Efforts to prevent pressure ulcers in hospitals may not be making headway on the worst kind

November 5, 2018, University of Michigan
Credit: Anne Lowe/public domain

Ask any patient who has ever had one: A bedsore hurts a lot. And if it doesn't heal, that sore can last for years, eating away at the flesh and leading to infections, sepsis or even death.

That's why hospitals have worked for years to reduce the chance that patients will develop such sores—also called pressure ulcers or pressure injuries—and to treat new ones quickly. It's also why Medicare pays less to hospitals with the highest hospital-acquired complication scores, which include hospital-acquired pressure ulcers or HAPUs.

But a new study shows important differences between two sources of data used to track the rates and progress of HAPUs. The hospital billing data used to calculate Medicare payment rates and penalties for hospitals may miss many of the HAPUs that patients are actually getting, the study finds.

And hospitals' progress in reducing HAPUs is almost entirely because they prevented less-costly and less dangerous early-stage HAPUs, and not the more severe kind, according to billing data.

In a new paper in the November issue of Health Affairs, the research team from the University of Michigan recommends better ways of tracking HAPUs for value-based purchasing policies. The program should use the same approach hospitals already use to track infections that patients develop during their stay, and adjust rates and penalties based on patients' underlying risk.

Better data will mean more valid penalties for HAPUs, which affect 2.5 million patients in the U.S. alone, lead to the deaths of about 60,000 of them a year, and cost about $10 billion to treat.

The senior author of the paper, Jennifer Meddings, M.D., M.Sc., will discuss the results at a Health Affairs event on Nov. 6 in Washington, D.C.

"We find that the data used for policy implementation doesn't support a 'victory lap' yet about the impact of efforts to reduce rates of severe HAPUs, specifically Stage 3 or 4 ones," she says. "There has been some change in pressure ulcer rates, to be sure, but not to the extent that many might have assumed."

The research team cites recent public reports of progress against HAPUs, which were based on surveillance chart review data from the Medicare Patient Safety Monitoring System that tracks trends in HAPUs and other hospital-acquired conditions.

Those reports found a decrease of 23 percent in the rate of HAPUs between 2010 and 2014, from 4 percent to just over 3 percent of inpatients, and concluded that this resulted in savings of more than $1 billion.

But the data used for these reports—which came from detailed medical chart reviews—aren't the same as the billing data used to carry out the federal hospital payment policies for HAPUs.

Meddings, first author Shawna Smith, Ph.D. and colleagues looked at billing data from patients in Florida, New York and Washington State, and calculated that HAPUs dropped 40 percent from 2009 to 2014. But this drop started from a much lower absolute incidence rate of 0.27 percent of patients, and fell to 0.16 percent of patients.

In other words, billing data used for policy purposes only captured about 1 out of every 20 HAPUs documented in chart review data.

Then, the researchers dug deeper, because the progress recently reported from the chart reviews did not distinguish between the most dangerous and expensive advanced stage HAPUs and less expensive, early stage HAPUs.

They found that 96 percent of the decline in HAPUs seen in the billing data happened because of a decline in reporting of early-stage (stage 1 and 2) sores. Advanced-stage HAPU rates remained steady at 0.04 percent, or 4 per 10,000 discharges.

However, these early stage HAPUs were also the kind that the federal government stopped using to adjust hospital payments from Medicare in 2008. Without a reason to put them on a patient's bill, it is difficult to know whether this decline captures a true reduction in the incidence of early stage HAPUs or simply that hospitals mostly stopped reporting them in billing data at all, which in turn led to the apparent rate reduction.

The researchers also looked at those patients whose records are excluded from current policies that use billing data, because of their higher risk of HAPUs due to conditions such as paralysis and spinal cord injury.

Among these higher-risk patients, billing data also showed that hospitals did make inroads between 2009 and 2014 in reducing rates of early-stage HAPUs—but rates of late-stage HAPUs in these high-risk patients stayed nearly constant.

"Prevention of stage 1 and 2 sores is important, because they can worsen to stages 3 and 4," Meddings explains. "But we expected to have been able to see changes in rates of stage 3 and 4 HAPUs also if hospitals were succeeding in preventing stage 1 and 2 sores. And for the most part, we didn't." Meddings is an associate professor of internal medicine and pediatrics at Michigan Medicine, U-M's academic medical center, and a patient safety researcher at the U-M Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation and U-M/VA Patient Safety Enhancement Program.

