Obesity is not a character flaw, expert says

April 11, 2017 by Charles Jolie, Rush University Medical Center
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Is obesity the result of a poor self-control? Most people in the United States believe it is, according to a survey by the National Opinions Research Center: Three-quarters of the people surveyed attributed obesity to a lack of willpower.

In the same survey, more than 80 percent of Americans believed obesity is the most serious health problem facing the nation. That response tied obesity with cancer and ranked it an even more a serious health problem than diabetes, heart , mental illness, and HIV/AIDS. But while those surveyed classified these other health threats as diseases, three-quarters said obesity was not one.

Alfonso Torquati, MD, MSCI, strongly disagrees with these views. Torquati understands that obesity isn't a character flaw, but a chronic disease caused by an array of genetic, biologic, metabolic, behavioral, social and economic factors.

"Obesity is absolutely a disease that requires a range of interventions and medical management," says Torquati, chairperson of the Rush University Medical Center Department of Surgery and director of the Rush University Center for Obesity. "People may say 'just eat less, have will power' but they just don't understand that simply does not work for many people."

While the public misconception of obesity as a character flaw persists, Torquati says that have made progress in defining—and thus treating—obesity as a chronic disease. The importance of this label, he says, is not in how obesity is defined, but how it is measured.

"Successfully treating obesity shouldn't just be measured in lost pounds, but in not escalating to other diseases. Obesity is a base condition that then leads to or worsens so many others diseases like diabetes, high blood pressure, , sleep apnea, arthritis, and even cancer," he says.

Fighting attitudes, and evolution

While widespread public perceptions of obesity need to be corrected, perhaps the "audience" most resistant to change is our own cells and metabolic systems. For hundreds of thousands of years, was a signal that humans were starving. In response, the human body has evolved complex, self-protection systems.

Weight loss triggers a drop in leptin a hormone that tells the body when it's fully fed, and increases ghrelin a hormone that tells the body it's time to eat. The brain also reacts to loss by intensifying the feeling of reward from food, causing muscles to burn fewer calories. Those extra calories are stored as fat, so the body can return to its previous weight.

Indeed, keeping lost weight off is the fundamental challenge for those struggling with obesity. "Most of my patients have lost hundreds of pounds, but then steadily put that weight back on," Torquati says. "It's not just a matter of how disciplined they are."

Bariatric surgery is often most effective treatment for obesity

When someone is 20 or 30 pounds overweight, diet and exercise are prescribed and can work extremely well. Under a doctor's supervision, a multidisciplinary team of experts in endocrinology, cardiovascular disease, behavioral health, nutrition and fitness can help patients make lasting lifestyle changes.

But for people with a body mass index of 35—about 60 pounds overweight for their height –the most effective strategy to beating obesity is likely , a range of surgical procedures that limit how much food someone eats by making the stomach smaller or changing the small intestine. Several research studies have shown that bariatric is the most effective method to achieve sustained weight loss, and thus better health.

The American Diabetes Association now recommends bariatric surgery as a first-line treatment for people considered severely obese. (For more information, please see these Bariatric Surgery FAQs.)

Don't call it cosmetic surgery

Bariatric surgery doesn't result in substantial weight loss simply by limiting how much food a person eats. Needing less food to feel full results in a series of changes in how people convert food into energy. Research by Torquati and colleagues, for example, documented how patients with type 2 diabetes can achieve long term remission after bariatric surgery.

"In China, is not widespread but diabetes is. So bariatric surgery there is called 'diabetes" surgery," Torquati points out.

While the body fights steady weight loss through appetite-enhancing hormones, bariatric surgery's very quick weight loss seems to re-set the body's metabolic systems, so people no longer crave the foods that added excessive pounds.

Torquati's patients tell him they don't care if it's called diabetic, bariatric or metabolic surgery. "When we talk to the patients that finally seek medical solution, they never say it is for cosmetic reasons, or to look better," Torquati says.

"It is because they want to live longer, live better, play with their children, etc. They just want to be healthy. "

Explore further: Patients with higher thyroid hormone levels lose more weight after bariatric surgery

Related Stories

Patients with higher thyroid hormone levels lose more weight after bariatric surgery

April 3, 2017
Patients who have higher levels of the thyroid hormone triiodothyronine (T3) lose more weight after bariatric surgery, new research from Portugal reports. The study results will be presented in a poster Monday, April 3, at ...

Bariatric surgery may reduce heart failure risk

November 14, 2016
Bariatric surgery and other treatments that cause substantial weight loss can significantly reduce the risk of heart failure in obese patients, according to preliminary research presented at the American Heart Association's ...

Is bariatric surgery a cost-effective treatment for teens with severe obesity?

October 26, 2016
In a study published online by JAMA Surgery, Chin Hur, M.D., M.P.H., of Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, and colleagues assessed the cost-effectiveness of bariatric surgery for adolescents with obesity using recently ...

Study shows bariatric surgery better than intensive lifestyle and drug interventions at reversing diabetes

March 17, 2016
New research shows that bariatric surgery (also known as obesity surgery) is much more effective than an intensive lifestyle/medication intervention at reversing type 2 diabetes in patients with only mild-to-moderate obesity.

Consider obesity surgery more often for diabetes: guidelines

May 24, 2016
New guidelines say weight-loss surgery should become a more routine treatment option for diabetes, even for some patients who are mildly obese.

Morbidly obese patients may benefit from bariatric surgery prior to knee replacement

January 21, 2016
Previous research studies have linked obesity to adverse outcomes and increased costs following total knee replacement surgery (TKR). A new, computer model-based evaluation appearing in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, ...

Recommended for you

Nearly all adolescents have eating, activity or weight-related issues

June 22, 2018
A new study from the University of Minnesota School of Public Health found that nearly all young people have struggles with eating, activity and weight as they move from adolescence to adulthood.

Obesity plagues rural America

June 19, 2018
(HealthDay)—Country folk are being hit harder by the U.S. obesity epidemic than city dwellers, two new government studies show.

Binging, purging and fasting more common in overweight, obese young adults

June 12, 2018
Young adults who are overweight or obese are twice as likely as their leaner peers to binge and purge, use laxatives or diuretics, or force themselves to vomit as a means of controlling their weight, according to a new study ...

Study offers new hope for the fight against genetically determined obesity

June 3, 2018
Around 2 to 6 percent of all people with obesity develop the condition in early childhood. Obesity-causal mutations in one of the 'appetite genes' gives them a strong genetic predisposition for developing obesity, also called ...

Abnormal lipid metabolism in fat cells predicts future weight gain and diabetes in women

May 31, 2018
The inefficient breakdown of fats predicts later weight gain and metabolic complications such as type 2 diabetes in women, researchers report May 31 in the journal Cell Metabolism. Low levels of hormone-stimulated lipolysis—a ...

Antidepressant use may contribute to long-term population weight gain

May 24, 2018
Researchers at King's College London have found that patients prescribed any of the 12 most commonly used antidepressants were 21% more likely to experience an episode of gain weight than those not taking the drugs, (after ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.