Women need more freedom during labour, not a medicalised birth script to follow

March 8, 2018 by Alys Bethan Einion, The Conversation
Everyone is born to someone, so birth is everyone’s business – or so it seems. Credit: Dariia Pavlova/Shutterstock

Countless women around the world give birth to babies without medical intervention in this natural process. For them, the most valuable care is the constant presence of a midwife or other skilled attendant who creates an environment which supports their hormonal and physical processes.

Midwives, the experts in physiological, undisturbed birth, have been providing – and arguing for – the supportive care of birthing mothers for decades. However, while they want to exercise their professional autonomy in order to give care which centres around the mother's individual needs – during what can be a risky time – they are increasingly battling with their employers and a professional blame culture to do so. Strict time limits on labour progress and so-called "active management of labour" intervenes in the natural process, with the aim of preventing labour delay.

But there is evidence – both clinical and experiential – which shows that labour and birth cannot be rigidly regarded as universal, mechanised processes defined by clinical parameters. Now, a new guideline from the World Health Organization (WHO) has definitively stated that ' approach to caring for and supporting in childbirth must change to recognise this.

But surprising as this notion may be, a more humanistic model of care is difficult to implement. The WHO acknowledges that the main reason for this is the increasing medicalisation of natural childbirth processes. The "birth script" – which involves repeated use of a particular type of language (such as "failure to progress") and habitual interventions (for example, routine electronic monitoring) sets doctors and midwives as the experts and holders of the mysterious and specialist knowledge of birth.

The system gives them the control and power over women, and means they may intervene when it is not necessary or indicated by the mother. They control the experience of birth by presenting choices, chances and clinical indicators in ways which do not reinforce or even indicate the fact that the majority of births can happen with little intervention.

Freedom to decide

Research shows that how midwives and doctors communicate with women makes them more likely to make choices which are in line with the professionals' preferences. The way that things are phrased seems to pressure individuals towards certain choices. For example, using the phrase "we just need to" makes it harder for a woman to say no to intervention.

These professional preferences are often grounded in a culture of risk which does not seem to support autonomy in childbirth or respect women's ability to make their own decisions. Simply changing the language used by medical professionals when talking to and about expectant mothers can change all this, however. One glaring example is how women are referred to as "the labourer" or told about "the induction". They are people and should be referred to as such.

This idea is supported by NICE guidelines, which advise midwives and doctors to communicate in a way that creates a "culture of respect" for the birthing woman. Under this advice, she is recognised as being the person in control of the situation, not the professionals.

While having this enshrined in a guideline is helpful, it is also a damning indication of the current state of the culture of obstetrics and midwifery. At present, women do not have the freedom to make decisions without being pressured into taking certain options – such as declining invasive examinations in labour, or into giving birth in certain places – because it is believed to be in their best interests.

Informed choices

Midwives and obstetricians cannot avoid the fact that they need to look closely at their own practices and change the ways that they communicate. Research has shown that changing the "birth script" enables the birthing woman to understand their innate ability to birth without intervention, and make informed choices that are in line with their own needs and preferences. It can also help mothers to adapt to changing circumstances during birth, and cope better on the rare occasions that valuable is needed, so that they still have a positive birth experience.

During pregnancy and birth, women are being disempowered during their encounters with medical professionals. The new WHO guidelines are a welcome change, but we need to make sure they are followed. Professionals must become aware of the power of their behaviour and communication during birth, and give childbearing women the opportunity and right to become more knowledgeable about what they are going through. Women must be able to make appropriate, informed decisions for themselves while accessing the safety net of expert knowledge and care.

It may be a potentially radical shift for some healthcare providers – away from a medicalised model of viewing in terms of risk – but the recommended practice of respectful care will give women the care and support they want as well as need.

Explore further: WHO revises childbirth guidelines to curb caesarean delivery surge

Related Stories

WHO revises childbirth guidelines to curb caesarean delivery surge

February 15, 2018
The UN health agency said Thursday it has revised a benchmark used by health professionals worldwide in caring for women during childbirth because it has caused a surge in interventions like caesarean sections that could ...

Does mum have the final say? New study reveals confusion in maternity care

May 2, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—A study from The University of Queensland has highlighted the tension doctors and midwives experience when supporting women's right to decide what happens to them and their babies.

More training key to water births

December 2, 2015
Mandatory training for midwives in facilitating water births could help banish a stigma that is attached to the birthing practice, according to a Perth midwife.

Opinion: Why we need to support Aboriginal women's choice to give birth on country

June 15, 2016
Around 9.6 out of every 1,000 Aboriginal babies are stillborn, or die in childbirth or the first 28 days of life, compared with 8.1 non-Aboriginal babies. Getting maternity care right for Aboriginal women is critical to closing ...

Explainer: What are women's options for giving birth?

July 1, 2016
For many women, getting pregnant is the easy part. After that line appears on the pregnancy test, it can be difficult to work out who to visit for care, and where you should have your baby.

Research finds women are being steered toward 'routine acceptance of induction' in labour

January 18, 2018
New research, conducted by academics at the University of Hertfordshire, has found that women are not always getting enough information from their midwives and antenatal classes about what to expect during induction, or the ...

Recommended for you

Undiagnosed STIs can increase negative PMS symptoms

September 17, 2018
Women that have undiagnosed sexually transmitted infections may be at greater risk of experiencing negative premenstrual symptoms (PMS), according to new Oxford University research.

High dose folic acid does not prevent pre-eclampsia in high risk women

September 13, 2018
Taking high dose folic acid supplements in later pregnancy (beyond the first trimester) does not prevent pre-eclampsia in women at high risk for this condition, finds a randomised controlled trial published by The BMJ today.

Study finds air purifiers may benefit fetal growth

September 12, 2018
A new study led by SFU health sciences researchers Prabjit Barn and Ryan Allen reveals fetal growth may improve if pregnant women use portable air purifiers inside their homes.

Delayed childbearing is a growing source of multiple births, study shows

September 12, 2018
Starting in the 1980s, the number of multiple births—twins, triplets, quadruplets and quintuplets—steadily increased from about 20 sets per 1,000 live births to almost 35 sets per 1,000 live births in the 2010s.

Transforming pregnancy research with a smartphone app

September 5, 2018
For years, pregnant women have been underrepresented in biomedical research. Current treatments, interventions and guidelines do a poor job of taking into consideration the diverse characteristics of all pregnant women.

For women undergoing IVF, is fresh or frozen embryo transfer best?

August 21, 2018
The world's first baby born via in-vitro fertilization turned 40 years old this summer. Still, after four decades, IVF is a relatively new field with ongoing debate on how to get the best results for families who have placed ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.