Fashionable FitBits discourage young teens from exercising, study finds

August 2, 2017 by Sarah Cox, Brunel University London, Brunel University
Credit: Brunel University

Wearable activity trackers could be doing more harm than good in encouraging young teenagers to exercise, new research from Brunel University London suggests.

Demand for FitBits soared among 11-15 year-olds last year, and The Times referred to the gadget as the 'latest status symbol' for kids.

Over decades, physical interventions targeted at young people in schools have only produced modest effects. Finding new ways to motivate young people is vital for long-term health, and - for a generation tethered to their mobiles - fitness devices seemed to be a new and exciting way to help.

A new study by Dr Charlotte Kerner (Brunel University London) and Dr Victoria Goodyear (University of Birmingham) found that the opposite could be true.

Their research with school pupils aged 13-14 showed that wearing a FitBit for eight weeks demotivated the teenagers from exercising rather than encouraging them to do more.

Surveys and focus groups conducted before and after the trial period concluded that the device (in this case, the FitBit Charge wristband and app, which retails for around £100) ultimately made participants feel less confident about their competence at exercising, less connected to their peers, and less like they had autonomy or choice over how to engage with physical activity.

The FitBit app is designed with features to encourage competition and interaction among peers, and while pupils reported that they set up competitions in their friendship groups, the end result did not always have positive implications.

The FitBit 'community' often helped encourage pupils to engage with discussions about physical activity and develop common understandings and behaviours, but the competitive element often led to peer-pressure to achieve goals. In some cases, it induced a sense of guilt and other negative feelings of self.

Competition was an external pressure to engage in physical activity rather than an internal motivator, and while the desire to get to the top of the leaderboard encouraged some participants to be more active, most of the pupils did not report engaging in activity 'for fun' during the 8-week period.

The research team noticed a short-term novelty effect where some participants were more active for the first few weeks, but it was consistently reported that after a month, pupils became bored of the FitBit. After that, reported declined.

"I did it for the first four weeks, and then the last couple of weeks I just sat at home all day," reported one participant.

Dr Kerner comments: "Our data suggests that peer-comparison was a key factor in undermining levels of competence and autonomous motivation. There wasn't a desire for our participants to be more active for themselves and their own goals, or for fun, it was simply because they wanted to beat their mates. Self-determined forms of motivation are much better in encouraging people to engage in a particular behaviour.

"Additionally, the pre-defined daily target encouraged by FitBit is 10,000 steps. It's not a personalised target and our results show that many participants found it undermining. They said it was unfair, especially if you lacked the ability to achieve those targets.

"They strived to achieve it but would often fall short. That made them feel really bad about themselves, and put them off exercise. The app had a negative influence on their perceptions of what being competent at activity means because these pre-defined targets were not relevant to individual needs."

The researchers suggest that digital technologies could still play a useful role but practitioners (for example, PE teachers) should help support and educate young people in personalisation and interpreting data for individual goals and ability, rather than encouraging young people to compare themselves to others or a normative standard of achievement. It is vital to promote autonomy as young people's motivation to be more physically active. They need to see themselves as capable and confident, and the 'origin' of their behaviours rather than a 'pawn'.

Study participants (44 girls and 40 boys) were recruited from six randomly selected PE classes within two schools, a non-selective private school in the South East of England and a comprehensive in the North West.

The research team conclude that research should continue with a larger group of to enable further solid conclusions on the role of healthy lifestyle technologies in behaviour.

Explore further: Why you should consider more than looks when choosing a fitness tracker

More information: Charlotte Kerner et al. The Motivational Impact of Wearable Healthy Lifestyle Technologies: A Self-determination Perspective on Fitbits With Adolescents, American Journal of Health Education (2017). DOI: 10.1080/19325037.2017.1343161

Related Stories

Why you should consider more than looks when choosing a fitness tracker

July 25, 2017
A UNSW study of five popular physical activity monitors, including Fitbit and Jawbone models, has found their accuracy differs with the speed of activity, and where they are worn.

Don't expect Fitbits to improve health, help drop pounds

October 5, 2016
Wearing a fitness tracker may help you keep tabs on how many steps you take, but the devices themselves—even with the lure of a cash reward—probably won't improve your health, according to the biggest study yet done on ...

Self-efficacy boosts physical activity in osteoarthritis patients

July 27, 2017
Osteoarthritis patients that are more confident in their abilities in the morning go on to be more physically active throughout the day, according to a team of Penn State researchers.

Does a Fitbit make you more active?

June 28, 2016
My wife recently purchased a FitBit Alta activity tracker that she absolutely loves. She is constantly looking at the number of steps she's taken throughout the day, and rejoices like a child when she hits a milestone (i.e. ...

Youth more likely to discourage than promote smoking among peers

July 28, 2017
Young people more often discourage smoking among their peers than encourage it, new University of Otago research suggests.

Recommended for you

Study unmasks scale of patient doctor divide

June 13, 2018
A study has estimated that around three million Britons—or 7.6 % of the country—believe they have experienced a harmful or potentially harmful but preventable problem in primary healthcare.

Lentils significantly reduce blood glucose levels, study reveals

June 13, 2018
Replacing potatoes or rice with pulses can lower your blood glucose levels by more than 20 per cent, according to a first-ever University of Guelph study.

Researcher studies the impact religion has on sleep quality

June 13, 2018
Can a person's religious practices impact their sleep quality? That's the focus of a new study by Christopher Ellison in The University of Texas at San Antonio (UTSA) Department of Sociology and his collaborators.

Mediterranean-style eating with lean, unprocessed red meat improves heart disease risk

June 13, 2018
Adopting a Mediterranean-style eating pattern improves heart health, with or without reducing red meat intake, if the red meat consumed is lean and unprocessed, according to a Purdue University nutrition study.

Sleeping too much or not enough may have bad effects on health

June 12, 2018
Fewer than six and more than ten hours of sleep per day are associated with metabolic syndrome and its individual components, according to a study published in the open access journal BMC Public Health that involved 133,608 ...

American toddlers consume too much added sugar

June 11, 2018
A new study suggests children in the US begin consuming added sugar at a very young age and that many toddlers' sugar intake exceeds the maximum amount recommended for adults.

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

IronhorseA
not rated yet Aug 02, 2017
"Self-determined forms of motivation are much better in encouraging people to engage in a particular behaviour."

Essentially, competition is not the be all end all of existence. And, more importantly, the few who do get to the top aren't enough, by themselves, to carry the weight of the world forward. Maybe it's time to have a competition for ideas to replace competition.
EmceeSquared
not rated yet Aug 05, 2017
Children need guidance and discipline in order to learn to apply themselves consistently.

Parents spending £100 on an object is no substitute for that, and evidently has the opposite effect.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.