Answering a medical mystery: Why are vaccines less effective in the developing world?

May 29, 2018, University of Minnesota
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

It's a question that has challenged scientists and physicians for years: Why do vaccines work better in some parts of the world than in others? A new study, led in part by University of Minnesota Medical School researcher Tim Schacker, MD, contributes to knowledge about why vaccines given in the developing world often are less effective than in the developed world.

The study, to be published in the Journal of Clinical Investigation, finds that diseases common in the developing world might be a culprit. For example, malaria, tuberculosis and infections caused by parasites may damage lymph node structures that are crucial to developing immunity after a vaccine.

"One of the unanswered questions in is why some vaccines work well in the developed world but very poorly in the developing world—especially in more tropical climates. We wanted to know whether environmental factors or pervasive infections in developing areas were making vaccines less effective," says Schacker, a professor of infectious diseases and international medicine and director of the Program in HIV Medicine at the University of Minnesota. "Our research suggests that having certain diseases does affect the body's ability to prompt immune protection after a vaccine."

For the study, researchers evaluated groups of people from Uganda and the United States. They found that the Ugandans have significantly higher levels of inflammation in their bodies and a depleted supply of protective T cells. Their secondary lymph nodes, where vaccine responses happen, had fibrosis or thickening and scarring from the inflammation.

Schacker's research uncovered significant differences in the lymphoid anatomy between subjects in Uganda and the United States. Every Ugandan participant showed evidence of differences in the anatomy of their secondary lymph nodes compared to participants in the United States. These differences include fibrosis, increased immune activation and other anatomy changes that would be considered abnormal in the United States.

With this evidence in hand, researchers then explored whether such differences hindered the Ugandans' response to vaccinations. They gave Ugandans a yellow fever vaccination and monitored them for 60 weeks, seeking to determine whether their lymphoid abnormalities were associated with immune dysfunction. In addition, they found correlations between the Ugandans' limited antibody response to the vaccine and the amount of damage from inflammation and fibrosis in the lymph nodes. "We showed that the degree to which these tissues were damaged by inflammation was significantly associated with the response to a vaccine," Schacker says. "This suggests that common infections in the developing world may be an important limiting factor in the development of immune response to a ."

"We believe that these data have important implications for how vaccines are designed and tested for infections that greatly impact the ," he adds. "This is especially true of vaccines for HIV, malaria, and TB—diseases that are responsible for the greatest number of deaths."

Explore further: How intestinal worms hinder tuberculosis vaccination

Related Stories

How intestinal worms hinder tuberculosis vaccination

May 17, 2018
New research in mice suggests that chronic infection with intestinal worms indirectly reduces the number of cells in lymph nodes near the skin, inhibiting the immune system's response to the Bacille Calmette-Guerin (BCG) ...

Researchers detect protein that increases effectiveness of vaccines

April 7, 2017
Researchers have discovered a protein they believe would help make vaccinations more effective and provide protection from other diseases such as cancer.

'Bystander' chronic infections thwart development of immune cell memory

May 15, 2014
Studies of vaccine programs in the developing world have revealed that individuals with chronic infections such as malaria and hepatitis tend to be less likely to develop the fullest possible immunity benefits from vaccines ...

Hitchhiking vaccines boost immunity

February 17, 2014
Many vaccines, including those for influenza, polio, and measles, consist of a killed or disabled version of a virus. However, for certain diseases, this type of vaccine is ineffective, or just too risky.

Recommended for you

Tibetan sheep highly susceptible to human plague, originates from marmots

August 16, 2018
In the Qinghai-Tibet plateau, one of the region's highest risk areas for human plague, Himalayan marmots are the primary carriers of the infectious bacterium Y. pestis. Y. pestis infection can be transmitted to humans and ...

Autoimmunity plays role in development of COPD, study finds

August 16, 2018
Autoimmunity plays a role in the development of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), according to a study led by Georgia State University and Vanderbilt University Medical Center that analyzed human genome information ...

Reliable point-of-care blood test can help prevent toxoplasmosis

August 16, 2018
A recent study, performed in Chicago and Rabat, Morocco, found that a novel finger-prick test for infection with the parasite Toxoplasma gondii during pregnancy—and many other potential applications—is 100 percent sensitive ...

Scientists identify nearly 200 potential tuberculosis drug targets

August 16, 2018
Tuberculosis is one of the top 10 causes of death worldwide. Nearly 2 million people die every year from this infectious disease, and an estimated 2 billion people are chronically infected. The only vaccine, developed almost ...

First mouse model to mimic lung disease could speed discovery of more effective treatments

August 16, 2018
The biggest hurdle to finding effective therapies for idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) – a life-threatening condition in which the lungs become scarred and breathing is increasingly difficult – has been the inability ...

Anticancer drug offers potential alternative to transplant for patients with liver failure

August 15, 2018
Patients suffering sudden liver failure could in the future benefit from a new treatment that could reduce the need for transplants, research published today shows.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Vicente_Cif
not rated yet May 31, 2018
"..Why do vaccines work better in some parts of the world than in others?..". Vaccines don't work anywhere, but since the standard of living in the West is so high, we only notice vaccine failure in the third world where the true factors that control infectious diseases are missing

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.