Study challenges best way to position women during childbirth

Study challenges best way to position women during childbirth
Credit: Anesthesiology

New research is challenging what many obstetricians and physician anesthesiologists believe is the best way to position women during labor. According to a study published in the February issue of Anesthesiology, the official medical journal of the American Society of Anesthesiologists® (ASA®), the traditional practice of positioning women on their side, with hips tilted at 15 degrees, during labor does not effectively reduce compression of the inferior vena cava, a large vein located near the abdominal area that returns blood to the heart, as previously thought. In fact, not until the degree of tilt reached 30 degrees did blood flow only partially increase in patients, the study found.

"It is widely believed that lying women flat on their back during labor can lead to dangerously low blood pressure caused by the compression of both the inferior vena cava and the aorta due to the weight of the fetus," said Hideyuki Higuchi, M.D., study author, department of anesthesiology, Tokyo Women's Medical University, Japan. "It is accepted by many physicians that positioning women on their side, with hips tilted at 15 , during childbirth reduces this complication. However, our research found no evidence of aortic compression in in any position and the recommended degree of tilt that most physicians follow did not reduce compression of the inferior vena cava at all. This is the first study to challenge this antiquated practice."

In the study, (MRI) of 10 pregnant women at full term and 10 non-pregnant women were obtained for measurement of the , the largest artery in the abdominal cavity, and the inferior vena cava. Measurements were taken while the women laid flat on their back and while tilted at 15, 30, and 45 degrees. Foam was placed under the right side of the study participants to achieve the desired amount of tilt.

The study found that abdominal aortic did not differ significantly between pregnant and non-pregnant women regardless of the position in which they were placed. Conversely, inferior vena cava blood volume was significantly lower in pregnant women than in non-pregnant women when the were positioned flat on their back, indicating almost complete compression of the vein. Inferior vena cava blood volume did not increase at 15 degrees, but partially increased at 30 degrees.

An accompanying editorial commented favorably on the study's results, but offered a word of caution:

"Although it would be great to be able to conclude by saying all of our patients in the delivery room should be placed in at least 30 degrees left lateral tilt after regional anesthetic, I have serious doubts that our obstetric colleagues would find it a reasonable position for cesarean delivery, particularly in obese patients," said editorial author Craig Palmer, M.D., department of anesthesiology, University of Arizona College of Medicine in Tucson, Ariz. "There quite probably are patients for whom the modest (15 degree) tilt we apply has a salutary effect. However, I will have to be less dogmatic about the practice. Kudos to the authors of this study for revisiting an 'ancient' practice, applying current technology to the matter, and shedding new light on an old routine."

Explore further

Endobronchial forceps effective in retrieval of tip-embedded inferior vena cava filters

Journal information: Anesthesiology

Provided by American Society of Anesthesiologists
Citation: Study challenges best way to position women during childbirth (2015, January 20) retrieved 19 October 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jan 20, 2015
Sorry but as a doula, antenatal teacher and mother I am appalled by this article.
Point 1: No human should be forced to give birth on the narrow, hard, high, unsupportive object in the illustration.
Point 2: the side-lying position is NOT considered by anyone to be an optimal birthing position. Any position in which the woman is upright, leaning forward and mobile is likely to be better than lying on one side. Lying on one side is only optimal where a woman's mobility is restricted by, for example, foetal monitoring or epidural anaesthesia.
Point 3: You will find that a woman who has continuous emotional support and encouragement to keep mobile, breathe comfortablywill probably have a better birthing outcome. The absence of any reference to emotional wellbeing in this article is really disgraceful

Jan 20, 2015
Sarah -
I think you misunderstand the intent of the article.
First - the picture is a stock picture of an OR table, not a delivery bed or other birthing bed.
Also, the lateral tilt the article speaks of is not a delivery position. It has long been recommended (though this article refutes this) that this tilt helps keep abdominal (baby) pressure off the major abdominal vessels when a laboring woman is lying down, especially after an epidural or just before a C/Section starts. Yes, a more upright, forward position would be more optimal, but not feasible for those who have an epidural or undergoing a C/Section (hence the article in the journal Anesthesiology).
And, because this article deals with the above issues, especially blood flow through the major vessels, references to emotional support, etc. are really not warranted.
Please don't be appalled by my response - I'm not trying to argue against the very things you are espousing, only the context in relation to this article.

Jan 21, 2015
ThNks for your prompt reply which is reassuring. Actually, though, the article refers to women in labour initially. You have to admit the stock illustration is a poor choice. And by the way emotional support is very much needed in an Operating theatre. As for positions in epidurals, I have seen women able to mobilise and get up in a forward leaning position - again sensitive support being essential.

Jan 25, 2015
Surely the optimal position is squatting, with gravity assisting?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more