Children should be more involved in healthcare decisions that affect them

April 19, 2017 by Imelda Coyne, The Conversation
Credit: Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock

Few people would disagree that children have a right to participate in matters that affect them. But in hospitals this right seems to be waived. My research at hospitals in Ireland revealed that children find it difficult to have their views heard.

The said that doctors and nurses were "nice" and "kind", but some tended to carry out medical procedures without seeking their opinions or telling them beforehand. Some parents helped children to be included in talks about their care, but other parents answered questions on their behalf, told them to stay quiet and withheld information from them. Some parents also told their child to stay quiet and not annoy the doctor or nurse. Being excluded from discussions made some children feel sad, frustrated and angry. As one 14-year-old girl put it: "It made me feel like a piece of machinery; they weren't actually talking to me."

Big and small decisions

Children tend to see decisions as being big or small. They generally accept that adults make the "really big" decisions and they trust them to make the right call. Children tended to trust their parents as they have their welfare at heart, and they believe that know what the best treatment is as they are the experts. Nevertheless, children said that they would like to be included in discussions about decisions that affect them. They also expressed a desire for adults to use simple words – not medical jargon.

According to children, the "small decisions" are those that focus on the way the nursing care, procedures and tests are done to them. For many children, though, these are because having choices makes it easier to cope. Inclusion in decisions, makes children feel happier, respected, less anxious and more prepared. Most children, regardless of age, prefer to share -making with their parents and healthcare professionals rather than have sole responsibility.

Respecting human rights

Children and teenagers need to be involved in decisions as it respects their rights as human beings and makes it easier for them to cope with receiving care in . Being in hospital can make children scared and anxious, but they are less likely to be distressed if they are prepared for what is going to happen to them.

Drafted by the UN nearly 30 years ago, the Convention on the Rights of the Child states that children have the right to be heard in all matters affecting their lives. Although there has been significant efforts to respect and promote the rights of children, they still encounter barriers to having their views heard in decisions that affect them.

Healthcare professionals and parents don't always agree on the extent to which children should be involved in making decisions about their treatment. Doctors and nurses want to provide the best care and treatment but worry about children's mental ability and emotional maturity to participate in decisions. As a result, some healthcare professionals restrict the involvement of children in decisions that could influence the outcome of treatment for the worse.

Likewise, parents want the best for their child. They want to make the hospital stay easier for the child and for their child to get better and return home. Parenting practices have changed greatly over the past 30 years, and we now know that parents tend to listen more and include their children in everyday decisions in the home. In the hospital, many parents think it is important to involve children in decisions to promote self-esteem and well-being. But some parents feel they should protect their child from potentially distressing information or , so they restrict their child's involvement. They think that the has enough to cope with, so they filter the information to avoid causing further distress.

However, we should not be overly critical of and healthcare professionals who exclude children from as these decisions are not always straightforward and can vary a lot depending on the situation. Children often want to participate in discussions about their care but would rather not bear full responsibility for decision making.

When we talk about decisions most people think of major decisions that make the headlines, such as end-of-life decisions or legal capacity to consent. For children, though, it is about taking part, voicing preferences, being listened to and being heard in the decisions that affect their lives in hospital. These may be simple, but they can make a huge difference to children.

Explore further: Parents can help soothe burns treatment stress

Related Stories

Parents can help soothe burns treatment stress

April 7, 2017
Playful distraction can trump kisses and cuddles to reduce a child's anxiety and pain during potentially painful burns dressing changes.

Excluding children from discussions about their hospital care causes unnecessary distress

July 25, 2011
Children who are excluded from discussions about their hospital care often feel scared and angry that no-one is listening to them or telling them what is going on. That's why health professionals and parents need to do more ...

When doctors and parents disagree—clinical 'best' not always best for family

September 9, 2016
A University of Melbourne ethicist is encouraging doctors to recognise the autonomy of parents, even if this could mean "less than optimal" treatment decisions for their children.

Poll: Parents struggle with when to keep kids home sick from school

January 16, 2017
It can be a nerve-wracking, game time decision for parents: whether their sick child should stay home from school.

Working pressures increase children attending nursery with respiratory tract infections

March 5, 2014
Working parents are often caught between the needs of their sick child and their job, which can lead to continued day care use even when their child is ill. New research has found children going to nursery when they are unwell ...

Cartoons help children decide on participation in research

November 30, 2016
Children are often able to decide for themselves whether they want to take part in medical research. In order to be able to make an informed decision, they need clear information. PhD candidate Ronella Grootens set a good ...

Recommended for you

Stress in pregnancy linked to changes in infant's nervous system, less smiling, less resilience

November 23, 2017
Maternal stress during the second trimester of pregnancy may influence the nervous system of the developing child, both before and after birth, and may have subtle effects on temperament, resulting in less smiling and engagement, ...

Molecules in spit may be able to diagnose and predict length of concussions

November 20, 2017
Diagnosing a concussion can sometimes be a guessing game, but clues taken from small molecules in saliva may be able to help diagnose and predict the duration of concussions in children, according to Penn State College of ...

Breastfed babies are less likely to have eczema as teenagers, study shows

November 13, 2017
Babies whose mothers had received support to breastfeed exclusively for a sustained period from birth have a 54% lower risk of eczema at the age of 16, a new study led by researchers from King's College London, Harvard University, ...

Obesity during pregnancy may lead directly to fetal overgrowth, study suggests

November 13, 2017
Obesity during pregnancy—independent of its health consequences such as diabetes—may account for the higher risk of giving birth to an atypically large infant, according to researchers at the National Institutes of Health. ...

Working to reduce brain injury in newborns

November 10, 2017
Research-clinicians at Children's National Health System led the first study to identify a promising treatment to reduce or prevent brain injury in newborns who have suffered hypoxia-ischemia, a serious complication in which ...

Why do some kids die under dental anesthesia?

November 9, 2017
Anesthesiologists call for more research into child deaths caused by dental anesthesia in an article published online by the journal Pediatrics.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.