Surgical residents adapt to flexible shift hours

August 10, 2017 by Will Doss, Northwestern University

Surgical residents across the country have grown accustomed to less restrictive shift lengths, according to new findings published in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM). The research explored implications from a Northwestern Medicine study also published in NEJM, which found in 2016 that flexible duty hour requirements were safe for patients and improved resident education.

"We're not allowing residents to work more hours, we're just rearranging their hours within the set limits to improve patient care and resident education," said Karl Bilimoria, MD, MS, John B. Murphy Professor of Surgery and director of the Surgical Outcomes and Quality Improvement Center.

Bilimoria was the senior author of the current publication, and was also the lead author on the 2016 study.

Over the past two decades, the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) introduced restrictions on resident shift length and capped duty hours to 80 hours per week, in response to concerns about patient safety and resident well-being. However, these reforms also caused unintended consequences to and resident training, according to Bilimoria.

"We saw residents leave the operating room mid-procedure because their duty hour clock was up, or be forced to go home in the middle of stabilizing a critically ill patient in the ICU because they didn't have any hours left," Bilimoria said. "That's not what anybody wants—we want some reasonable standards in place, while having the flexibility to take care of ."

In the 2016 study, Bilimoria's team designed a trial involving 117 surgical residency programs across the U.S., allowing half of the participating institutions to waive rules on maximum shift lengths and time off between shifts by applying for exemption waivers. After a year, the flexible programs showed no change in patient safety or quality of care. Meanwhile, residents at those institutions reported improved continuity of care, surgical training and professionalism.

They did report that these flexible policies had a negative effect on leisure or time with family and friends, but they appeared willing to make the sacrifice.

"We asked them to pick which kind of program they preferred and only 14 percent chose the current standard duty hour policies," Bilimoria said. "They aren't dissatisfied by flexible duty hours, and this shows that they are willing to make the tradeoff."

The ACGME took notice of the results, forming a task force to evaluate the concept further and officially adopting the flexible duty hours policy on July 1, 2017.

Bilimoria and colleagues extended the trial by another year to investigate if residents' perceptions of well-being changed in the second year of the trial. In the current study, the scientists found fewer trainees reported negative effects stemming from flexible duty hours in year two when compared to year one.

"They got used to it, they started to accept it more, it's what we suspected might happen," Bilimoria said. "We actually saw the waivers being utilized a little less."

The extra year of experience as a resident may have also contributed to the growing acceptance, according to Bilimoria.

"You realize how important it is to stay to take care of the same patient and to be available," he said. "When you first get there you probably don't realize why you have a pager or why you're on call so much, but over time, you gain an appreciation of why you always want to be available."

Next, Bilimoria is planning on investigating other resident safety issues he stumbled upon during the course of the duty hours study. Needle stick rates were higher than they should be, Bilimoria said, so additional training and systems to prevent them should be implemented. Another issue relates to fatigue and burnout, which may contribute to safety issues for residents outside the hospital.

Explore further: General surgery residents prefer flexible work hours for patient care, education

More information: Allison R. Dahlke et al. Surgical Residents' Work Hours and Well-Being in Year 2 of the FIRST Trial, New England Journal of Medicine (2017). DOI: 10.1056/NEJMc1703812

Related Stories

General surgery residents prefer flexible work hours for patient care, education

November 14, 2016
CHICAGO (November 14, 2016): U.S. general surgery residents strongly prefer work hour policies that allow them the flexibility to work longer when needed to provide patient care over standard, more restrictive work schedules, ...

Extending length of surgical trainees' shifts does not affect surgical patients' safety

February 2, 2016
Allowing surgeons in training, otherwise known as residents, the flexibility to work longer shifts than currently allowed in the U.S. and/or take less time off between shifts to provide continuity of patient care is not associated ...

Restricting surgical residents' hours doesn't improve outcomes

December 9, 2014
Controversial restrictions on hospital residents' duty hours imposed in 2011 did not improve surgery patients' outcomes, reports a large new Northwestern Medicine study of U.S. hospitals, one of the first national evaluations ...

Patient care and safety are priorities for surgery residents who work flexible schedules

November 21, 2016
U.S. general surgery residents are selectively making the choice to work additional hours when needed to manage critical stages in patient care, according to results from a national survey conducted as part of the Flexibility ...

Surgery residency program directors believe flexible duty hours improve continuity of care

April 4, 2016
Directors of general surgery residency programs believe that flexible work hour schedules for surgeons in training (residents) improve the continuity of patient care as well as resident training without compromising patient ...

Rules allowing longer shifts for first-year doctors signal a new approach to evidence-based medical education

April 5, 2017
The long shifts and sleepless nights of resident physicians have been controversial since 1984, when 18-year old Libby Zion died in a New York hospital under the care of what her father alleged were overworked medical residents. ...

Recommended for you

1 in 9 U.S. adults over 45 reports memory problems

July 13, 2018
(HealthDay)—If you're middle-aged and you think you're losing your memory, you're not alone, a new U.S. government report shows.

Antioxidant benefits of sleep

July 12, 2018
Understanding sleep has become increasingly important in modern society, where chronic loss of sleep has become rampant and pervasive. As evidence mounts for a correlation between lack of sleep and negative health effects, ...

Footwear habits influence child and adolescent motor skill development

July 11, 2018
New research finds that children and adolescents who spend most of their time barefoot develop motor skills differently from those who habitually wear shoes. Published in Frontiers in Pediatrics, this is the first study to ...

How a Mediterranean diet could reduce osteoporosis

July 11, 2018
Eating a Mediterranean-type diet could reduce bone loss in people with osteoporosis—according to new research from the University of East Anglia.

Extreme heat and reduced cognitive performance in adults in non-air-conditioned buildings

July 10, 2018
Students who lived in dormitories without air conditioning (AC) during a heat wave performed worse on a series of cognitive tests compared with students who lived in air-conditioned dorms, according to new research led by ...

Suppressing negative emotions during health scare may whip up spiral of fear

July 10, 2018
Trying to suppress worries during a health scare, like the recent Zika outbreak, may lead to an ever-intensifying cycle of emotional suppression and fear, according to a team of researchers.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.