Researchers improve how surgeons discuss high-stakes treatments

February 8, 2017

For frail older adults, acute health problems often have significant life-altering effects. Despite that reality, research shows that aggressive treatments, including surgery, are common near the end of life, even though the majority of older adults say they prefer to avoid burdensome interventions that could leave them with a diminished quality of life.

In a new study published online in the journal JAMA Surgery, researchers from the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health (SMPH) describe a novel communication model that shifts the focus of decision-making conversations from a problem with a surgical solution to a discussion about treatment alternatives and outcomes.

Researchers say this framework for conversations, called "Best Case/Worst Case" (BC/WC), may allow patients and families to make treatment decisions that are better aligned with their personal goals.

The BC/WC model, developed by SMPH researchers, combines narrative description and handwritten graphic aids to illustrate choices between treatments and is designed to engage patients and families in the decision-making process. Using the BC/WC framework, surgeons use stories to describe how patients might experience a range of possible outcomes, from the best case to the worst case, and the most likely scenarios they could encounter.

"Incorporating stories that describe how surgery can impact the patient's overall quality of life can help surgeons, patients and their families avoid surgery when even the best-case surgical outcome is unacceptable," said Dr. Margaret "Gretchen" Schwarze, associate professor of surgery and principal investigator on the study. "Our study suggests that presenting and exploring a set of treatment options and plausible outcomes with patients can help patients and families think more strategically and make decisions based on what's most important to them."

For the study, 25 surgeons (cardiothoracic, vascular, and acute care) from the University Hospital in Madison, Wisconsin, completed a two-hour training session to learn the BC/WC framework using simulation with standardized patients and one-on-one instruction with coaches. Before training, the surgeons described patients' conditions in conjunction with operative solutions, directed deliberation over options, listed procedural risks and did not integrate patient/family preferences into a treatment recommendation.

After the BC/WC training, surgeons presented a clear choice between treatments, described a range of postoperative trajectories, including functional decline, and involved patients and families in the shared and deliberation.

The study participants included a control group of nine men and three women and an intervention group of seven men and 13 women. Participants were 68 to 95 years of age and nearly half had five or more comorbid conditions.

"We believe that with this proof of concept, the Best Case/Worst Case intervention can be used to change surgeon behavior to better support patients and families who are maintaining hope for the best but who also need to be aware of and prepare for the worst," Schwarze said.

Although the study demonstrated that the BC/WC model can distinctly change the way surgeons communicate with their regarding high-stakes decisions, researchers were unable to identify a measurable health outcome that would allow them to test whether this intervention improves clinical outcomes beyond shared decision-making.

Explore further: Surgery isn't always the best option, and the decision shouldn't just lie with the doctor

More information: Lauren J. Taylor et al. A Framework to Improve Surgeon Communication in High-Stakes Surgical Decisions, JAMA Surgery (2017). DOI: 10.1001/jamasurg.2016.5674

Related Stories

Surgery isn't always the best option, and the decision shouldn't just lie with the doctor

October 31, 2016
Surgeons often decide to perform procedures because that's what's usually done, it's what they're taught, it sounds logical or it fits with observations from their own practice.

Study finds substantial rate of contralateral prophylactic mastectomy when procedure not indicated

December 21, 2016
In a survey of women who underwent treatment for early-stage breast cancer in one breast, contralateral prophylactic mastectomy (CPM; both breasts are surgically removed, the breast that contains cancer and the healthy breast) ...

To operate or not to operate: A serious question with no clear answers

May 20, 2016
What goes into a surgeon's decision to operate or recommend an alternative treatment option?

Frailty in older surgery patients may be under recognized

October 12, 2016
Key findings in this study show nearly 70% of patients who participated in the frailty screening were determined to be pre-frail or frail. Patients who are frail or pre-frail may be at greater risk of surgical and post-surgical ...

Surgeon experience influences post-op mobilization orders

October 24, 2016
(HealthDay)—Patient characteristics and surgeon factors influence surgeons' postoperative weight-bearing orders after hip fracture repair, according to research published online Oct. 6 in the Journal of Evaluation in Clinical ...

Orthopaedic surgeons use new patient-focused measures to assess outcomes

November 1, 2016
Orthopaedists traditionally rely on X-rays, MRI, CT scans, physical measurements, and functional tests for patient outcomes assessments, but this is changing thanks to new technology that communicates ongoing, real-time outcomes ...

Recommended for you

Defining optimal opioid pain medication prescription length following surgery

September 27, 2017
A new study led by researchers at the Center for Surgery and Public Health at Brigham and Women's Hospital analyzed opioid prescription data from the Department of Defense Military Health System Data Repository, identifying ...

Is older blood OK to use in a transfusion?

September 27, 2017
(HealthDay)—Using older red blood cells to give transfusions to critically ill patients doesn't appear to affect their risk of dying, Australian researchers report.

One weight-loss surgery shows lasting results

September 21, 2017
(HealthDay)—Obesity surgery can have long-lasting effects on weight and the risk of developing type 2 diabetes and high blood pressure, a new study finds.

Hold the phone: An ambulance might lower your chances of surviving some injuries

September 20, 2017
Victims of gunshots and stabbings are significantly less likely to die if they're taken to the trauma center by a private vehicle than ground emergency medical services (EMS), according to results of a new analysis.

Surgeons have major influence on breast cancer treatment

September 13, 2017
A woman's choice of surgeon plays a significant role in whether she's likely to receive an increasingly popular aggressive breast cancer surgery.

Some thyroid cancer patients can safely delay surgery

September 4, 2017
Most people diagnosed with cancer want to start treatment as soon as possible, for fear that delaying care will allow their tumor to grow out of control.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.