Despite changes to US kidney allocation system, inequality persists

September 18, 2018 by Lauren Ingeno, Drexel University

The implementation of a new U.S. kidney transplant allocation system did not solve many of the inequities that low-income and minority kidney disease patients face, Drexel University College of Medicine researchers found in a new study published recently in the journal Clinical Transplantation.

The study strengthens the argument that early disease diagnosis and preemptive waitlisting (being "listed" before requiring chronic ) remain the most effective strategies to improve survival chances—strategies that many of the country's most vulnerable populations still do not have access to.

Dialysis is a treatment needed when a person develops end stage kidney failure. When kidneys fail, dialysis keeps the body in balance by removing waste, helping to control blood pressure and regulating chemicals. Though dialysis can keep a person alive while waiting for a , the treatment is risky and comes with a slew of uncomfortable side effects.

"Dialysis time isn't like regular time. Waiting to pursue transplantation until a patient is already on dialysis is basically playing Russian roulette with their health," said study lead author Meera Nair Harhay, MD, a nephrologist and associate professor of medicine at Drexel's College of Medicine.

That's why it is best to receive an early diagnosis and explore transplant as a treatment right way. Then, you might be able to get a transplant "preemptively," without ever needing to start dialysis. However, the process of getting on a waitlist for a transplant—and avoiding dialysis—has for some time been skewed toward patients with a higher socio-economic status, access to better health insurance and primary care. Low-income and minority patients, by contrast, are disproportionately less likely to receive care for their disease early, and therefore spend much longer on dialysis.

In an effort to shrink this disparity, the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network made major changes to the deceased donor kidney allocation system in 2014. Before then, waiting time for kidney transplants universally started after a person was waitlisted, whether or not they had started dialysis.

"Minorities and the uninsured, who were less likely than white patients to be referred early for kidney transplant, used to have to wait even more years on dialysis before getting a transplant," said Harhay. "Dialysis has a lot of risks. People die, or their health status can worsen considerably."

Under the new system, kidney transplant candidates who are waitlisted after beginning dialysis get that dialysis time "credited" to their overall waiting time. For example, someone who endured five years of dialysis before going on the transplant waiting list would accrue five "priority points" and be elevated on the list. However, those with preemptive wait-listing still start their clock even earlier, accruing an extra priority point for every year they spend on the list.

While early studies showed that the new system was successful in closing the gap in transplant rates between waitlisted white and minority patients, the Drexel study authors wanted to look into other potential implications of the new rules. The researchers examined retrospective data, between 2011 to 2014 (before the allocation system changed) and 2014 to 2017 (after the change).

They found that after the new system was implemented, transplant recipients who were waitlisted before starting dialysis (who are overwhelmingly white) continued to receive transplants with three to four years less, on average, of dialysis exposure than their peers who were waitlisted after starting dialysis.

"You would expect that this new system would reshuffle the deck a bit and narrow this gap—so that someone who had been on dialysis for two or three years might get a kidney transplant before someone who has not started dialysis," Harhay said. "But we did not find that to be the case. The gap between those who were listed early and listed late is still quite wide."

Moreover, the system gives the highest quality kidneys to those who have had the least years on dialysis, opening the door to further disparities based on the timing of wait-listing.

Historically, patients who are preemptively listed for a transplant (before dialysis), have been found to have superior outcomes, compared to those listed after going on dialysis, due to both socioeconomic differences and the debilitating health impacts of prolonged dialysis exposure.

In the U.S, Medicare only provides health insurance for individuals with kidney disease after they start dialysis, so individuals who don't qualify for Medicare by age criteria have to rely on private insurance or Medicaid to be pre-emptively wait-listed. With the implementation of the ACA, states that expanded their Medicaid programs experienced a significant increase in preemptive listings of Medicaid beneficiaries, a previous study from Harhay and colleagues showed.

But even with expanded access to insurance, there are many other barriers to preemptive waitlisting for low-income and , Harhay said, including differences in access to high-quality primary care to ensure timely diagnosis of kidney disease and referral to kidney disease specialists.

"Our study shows that, even under the new allocation system, important equity issues remain in care," Harhay said. "I think we really need to be focusing on increasing awareness, long before dialysis is needed."

Explore further: Medicaid Expansion increased low-income patient access to kidney transplants

More information: Meera N. Harhay et al, Association of the kidney allocation system with dialysis exposure before deceased donor kidney transplantation by preemptive wait-listing status, Clinical Transplantation (2018). DOI: 10.1111/ctr.13386

Related Stories

Medicaid Expansion increased low-income patient access to kidney transplants

June 21, 2018
After states expanded Medicaid to cover more low-income individuals under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), there was a significant boost in the number of chronic kidney disease patients with Medicaid coverage who were placed ...

Method assesses how well dialysis clinics refer patients for transplantation

January 25, 2018
A new method may be useful for assessing dialysis facilities' performance concerning referrals to transplant centers. The method, which is described in an upcoming issue of the Clinical Journal of the American Society of ...

Disparities exist in kidney transplant timing

January 31, 2013
African-Americans and individuals without private health insurance are less likely than others to receive a kidney transplant before requiring dialysis, according to a study appearing in an upcoming issue of the Clinical ...

Race, insurance status related to likelihood of being assessed for kidney transplantation

July 26, 2012
Young black patients and patients without private health insurance are less likely to be assessed for a kidney transplant when they start dialysis, according to a study appearing in an upcoming issue of the Clinical Journal ...

Trained navigators may improve access to transplantation for disadvantaged patients

March 26, 2018
In a recent study, a trained navigator who provided guidance to disadvantaged patients with kidney failure helped increase access to the transplant waitlist among patients who needed a longer time to get through the transplant ...

Dialysis providers' awareness of racial disparities in transplantation is low

April 12, 2018
In a recent study of dialysis facilities with low rates of waitlisting for transplantation, healthcare providers' awareness of racial disparities in kidney transplant waitlisting was low. The findings, which appear in an ...

Recommended for you

Rapid response inpatient education boosts use of needed blood-thinning drugs

November 16, 2018
A new study designed to reach hospitalized patients at risk shows that a "real-time" educational conversation, video or leaflet can lower the missed dose rates of drugs that can prevent potentially lethal blood clots in their ...

Race plays role in regaining weight after gastric bypass surgery

November 15, 2018
African Americans and Hispanic Americans who have undergone Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) are at greater risk to regain weight as compared to Caucasians. To date, no study has addressed the effect of race on weight regain ...

Surgery, not antibiotics, should remain first-line treatment for appendicitis: study

November 14, 2018
Treating appendicitis with antibiotics as an alternative to surgical removal of the inflamed organ was found to be more costly in the long term and result in higher rates of hospital readmissions, according to a study by ...

Study finds that in treating obesity, one size does not fit all

November 13, 2018
Analyzing data from more than 2,400 obese patients who underwent bariatric weight-loss surgery, researchers identified at least four different patient subgroups that diverge significantly in eating behaviors and rate of diabetes, ...

Surgery patients use only 1/4 of prescribed opioids, and prescription size matters

November 7, 2018
Many surgeons write prescriptions for opioid pain medications four times larger than what their patients will actually use after common operations, a new study shows.

Minimally invasive surgery associated with worse survival for women with cervical cancer compared to open hysterectomy

October 31, 2018
When comparing standard-of-care surgical options for women with early-stage cervical cancer, two studies led by researchers at The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center discovered that minimally invasive radical hysterectomy ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.