Storing babies' blood samples pits privacy versus science

May 13, 2016 by By Rick Callahan
In this Thursday, May 12, 2016 photo, Jessica Bailey holds her newborn daughter Ellie Bailey after blood was collected at Community Hospital North in Indianapolis. Ellie is among some 4 million newborns in the United States who will have blood drawn this year to screen them for serious inherited diseases. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

Two-day-old Ellie Bailey squirms in a hospital bassinet and cries as her tiny left heel is squeezed and then pricked with a needle to draw a blood sample. An Indianapolis hospital technician quickly saturates six circles on a special filter card with the child's blood.

Ellie is among some 4 million newborns in the United States who will have blood drawn this year to screen them for serious inherited diseases such as , which can cause organ damage, and the metabolic disease phenylketonuria, or PKU, which can lead to mental disabilities.

Newborn screening saves or improves the lives of about 12,000 newborns each year by swiftly identifying therapies they might need, said Jelili Ojodu, director of and genetics with the Association of Public Health Laboratories.

But what happens to the dried blood samples on those cards after the testing that's mandatory in all 50 states is completed has sparked legal battles in some states. Minnesota and Texas have destroyed some 6.4 million samples following lawsuits. And in Indiana, the parents of a 9-year-old suburban Indianapolis girl are seeking the same for up to 2.5 million samples collected over two decades and stored in 600 boxes at a state warehouse.

"Her parents' main concern is that down the road who knows what could happen with these samples?" said Jonathan Little, an attorney for parents of the girl, identified in court documents only as A.B. Doe.

In this Thursday, May 12, 2016, Community Hospital North obstetrician technician Sherron Harris collects a blood sample from newborn Ellie Bailey in the nursery at Community Hospital North in Indianapolis. Ellie is among some 4 million newborns in the United States who will have blood drawn this year to screen them for serious inherited diseases. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

The case poses a dilemma: How can society balance the right to privacy with the needs of science and medical research?

The Indiana lawsuit was dismissed by a trial court last year and in April by the Indiana Court of Appeals. Both courts found the girl was in no imminent danger of suffering harm from the state holding onto her sample. Her attorneys plan to appeal to the Indiana Supreme Court next week.

In an era of increasingly sophisticated genetic analysis, some privacy advocates fear insurance companies could access blood samples and charge higher premiums for people found to have a genetic predisposition to diseases such as Alzheimer's.

"The question is, 'These cards are being collected for a very specific purpose, and once they have met that purpose what's the necessity for keeping these blood stains?" said Sheldon Krimsky, acting executive director of the Cambridge-Massachusetts-based Council for Responsible Genetics.

In this Thursday, May 12, 2016 photo, Mark and Jessica Bailey hold their newborn daughter Ellie Bailey after blood was collected at Community Hospital North in Indianapolis. Ellie is among some 4 million newborns in the United States who will have blood drawn this year to screen them for serious inherited diseases. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

He said law enforcement could also potentially access states' newborn blood stores to use them to create DNA databases of law-abiding citizens.

Such worries are "really a far stretch" and not based on actual threats to a person's genetic privacy, said Natasha Bonhomme, vice president of strategic development for the Genetic Alliance, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit health advocacy group.

Scott Kelly, an attorney who represented some of the families who sued Minnesota over its blood-retention policies, said more than 50,000 of Minnesota's dried blood samples and test results were used for research, including third-party research by drug companies and manufacturers. That suit led Minnesota in 2014 to destroy 1.1 million newborn blood samples and another 900,000 test results.

In 2009, Texas destroyed some 5.3 million newborn blood samples as part of a settlement of a similar lawsuit, and Texas lawmakers also set into law an opt-out policy for parents who object to the state using their child's blood for research.

In this Thursday, May 12, 2016 photo, the blood samples collected from a newborn at Community Hospital North are shown in the nursery at Community Hospital North in Indianapolis, Thursday, May 12, 2016. Some 4 million newborns in the United States will have blood drawn this year to screen them for serious inherited diseases such as sickle cell anemia, which can cause organ damage, and the metabolic disease phenylketonuria, or PKU, which can lead to mental disabilities. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

Attorneys for Indiana say the 2.5 million blood samples at the heart of the pending lawsuit won't be used for medical research, but argue the state has an interest in holding onto them, such as for evidence in missing persons or medical malpractice cases.

