Why cancer patients won't find a cure in drinking human milk they get online

July 20, 2018 by Sarah Steele, The Conversation
Freezer stash of frozen breast milk. Credit: MISS TREECHADA YOKSAN/Shutterstock.com

In 1995, scientists at Lund University in Sweden made a serendipitous discovery while looking for new antibiotics. They found that by altering a protein in human milk, producing a complex they called HAMLET (Human Alpha-lactalbumin Made LEthal to Tumour cells), they could destroy some cancer cells, leaving healthy cells unharmed.

Since then, the tumour-fighting effects of HAMLET have been demonstrated in several animal studies. It has been shown to limit the progression of brain tumours, colon cancer and bladder cancer in mice.

It wasn't until last year, though, that the popular press caught up with these developments. A promising proof-of-concept study in humans with bladder cancer led to breathless headlines describing as an "accidental cure for cancer".

An unintended side effect of this coverage was a surge of people looking to buy human online, hoping that it will cure their illness. The trend resulted in an upsurge in use of the social media tag #freezerstash by adult consumers. Others turned to commercial sale sites, desperately pleading for donations to save loved ones. One woman even sought human milk for her family dog, which had been diagnosed with cancer.

While much of the online trade is for infant feeding, some adults are seeking human milk in the hope that it will cure their, or their loved one's, illness. Others see the milk as a complementary therapy – a supplement to take alongside conventional treatments, or during palliative care. And some see it as a nutritionally rich drink, with immune-boosting properties, that is more digestible than commercially available milk. It is seen as a "clean eat" – unlike industrially produced cow's milk or soya – and thus safer.

Much of this information is wrong.

Misunderstanding the science

First, the HAMLET study did not involve drinking human milk. For human milk to fight tumours, the protein needs to be altered, which scientists have done by partly unfolding the protein and adding a fatty acid to it. Without this process, specifically the inserted fatty acid, you only have the alpha-lactalbumin protein, not HAMLET. In short, you need a laboratory, not just a pump and some freezer bags off eBay.

Second, while human milk is optimal nutrition for babies and toddlers, offering them immunological benefits, the adult gut functions in such a way that many of these benefits are lost. The adult stomach is higher in acid and also has different and more enzymes that are harsher to human milk. As a result, adults don't get the same benefits as infants. Adults need more diverse foods to get all the essential nutrients.

Third, drinking people's #freezerstash can be risky, exposing consumers to bacterial, viral and contaminant risks. Human milk isn't a "clean eat" in the way many suggest.

While many offering milk online state that they are well, not taking medicines or caffeine, eating particular diets (such as organic, vegan or vegetarian) and storing the milk in their freezer, this doesn't mean the milk is safe or "clean". As with any food or drink, bacteria are present, and those causing food-borne illness can easily grow when human milk is not collected, stored or handled correctly.

Online posts suggest greatly variable collection, storage and transit processes – as confirmed by a reporter from The Sun whose purchase arrived in a gravy tin.

Also, while well-meaning mothers may be pumping and offering their milk with the best intentions, they may expose those who are unwell to viruses. While some online traders mention that they have been tested for HIV and are also free from other infections, this overlooks common viruses – such as Cytomegalovirus – that can make it into the milk and can have a profound effect on those who are unwell.

Many healthy people are infected with Cytomegalovirus and have few or no symptoms – but, for those with a weakened immune system, this virus can cause serious diseases, including pneumonia and swelling of the brain.

Human milk from milk banks is pasteurised and tested for pathogens, but human milk traded online isn't subject to the same tests.

Getting milk online for unwell is not worth the risks. People who claim that human milk can cure are giving false hope – and many are making a tidy profit off the back of this false hope. While research suggests human milk may have medical uses, these will be found in the lab and the clinic, not with a #freezerstash.

Explore further: Breast milk consumption trending among body builders

Related Stories

Breast milk consumption trending among body builders

February 19, 2015
(HealthDay)—Some bodybuilders are drinking human breast milk in the mistaken belief it will give a boost to their muscles.

Does breast milk boost athletic performance in adults or cure cancer?

October 5, 2017
Does breast milk boost athletic performance in adults or cure cancer? Or is this all just a weird internet fetish?

The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine issues guidance on informal milk sharing

January 8, 2018
In response to the increasing informal sharing of human milk, the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine (ABM) has published guidelines to minimize the risk of this practice while enhancing the health benefits. The position statement ...

CDC issues warning on contaminated raw milk

November 22, 2017
(HealthDay)—Individuals who may have consumed contaminated raw milk and milk products from the Udder Milk company are urged to seek medical care, according to a report published by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and ...

Adult craze for human breast milk purchased online poses serious health risks

June 17, 2015
The recent craze for human breast milk amongst certain fitness communities, fetishists and chronic disease sufferers is ill advised say the authors of an editorial published today by the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. ...

Recommended for you

Healthy diet linked to healthy cellular aging in women

August 20, 2018
Eating a diet that is rich in fruits, vegetables and whole grains and low in added sugar, sodium and processed meats could help promote healthy cellular aging in women, according to a new study published in the American Journal ...

'Liquid biopsy' predicts lymphoma therapy success within days, study finds

August 20, 2018
A blood test can predict which patients with a type of cancer called diffuse large B cell lymphoma are likely to respond positively to initial therapy and which are likely to need more aggressive treatment, according to a ...

Study shows how to make (and destroy) a metastatic cancer cell

August 20, 2018
Many cancers become especially dangerous only when they metastasize from their site of origin to faraway tissues such as lung, brain or bone. Now, a University of Colorado Cancer Center study published today in the Proceedings ...

Research team develops predictor for immunotherapy response in melanoma

August 20, 2018
In a new study, researchers developed a gene expression predictor that can indicate whether melanoma in a specific patient is likely to respond to treatment with immune checkpoint inhibitors, a novel type of immunotherapy. ...

Sitting for long hours found to reduce blood flow to the brain

August 20, 2018
A team of researchers with Liverpool John Moores University in the U.K. has found evidence of reduced blood flow to the brain in people who sit for long periods of time. In their paper published in the Journal of Applied ...

Balanced advice needed to address 'screen time' for children, study shows

August 20, 2018
Parents, health professionals and educators need clear and balanced information to help manage young children's use of mobile touch-screen devices in Australia, new research by Curtin University has found.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.