identify the specific factors and beliefs within women's communities, social groups and households that may have influenced their willingness or ability to follow the daily regimens in VOICE. It was conducted at a single site – Wits Reproductive Health and HIV Institute (Wits RHI) in Johannesburg, South Africa – and included 102 women enrolled in VOICE, as well as 26 male partners, 17 members of WRHI's Community Advisory Board (CAB) and 23 key community stakeholders, for a total of 164 participants. The results reported in PLOS ONE involve only the group of VOICE participants, who took part in a focus group discussion, a one-time in-depth interview or in a series of ethnographic interviews involving more open-ended conversation over several hours.

While most women claimed they were able to use their assigned products, they alleged other participants were not. All but two women mentioned knowing or hearing about other participants who were not following the study's regimens, often times while sitting in the clinic's waiting room. The lead authors, Dr. van der Straten and Jonathan Stadler, Ph.D., of Wits RHI, who together also led the study, suggest the reasons for women not using the study products included; worries about both the side-effects and the stigma associated with the use of products meant for people infected with HIV; ambivalence about participating in a blinded clinical trial in which it wasn't known whether they had been assigned to use an active product or a placebo, or that the active products were even effective; and pressure from loved ones or strains on relationships with partners, family and friends.

Unlike VOICE C, VOICE D was designed to be conducted after women completed their participation in VOICE, and it includes women from all three countries where VOICE was conducted. Of note, stage two of the study, which is still underway, involves individual interviews and/or focus group discussions with women assigned to use an active product during VOICE for whom stored blood samples have been tested for presence of drug. Researchers hope that when women are told whether or not drug was detected in their blood they will be more forthcoming about why they hadn't (or hadn't always) used their assigned product, or, for a minority of women, how they managed to use product consistently.

In response to VOICE, the MTN has looked to ways to both enhance and monitor product adherence in its ongoing trials so that challenges with use can be addressed as they occur. In ASPIRE, a Phase III trial of the dapivirine vaginal ring, this is being done in a way that preserves the blinded, placebo-controlled nature of the study. The unique design of MTN-017, a Phase II trial of a reduced glycerin formulation of tenofovir gel used as a rectal microbicide in men who have sex with men and transgender women, allows for routine tests of blood and the results to be shared with participants as part of their ongoing adherence counseling sessions on product use.

Explore further: Tenofovir Gel wins out in drug absorption study, but HIV prevention trials say differently

Related Stories

Tenofovir Gel wins out in drug absorption study, but HIV prevention trials say differently

January 30, 2013
A novel head-to-head study looking at differences in how the antiretroviral (ARV) drug tenofovir gets absorbed in the body as either an oral tablet or a vaginal gel found tenofovir gel can achieve substantially higher concentrations ...

Researchers launch first-ever phase II safety study of rectal microbicide to prevent HIV

October 2, 2013
Taking an important step toward the development of a product to prevent HIV infections associated with unprotected anal sex, researchers today announced the launch of a global Phase II clinical trial of a potential rectal ...

NIH discontinues tenofovir vaginal gel in 'VOICE' HIV prevention study

November 28, 2011
A large-scale clinical trial evaluating whether daily use of an antiretroviral-containing oral tablet or vaginal gel can prevent HIV infection in women is being modified because an interim review found that the gel, an investigational ...

NIH modifies 'VOICE' HIV prevention study in women

September 28, 2011
A large-scale clinical trial evaluating whether daily use of an oral tablet or vaginal gel containing antiretroviral drugs can prevent HIV infection in women is being modified because an interim review found that the study ...

Rectal formulation of tenofovir gel safe and acceptable in early phase clinical study

March 6, 2012
A gel formulation of the antiretroviral drug tenofovir designed specifically for rectal use was found safe and acceptable, according to a Phase I clinical study led by the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH)-funded Microbicide ...

Daily HIV prevention approaches didn't work for African women in the VOICE study

March 4, 2013
Results of a major HIV prevention trial suggest that daily use of a product – whether a vaginal gel or an oral tablet – does not appear to be the right approach for preventing HIV in young, unmarried African women.

Recommended for you

HIV-1 genetic diversity is higher in vaginal tract than in blood during early infection

January 18, 2018
A first-of-its-kind study has found that the genetic diversity of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) is higher in the vaginal tract than in the blood stream during early infection. This finding, published in PLOS ...

War in Ukraine has escalated HIV spread in the country: study

January 15, 2018
Conflict in Ukraine has increased the risk of HIV outbreaks throughout the country as displaced HIV-infected people move from war-affected regions to areas with higher risk of transmission, according to analysis by scientists.

Researchers offer new model for uncovering true HIV mortality rates in Zambia

January 12, 2018
A new study that seeks to better ascertain HIV mortality rates in Zambia could provide a model for improved national and regional surveillance approaches, and ultimately, more effective HIV treatment strategies.

New drug capsule may allow weekly HIV treatment

January 9, 2018
Researchers at MIT and Brigham and Women's Hospital have developed a capsule that can deliver a week's worth of HIV drugs in a single dose. This advance could make it much easier for patients to adhere to the strict schedule ...

New long-acting, less-toxic HIV drug suppresses virus in humanized mice

January 8, 2018
A team of Yale researchers tested a new chemical compound that suppresses HIV, protects immune cells, and remains effective for weeks with a single dose. In animal experiments, the compound proved to be a promising new candidate ...

Usage remains low for pill that can prevent HIV infection

January 8, 2018
From gritty neighborhoods in New York and Los Angeles to clinics in Kenya and Brazil, health workers are trying to popularize a pill that has proven highly effective in preventing HIV but which—in their view—remains woefully ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.