Drug and alcohol use by pregnant women: the evolution of state policies

August 20, 2018, Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation

Policymakers and public health experts have long recognized the harm that can come to fetuses if women use drugs during pregnancy. As U.S. states legalize marijuana and as governmental attention focuses on the "opioid crisis," state policies pertaining to drug use during pregnancy are increasingly important. A new study examines the scope of state policies targeting drug use during pregnancy, how they have evolved, and how they compare to policies related to alcohol use during pregnancy.

The researchers examined all statutes and regulations in U.S. states pertaining to drug and alcohol use by pregnant from 1970-2016, the entire period during which states legislated in these areas.

Laws included in the analysis were:

  • mandatory warning signs
  • priority access to for pregnant women
  • requirements to report evidence of drug use during pregnancy to law enforcement or child welfare agencies— or to a health authority for the purposes of data gathering and treatment
  • laws that define drug use during pregnancy as child abuse/child neglect
  • laws that limit toxicological tests as evidence in criminal prosecutions of fetal or child harm
  • mandatory involuntary commitment of pregnant women to treatment or to protective custody.

Policies were analyzed individually as well as classified as punitive toward or supportive of women. Punitive policies seek to control pregnant women's behavior through threats of sanctions. Supportive policies seek to provide information, early intervention, and treatment and services to them.

Key Findings:

Drug/Pregnancy Policy

  • The number of states with 1 or more drug/ pregnancy policies has increased substantially since 1970.
  • As of 2016, the number of states with either punitive or mixed policy environments is 31; 12 states have supportive policies; 8 states have no policy.
  • The most widely adopted supportive between 1970 and 2016 require reporting for data collection and/or treatment for women.
  • The most widely adopted punitive policies were reporting requirements to CPS and defining drug use during pregnancy as child abuse/child neglect.
  • The smallest increases from 1970 to 2016 were for the supportive policy of priority treatment for pregnant women (or pregnant women and women with children) and the punitive policy of civil commitment.
  • Drug use during pregnancy policy environments have become less supportive over time. As of 2016, few states are supportive-only.

Comparing Drug/Pregnancy Policy to Alcohol Pregnancy Policy

  • The most frequent drug use during pregnancy policies are punitive, and the most frequent alcohol/pregnancy policies are supportive. Yet, when factoring in mandatory signage laws (24 for alcohol; 2 for drugs—recreational cannabis), there is not a great deal of difference between the remaining types policies
  • The policy that could provide the most direct services to pregnant women—priority treatment laws are few whether the policy pertains to drugs or alcohol. For example, priority treatment for pregnant women with children is the least represented alcohol/pregnancy policy. For drug/pregnancy policies, only 5 have priority treatment for women with children.

One implication of the trend toward punitive and alcohol/ policies is that that research to date shows that they deter from seeking prenatal care and substance abuse . They also disproportionately negatively affect women of color.

Explore further: How do state policies on alcohol use affect pregnant women and infants?

More information: Sue Thomas et al, Drug Use During Pregnancy Policies in the United States From 1970 to 2016, Contemporary Drug Problems (2018). DOI: 10.1177/0091450918790790

Related Stories

How do state policies on alcohol use affect pregnant women and infants?

July 6, 2018
It is well known that if women drink while they are pregnant, they increase the chances that children may be affected by alcohol, including a broad range of serious defects referred to as Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder. ...

Don't punish pregnant women for opioid use, docs say

February 20, 2017
(HealthDay)—Prevention and treatment, not legal action, should be the focus when dealing with pregnant women who use opioids, a leading pediatricians' group says.

Thyroid dysfunction may lead to diabetes during pregnancy

June 7, 2018
Women with thyroid dysfunction in the first half of pregnancy face an increased risk for gestational diabetes, a form of diabetes that is typically diagnosed during the second trimester, according to a new study published ...

Many women still smoke during pregnancy

May 10, 2012
(HealthDay) -- Too many American women still smoke during their pregnancies, a new report finds, and rates of such smoking vary widely depending on race.

Medicaid coverage for methadone improves treatment for opioid use disorder in pregnancy

November 14, 2017
Pregnant women with opioid use disorder (OUD) are more likely to receive evidence-based treatment with an "opioid agonist"—usually methadone—in states where those medications are covered by Medicaid, reports a study in ...

Norwegian women drink least while pregnant, British women drink most

April 12, 2017
A study among over 7000 women in 11 European countries shows the proportion of women in Europe who drink alcohol when they know they are pregnant is lowest in Norway and highest in the UK. The countries with the highest proportion ...

Recommended for you

Undiagnosed STIs can increase negative PMS symptoms

September 17, 2018
Women that have undiagnosed sexually transmitted infections may be at greater risk of experiencing negative premenstrual symptoms (PMS), according to new Oxford University research.

High dose folic acid does not prevent pre-eclampsia in high risk women

September 13, 2018
Taking high dose folic acid supplements in later pregnancy (beyond the first trimester) does not prevent pre-eclampsia in women at high risk for this condition, finds a randomised controlled trial published by The BMJ today.

Study finds air purifiers may benefit fetal growth

September 12, 2018
A new study led by SFU health sciences researchers Prabjit Barn and Ryan Allen reveals fetal growth may improve if pregnant women use portable air purifiers inside their homes.

Delayed childbearing is a growing source of multiple births, study shows

September 12, 2018
Starting in the 1980s, the number of multiple births—twins, triplets, quadruplets and quintuplets—steadily increased from about 20 sets per 1,000 live births to almost 35 sets per 1,000 live births in the 2010s.

Transforming pregnancy research with a smartphone app

September 5, 2018
For years, pregnant women have been underrepresented in biomedical research. Current treatments, interventions and guidelines do a poor job of taking into consideration the diverse characteristics of all pregnant women.

For women undergoing IVF, is fresh or frozen embryo transfer best?

August 21, 2018
The world's first baby born via in-vitro fertilization turned 40 years old this summer. Still, after four decades, IVF is a relatively new field with ongoing debate on how to get the best results for families who have placed ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.