Sharing treatment decisions challenges doctors and parents of young children with autism

June 20, 2016, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia

Parents of young children diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) may experience significant difficulties in discussing treatment options with the child's pediatrician, according to new research. Among the barriers are problems with communication, physicians' lack of knowledge about specific ASD treatments and community resources, and uncertainty about the pediatrician's role in making treatment recommendations for a child with ASD.

Many parents in the study reported that they did not discuss the choice of any treatment options with their pediatricians, and others said their physicians provided only general recommendations or referrals. The study team suggests that tools such as decision aids and practice guidelines may help foster more effective communication between families and pediatricians.

"We investigated shared decision making—an interactive process in which patient families and physicians work together to arrive at a treatment plan," said study leader Susan E. Levy, M.D., M.P.H., a developmental and behavioral in the Center for Autism Research and the Division of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics at The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP).

The study appears online in Academic Pediatrics.

Shared decision making (SDM) has been studied over recent decades as a method for improving provider-patient communication and partnership, with improvements seen in satisfaction, adherence and health outcomes. "Although there are more studies in adult health settings, SDM concerns continue to expand into pediatric practice," said study co-author Alexander G. Fiks, M.D., M.S.C.E., a pediatrician at CHOP's PolicyLab and the Center for Pediatric Clinical Effectiveness who has investigated how to implement SDM approaches for children with special needs.

The current single-center study used a qualitative approach, with in-person or telephone interviews of 20 pediatricians and 20 parents of with a diagnosis of ASD, ages two to five years. All participating clinicians were from the CHOP pediatric network, drawn in equal numbers from urban and suburban offices. Families came from Philadelphia and surrounding suburbs.

The study team identified three principal themes: 1) both parents and physicians reported knowledge gaps about ASD treatments and community resources, and described ambiguity about the pediatrician's role in ASD care; 2) a lack of communication existed between parents and pediatricians about treatment choices; and 3) the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) treatments created conflict between pediatricians and parents.

The researchers suggest that as primary care pediatricians encounter more children with ASD in their practice, they may benefit from the use of tools available through the American Academy of Pediatrics, such as the Autism Toolkit and clinical practice guidelines. Such tools have helped support pediatricians in managing children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in the primary care setting.

However, noted Fiks, there are significant differences between the disorders, including more medication options for managing core symptoms of ADHD than for ASD. Referring to ASD management, one pediatrician told the interviewer, "we in general are not so much an expert on it so it is harder to just prescribe things, and it turns out we really can't do it anyway."

Many parents sought outside the medical community, from school staff or various therapists. As has been found in the literature, many parents pursued CAM treatments. Parents reported they did not discuss these treatments with their pediatrician due to the pediatrician's lack of knowledge or discomfort with the topic. One parent said, "Look, I left the last guy because he wouldn't listen to me. At this point this is what my son is on [a special diet]."If pediatricians are uncomfortable in discussing unproven CAM therapies, such as specialized diets, supplements or vitamin shots, they miss an opportunity to discuss benefits and risks.

Given the study's findings of knowledge barriers and a lack of engagement in treatment decisions, the authors suggest some specific measures for primary care practices: using care coordinators, ASD care plans, creating summaries of outside resources and providing families with logs to monitor progress.

More fundamentally, the authors conclude, shared decision making will involve greater recognition by both providers and parents that partnering in care for children with ASD falls within the scope of pediatricians' jobs and is in the families' best interest. "Much work remains to be done to improve this process in caring for children with ASD," said Levy.

Explore further: Pediatricians vary widely in diagnosing ADHD, depression

More information: Susan E. Levy et al, Shared Decision Making and Treatment Decisions for Young Children With Autism Spectrum Disorder, Academic Pediatrics (2016). DOI: 10.1016/j.acap.2016.04.007

Related Stories

Pediatricians vary widely in diagnosing ADHD, depression

April 1, 2016
(HealthDay)—There is a large variation in how often U.S. pediatricians diagnose and prescribe drugs for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and other mental health conditions, a new study suggests.

Trouble sleeping associated with behavioral problems in children with autism

February 16, 2016
New research from the University of Missouri has found associations between trouble sleeping and behavioral problems in children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD).

Healthcare providers' responses to parental concerns can delay diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders

April 15, 2015
Children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) can develop symptoms before 2 years of age and usually can be diagnosed by 3 years of age; early identification of ASD is associated with improved long-term developmental outcomes. ...

Engaging parents leads to better treatments for children with adhd

October 23, 2012
Pediatricians and researchers at The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia's(CHOP) have developed a first-of-its kind tool to help parents and health care providers better treat ADHD (attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder). ...

Many parents of kids with autism don't put faith in pediatricians

May 16, 2012
(HealthDay) -- Many parents of children with an autism spectrum disorder don't feel they can turn to their pediatricians for advice on treatments, a new study finds.

The dying child: Room for improvement in end-of-life care

May 27, 2016
Many pediatricians and pediatric subspecialists believe that their clinical care extends from treating ill children through end-of-life care. However, are pediatricians actually meeting the needs of families and their dying ...

Recommended for you

Brain activity shows development of visual sensitivity in autism

December 11, 2018
Research investigating how the brain responds to visual patterns in people with autism has shown that sensory responses change between childhood and adulthood.

Study connects the genetic background of autistic spectrum disorders with stem cell dysfunction

December 4, 2018
Disorders of the autistic spectrum have been associated with hundreds of genetic variations, which have helped in identifying disturbed intracellular signalling pathways and molecular mechanisms typical to autism.

Home videos of children can be scored to diagnose autism, study says

November 27, 2018
Short home videos can be used to diagnose autism in children, according to a new study from the Stanford University School of Medicine.

Brain responses to language in toddlers with autism linked to altered gene expression

November 26, 2018
An international team of scientists, led by researchers at the University of Cyprus and University of California San Diego School of Medicine, have identified a previously unknown, large-scale association between molecular ...

How many kids have autism? US government measures three ways

November 26, 2018
How many American children have autism? The U.S. government answers that question at least three different ways and says the latest estimate—1 in 40 kids—doesn't necessarily mean the numbers are rising.

Mutation that causes autism and intellectual disability makes brain less flexible

November 19, 2018
About 1 percent of patients diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and intellectual disability have a mutation in a gene called SETD5. Scientists have now discovered what happens on a molecular level when the gene is mutated ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.