Research shows in the long run, charcoal toothpaste likely won't whiten teeth

April 30, 2018, Creighton University

Using charcoal toothpaste to whiten teeth may leave a person with more issues than just ash in the mouth.

While the latest dental fad has gotten high marks from celebrities, a group of Creighton University School of Dentistry students has spent the past year taking a more in-depth look at how well charcoal toothpaste whitens and what detrimental effects such an abrasive substance could have on teeth. The students, all in their first year of dental school, presented their findings at a research seminar at the Boyne Building, April 24.

"It's been a big trend," said Jon Howell, one of six students on the project, which was overseen by School of Dentistry professors Donal Scheidel, DDS, Sonia Rocha-Sanchez, Ph.D. and Martha Nunn, DDS, Ph.D. "You see a lot of patients coming into a dentist's office and asking about it and wondering if and how it works, so we thought it was worth looking into."

The short answer as to whether charcoal toothpaste—at upwards of $7 a tube—works, Howell and his research partners said, is "No."

"You might use it to get rid of some surface stains on the teeth from something like coffee," Howell said. "Initially, it might help. But, as our experiments have demonstrated, there'll be a cost."

That cost is in a pronounced wearing away of tooth enamel under the harsh scrubbing of the gritty charcoal. Under lab conditions simulating extended use of charcoal toothpaste through of brushing for six minutes every day, the students observed a significant loss of enamel and watched as the toothpaste made its way into the dentin of the teeth used in the experiment, leaving them with a gray to a yellow shade. The bottom line is: continuous use of charcoal tooth paste has proven to cause the very discoloration most people are hoping to ward off when they first start using it.

Using an electron microscope in some trials, the students were also able to see the level of abrasion on .

"Enamel does not grow back," said Ben Huber, another researcher. "And once the charcoal gets into the dentin, the teeth start to get gray."

Compared with more traditional whitening methods like whitening strips or regular whitening toothpaste, the charcoal seemed to be a bit of a risk, in the researchers' opinions.

"There are other tooth-whitening options that could be safer and more effective," Howell said.

As it turns out, for all its seeming trendiness, the whitening method isn't new to this century.

Josh Hanson, another of the researchers, said patricians in Ancient Rome used the stuff to clean their . It was just one of many methods the Romans happened upon in the longstanding quest for pearlier whites.

"They also tried limestone," Hanson said. "In fact, if you look on some ingredient labels, you'll see bicarbonate, which the Romans discovered in limestone as a cleaning agent. So maybe something was working there."

Explore further: Toothpaste alone does not prevent dental erosion or hypersensitivity

Related Stories

Toothpaste alone does not prevent dental erosion or hypersensitivity

March 14, 2018
The rising prevalence of dental erosion and dentin hypersensitivity has led to the emergence of more toothpastes that claim to treat these problems. While no such toothpaste existed 20 years ago, today, many such brands are ...

New toothpaste uses latest research to put minerals back into teeth

September 20, 2017
Most people regard glass as being chemically stable and inert. This is certainly the case for the type of glass used in windows, which importantly, doesn't dissolve in the rain.

Recommended for you

Oral cancer prognostic signature identified

December 5, 2018
Researchers in Brazil have identified a correlation between oral cancer progression and the abundance of certain proteins present in tumor tissue and saliva. The discovery offers a parameter for predicting progression of ...

Much-needed new antibiotic shows great promise for treating gum disease

October 23, 2018
A new antibiotic being developed at the University of Virginia School of Medicine appears ideal for battling periodontal disease, the leading cause of tooth loss in adults, according to dental researchers at Virginia Commonwealth ...

Researchers identify immune culprits linked to inflammation and bone loss in gum disease

October 17, 2018
An unhealthy population of microbes in the mouth triggers specialized immune cells that inflame and destroy tissues, leading to the type of bone loss associated with a severe form of gum disease, according to a new study ...

Periodontal disease bacteria may kick-start Alzheimer's

October 4, 2018
Long-term exposure to periodontal disease bacteria causes inflammation and degeneration of brain neurons in mice that is similar to the effects of Alzheimer's disease in humans, according to a new study from researchers at ...

Dental research shows that smoking weakens immune systems

September 26, 2018
As if lung cancer, emphysema and heart disease weren't enough, there's more bad news for cigarette smokers.

Regrowing dental tissue with stem cells from baby teeth

September 11, 2018
Sometimes kids trip and fall, and their teeth take the hit. Nearly half of children suffer some injury to a tooth during childhood. When that trauma affects an immature permanent tooth, it can hinder blood supply and root ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.