Starting in June 2013, Indiana tried to solve the dilemma by asking the parents of newborns for permission to use their infant's blood for medical research. The parents of just over 63,000 infants—about a quarter of the babies born in Indiana in the past three years—have consented to that, said Jennifer O'Malley, an Indiana State Department of Health spokeswoman.

Those now include 27-year-old Jessica Bailey—the mother of Ellie. She checked the "yes" box on Indiana's consent form and signed it Thursday, authorizing the state to use her daughter's blood for medical research.

She and her husband, Mark, said they don't share concerns about the blood's possible misuse and believe there's great potential in allowing its use for medical research.

In this Thursday, May 12, 2016 photo, Community Hospital North obstetrician technician Sherron Harris collects a blood sample from newborn Ellie Bailey in the nursery at Community Hospital North in Indianapolis. Ellie is among some 4 million newborns in the United States who will have blood drawn this year to screen them for serious inherited diseases. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

"I personally feel the benefits with the research outweigh the risks," Jessica Bailey said as she and Mark prepared to leave Community Hospital North in Indianapolis with their second child. "For us, It was kind of an easy decision because it might help somebody in the future."

Indiana has posted a form on the state health department's website allowing parents to request that their child's blood sample be destroyed, no matter when it was collected. That's not enough for the father of the 9-year-old girl who sued the state. He asked The Associated Press not to use his name because it would identify his daughter.

He said he supports disease-screening for newborns, and said his daughter has even taken part in a project for stomach ailments. But he believes it's time for the state to dispose of the collected between 1991 and May 2013 that it held onto without alerting parents.

"Somebody obviously has some kind of plans for it, if they've gone to the expense of storing it and keeping it," he said.

Explore further: Scientific progress could be casualty in public health vs. privacy debate over newborn blood samples

Related Stories

Scientific progress could be casualty in public health vs. privacy debate over newborn blood samples

November 7, 2012
The tremendous potential public health benefits of research with blood samples left over after routine newborn screening must not be lost amidst controversy and litigation, say medical and bioethics experts in a commentary ...

Restoring trust vital in public acceptance of the use of residual newborn screening specimens

June 14, 2011
Government guidelines published today on the use of dried blood spots collected during mandatory newborn screening underemphasize the importance of getting the public on board with the practice, according to University of ...

Newborn screening test developed for rare, deadly neurological disorder

May 4, 2016
Soon after birth, a baby's blood is sampled and tested for a number of rare inherited conditions, such as cystic fibrosis and sickle cell anemia. But no such test has existed for a progressive neurodegenerative disease, called ...

Raiders of the lost blood spots

March 13, 2012
Almost every newborn in the United States is pricked on the heel within hours of birth for a few drops of blood that are then tested for conditions like PKU, sickle cell anemia, and cystic fibrosis. But then the sample is ...

Recommended for you

A math concept from the engineering world points to a way of making massive transcriptome studies more efficient

November 17, 2017
To most people, data compression refers to shrinking existing data—say from a song or picture's raw digital recording—by removing some data, but not so much as to render it unrecognizable (think MP3 or JPEG files). Now, ...

Genetic mutation in extended Amish family in Indiana protects against aging and increases longevity (Update)

November 15, 2017
The first genetic mutation that appears to protect against multiple aspects of biological aging in humans has been discovered in an extended family of Old Order Amish living in the vicinity of Berne, Indiana, report Northwestern ...

Genetic variant prompts cells to store fat, fueling obesity

November 13, 2017
Obesity is often attributed to a simple equation: People are eating too much and exercising too little. But evidence is growing that at least some of the weight gain that plagues modern humans is predetermined. New research ...

Discovering a protein's role in gene expression

November 10, 2017
Northwestern Medicine scientists have discovered that a protein called BRWD2/PHIP binds to histone lysine 4 (H3K4) methylation—a key molecular event that influences gene expression—and demonstrated that it does so via ...

Twin study finds genetics affects where children look, shaping mental development

November 9, 2017
A new study co-led by Indiana University that tracked the eye movement of twins finds that genetics plays a strong role in how people attend to their environment.

Boy with rare disease gets brand new skin with gene therapy

November 8, 2017
Doctors treating a critically ill boy with a devastating skin disease used experimental gene therapy to create an entirely new skin for most of his body in a desperate attempt to save his life.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.