Breast cancer screening does not reduce mortality

September 13, 2018, Aarhus University
Three-dimensional culture of human breast cancer cells, with DNA stained blue and a protein in the cell surface membrane stained green. Image created in 2014 by Tom Misteli, Ph.D., and Karen Meaburn, Ph.D. at the NIH IRP.

Fewer women are dying from breast cancer in recent years, but surprisingly, this decline is just as large in the age groups that are not screened. The decline is therefore due to better breast cancer treatment and not attributable to screening. This is shown by a major Danish-Norwegian study titled "Effect of organised mammography screening on breast cancer mortality: A populationbased cohort study in Norway," which has just been published in the International Journal of Cancer.

In the study, the researchers followed all Norwegian women aged 30-89 and identified those who developed in the period 1987-2010, before subsequently comparing the number of deaths before and after the programme was introduced.

Associate Professor Henrik Støvring from Aarhus University, Denmark, notes that the result does not favour the breast cancer screening programme. This conclusion can also be transferred directly to Denmark (and elsewhere), where all women aged 50-69 are offered involving an X-ray examination of the chest every second year. The Danish screening programme was progressively introduced from the early 1990s and was offered nationally to everyone from 2007, three years after the Norwegians, who have supplied data for the Danish-Norwegian research project.

"The important result is that we do not find a beneficial effect of breast cancer screening any longer. The original randomised trials examining were conducted way back in the 1980s, and they showed an effect, but the fact is that the better the treatment methods become, the less benefit screening has," says Henrik Støvring, associate professor at the Department of Public Health with biostatistics and screening programmes as his particular areas of expertise.

Here, he points toward one of the paradoxes of screening—the popular but erroneous belief that if breast cancer patients who have been screened live longer than other breast cancer patients, then screening works. The problem is that with screening, medical doctors detect cancerous tumours earlier than they would otherwise have done, and thus move the point of diagnosis forward in time. But even if someone who has been screened lives longer as a patient, it is not certain that their life as a whole will be longer. It is important to account for this fact, and the new study shows that screening does not lead to women living longer overall—and this is the study's most important finding.

"The women who are invited to screening live longer because all live longer, and they do so because we now have better drugs and more effective chemotherapy, and because we have cancer care pathways, which means the healthcare system reacts faster than it did a decade ago. But it does not appear that fewer women die of breast cancer as a result of mammography screening," says Henrik Støvring.

He also points out that it is not always beneficial for a woman to be diagnosed with a tiny cancerous growth of a millimetre in diameter at a mammography, for instance. Some of these small nodules are so slow-growing that the woman would have died a so-called natural death with undiagnosed cancer if she had not been screened.

"Now, what happens is these women are instead given a diagnosis that isn't going to make anyone happier. Such a cancer diagnosis makes life more difficult and costs a lot of money, but does not ultimately make a difference. The problem is that we are not currently able to tell the difference between the small tumours that will kill you and those that will not," says Henrik Støvring.

Here, he addresses the issue of overdiagnosis, which is a growing problem in all Western countries where the approach to medicine and examinations is extensive and where national screening programmes are prevalent. The problem was discussed last week in Copenhagen, Denmark, where 450 researchers from 30 countries attended the Preventing Overdiagnosis 2018 conference.

Even though the research results challenge the current health policy in Denmark, Norway and the rest of the Western world, Henrik Støvring is not in the business of telling Danish politicians that they should stop the national screening programme here and now: "It's certainly not my task to decide how the research results should be used, but my suggestion would nonetheless be that we should get together and begin to investigate whether it would beneficial to do something other than screening and whether this could have a better effect. If a doctor could instead examine women's breasts via hand palpation at regular intervals, then we would avoid much of the overdiagnosis," says Henrik Støvring.

Explore further: Screening has had 'little impact' on falling breast cancer deaths in the Netherlands

More information: Mette H. Møller et al, Effect of organised mammography screening on breast cancer mortality: A population-based cohort study in Norway, International Journal of Cancer (2018). DOI: 10.1002/ijc.31832

Related Stories

Screening has had 'little impact' on falling breast cancer deaths in the Netherlands

December 5, 2017
Breast screening in the Netherlands seems to have had a marginal effect on breast cancer mortality over the past 24 years, suggests research in The BMJ today.

Screening does not shift breast cancer to earlier stages

March 4, 2014
Screening for breast cancer appeared to have a very limited effect on the occurrence of serious and aggressive cancer cases. On the other hand, it appeared to detect many more early cancer cases, cases which would otherwise ...

Computer simulation suggests risk-based breast screening could have benefits

July 6, 2018
When it comes to breast cancer screening, there's a delicate balance between the benefits and harms.

Why are women at high breast cancer risk not having supplemental MRI screening?

March 19, 2018
Women at high lifetime breast cancer risk might benefit from breast MRI screening in addition to routine mammography, but a new study shows that breast MRI is greatly underutilized even though access is widely available. ...

Breast cancer screening associated with substantial overdiagnosis in Danish study

January 9, 2017
Breast cancer screening in Denmark was associated with a substantial increase in the incidence of nonadvanced tumors and DCIS but not with a reduction in the incidence of advanced tumors. The rate of overdiagnosis was also ...

Recommended for you

Researchers find adult stem cell characteristics in aggressive cancers from different tissues

September 19, 2018
UCLA researchers have discovered genetic similarities between the adult stem cells responsible for maintaining and repairing epithelial tissues—which line all of the organs and cavities inside the body—and the cells that ...

Ketogenic diet reduces body fat in women with ovarian or endometrial cancer

September 19, 2018
Women with ovarian or endometrial cancer who followed the ketogenic diet for 12 weeks lost more body fat and had lower insulin levels compared to those who followed the low-fat diet recommended by the American Cancer Society, ...

Eating foods with low nutritional quality ratings linked to cancer risk in large European cohort

September 18, 2018
The consumption of foods with higher scores on the British Food Standards Agency nutrient profiling system (FSAm-NPS), reflecting a lower nutritional quality, is associated with an increased risk of developing cancer, according ...

Could the zika virus fight the brain cancer that killed john McCain?

September 18, 2018
(HealthDay)—Preliminary research in mice suggests that the Zika virus might be turned from foe into friend—enlisted to curb deadly glioblastoma brain tumors.

CRISPR screen reveals new targets in more than half of all squamous cell carcinomas

September 18, 2018
A little p63 goes a long way in embryonic development—and flaws in p63 can result in birth defects like cleft palette, fused fingers or even missing limbs. But once this early work is done, p63 goes silent, sitting quietly ...

Enlarged genotype-phenotype correlation for a three-base pair deletion in neurofibromatosis type 1

September 18, 2018
International collaborative research led by Ludwine Messiaen, Ph.D., shows that while a three-base pair, in-frame deletion called p.Met992del in the NF1 gene has a mild phenotype for people with the genetic disorder neurofibromatosis ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.