The authors give three recommendations for improving current policies aimed at monitoring progress in prevention of HAPUs, particularly when tied to hospital payment:

  • Medicare's value-based payment programs should develop a new surveillance strategy for HAPUs that's not just based on administrative billing data. Instead, they should rely on trained staff to do standardized chart-based surveillance, similar to what is done for hospital acquired infections, or require regular in-person surveillance using standard criteria similar to what is done for other quality indicators
  • Surveillance for HAPUs must recognize the differences between early-stage (stage 1 or 2) bedsores, and more advanced (stage 3 or 4) HAPUs which are much harder to heal, hold higher risk for severe complications, and cost more to treat.
  • Rather than exclude high risk patients from measurement of complication rates, as some value-based purchasing policies currently do, all patients should be included for measurement, and then the Medicare's value-based purchasing programs could appropriately "risk-adjust" hospital HAPU rates to account for different proportions of higher-risk patients at different hospitals.

"The goal is to motivate hospitals to do better, but when the measure is so dependent on documentation and there's such a large discrepancy between the system used for payment and the systems used to gauge the impact of value-based purchasing policies, we need to ask if we're using the right data for public reporting and when comparing hospital performance for penalty assignment" says Meddings.

More about HAPU policy

Federal policies about HAPU-related payment first took effect in late 2008. Starting late that year, hospitals didn't get paid for HAPUs that reached advanced stages while a patient was in the hospital, and didn't get extra payment for caring for early-stage pressure ulcers that had when they arrived at the hospital or developed while they were there.

The Affordable Care Act doubled down on this effort, by imposing financial penalties on hospitals with the highest rates certain hospital complications, using a measure that includes HAPU rates. But it bases those penalties on hospitals' rates of higher-stage HAPUs, for which there is no clear incentive to bill beyond risk of audit because of no payment for these complications as diagnoses.

Meddings and her colleagues note that other types of value-based purchasing policies have transitioned to chart-review surveillance strategies to measure and rank hospitals on rates of hospital-acquired infections. Pressure ulcers, like catheter-associated urinary tract infections, were among the first patient safety measures to receive federal focus and affect income. It's time for HAPU measurement and payment to move away from administrative data, too, they say.

Explore further: 2008 initiative had minimal impact on pressure ulcer charges

More information: Health Affairs (2018). DOI: 10.1377/hlthaff.2018.0712

Related Stories

2008 initiative had minimal impact on pressure ulcer charges

July 29, 2015
(HealthDay)—The 2008 Hospital-Acquired Conditions Initiative (HACI) payment changes for pressure ulcers have had a minimal effect, according to a study published in the July issue of the Journal of the American Geriatrics ...

Hospital-acquired UTIs rarely reported in data used to implement penalties

September 5, 2012
Aiming to cut expenses and improve care, a 2008 Medicare policy stopped paying hospitals extra to treat some preventable, hospital-acquired conditions – including urinary tract infections (UTIs) in patients after bladder ...

Hospital report cards for hospital-acquired bedsores: How good are the grades?

October 14, 2013
The data Medicare uses to publicly report hospital rates of patients developing pressure ulcers (or bedsores) is not an accurate source for comparing hospitals on how well they prevent the condition, says a new University ...

Moneyball in Medicare? It's working, study says

September 17, 2018
Incentives for hospitals to improve their quality and reduce costs do work, according to a new University of Michigan study.

CMS Policy to reduce hospital-acquired conditions had minimal impact

June 28, 2018
Hospitals may have avoided financial penalties by billing hospital-associated conditions (HAC) as present at the time of the patient's admission, supporting prior work that showed that a Medicare policy designed to monetarily ...

GI bleeding research points to need for updated Medicare policies

June 5, 2018
Penn Medicine researchers are calling for greater precision in Medicare performance reporting for patients with gastrointestinal (GI) bleeding following an evaluation of patients with the condition.

Recommended for you

How to survive on 'Game of Thrones': Switch allegiances

December 9, 2018
Characters in the Game of Thrones TV series are more likely to die if they do not switch allegiance, and are male, according to an article published in the open access journal Injury Epidemiology.

Expert calls for strong, sustainable action to make world roadways safer

December 7, 2018
According to the latest World Health Organization (WHO) report on road safety, more than 1.3 million people die on the world's roadways each year—and millions more are injured or disabled. Yet despite the huge cost to families ...

Hazelnuts improve older adults' micronutrient levels

December 6, 2018
Older adults who added hazelnuts to their diet for a few months significantly improved their levels of two key micronutrients, new research at Oregon State University indicates.

Regular bedtimes and sufficient sleep for children may lead to healthier teens

December 6, 2018
Having a regular, age-appropriate bedtime and getting sufficient sleep from early childhood may be important for healthy body weight in adolescence, according to researchers at Penn State.

Stress from using electronic health records is linked to physician burnout

December 5, 2018
While electronic health records (EHRs) improve communication and access to patient data, researchers found that stress from using EHRs is associated with burnout, particularly for primary care doctors such as pediatricians, ...

Chemicals in personal care and household products linked to earlier puberty in girls

December 4, 2018
Chemicals that are widely used in personal care and household products are linked to girls entering puberty at earlier ages, according to findings from a long-running study of mothers and children published today.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.