Mimicking effect of exercise with gene therapy
It sounds too good to be true—and it is. But Jose Bianco Moreira and the CERG research group at NTNU are convinced that some of the positive health effects of physical exercise can be achieved using gene therapy and medication.
"We're not talking about healthy people and everyone who can exercise. They still have to train, of course," says Moreira. He and his colleagues at NTNU's Department of Circulation and Medical Imaging are studying the effect of exercise on our cells.
Those who can't
"But some people can't train, or only in a limited way. This could include individuals who've been in accidents, who are in wheelchairs, or who have diseases that prevent the possibility of physical expression. We want to create hope for these folks."
"A small group of healthy people out there also obtain very little effect from physical exercise—so-called low responders—and would benefit from a method that worked at the cellular level," says Moreira.
Cells are the key
A lot of research confirms the health benefits of physical exercise, but we know far less about what happens in the cells that provides the positive effects.
"International research in this field is brand new. We've barely scratched the surface," says the researcher.
"We think increasing our knowledge about what happens at the cellular level will be important for discovering medications and treatments for heart disease. My group studies genes, proteins and mitochondria that produce energy and are key for chemical processes in the cells."
Gene therapy already in use
Moreira believes that gene therapy is the most effective method for reproducing the health benefits we normally get through physical exercise.
A medicine that uses gene therapy is already in use for spinal muscle atrophy, a serious disease that leads to muscle wasting. The drug uses a harmless virus to deliver a copy that replaces the damaged motor neuron network in patients.
This form of therapy can inhibit or enhance the expression of a gene. This is a very expensive medicine and has not been tried for heart disease, for example.
CRISPR is coming
Moreira believes CRISPR will be the future go-to gene therapy method. He believes this method of editing the genes will revolutionize a lot of disease treatments.
"CRISPR is easier to use, faster and cheaper than today's gene therapy, which only attenuates or enhances the expression of a gene. CRISPR's potential is almost limitless. It can alter the gene itself. The parts of the gene that don't work properly are replaced with well-functioning parts."
Experiments on rats and mice have shown that the method works. Experiments have also been performed on human cells in the laboratory to confirm CRISPR's effectiveness, but it has not yet been tested on humans.
"CRISPR still has to be tested in large clinical studies. I'd be optimistic if I say gene editing will come into regular use in 10-15 years," says Moreira.
Moreira's research group has used CRISPR in its research, but the results are not yet ready for publication.
"We believe gene therapy is the most powerful method because patients don't have to take a pill every day. Usually, gene therapy changes the gene forever, perhaps with an injection or two. The challenge is to find the right gene that needs change, and an effective method to repair it," he says.
NTNU researchers are focusing on the heart. They have identified a protein that heart-diseased rats are deficit in, but which increases when the rats go through training.
"By increasing the amount of this protein through gene therapy, we've managed to strengthen the muscle cells and have replicated some of the positive effects of physical exercise," says Moreira.
Medications are another possible method of mimicking the effects of exercise. Some existing medicines might even be able to recreate some of the positive effect on the heart.
"The research now has powerful technology platforms to find possible other uses for medicines we already have. One problem, of course, is that medicine is chemistry that affects the whole body, not just the organ you want to help. Something that's good for the heart could be detrimental for the liver, for example. Compared to gene therapy, though, the potential for medications is much more limited," Moreira says.
Finding "attack targets"
When the research group at NTNU started their study, they had no idea which genes were affected by exercise. They performed experiments where rats with heart defects underwent training. Afterwards, the hearts were removed and examined. Then these hearts were compared with those from untrained rats with heart disease. Afterwards, the hearts of the trained and untrained rats with heart disease were compared to healthy rat hearts.
"We observed that genes were altered in the diseased hearts, but discovered that some of them were repaired in the rats that had trained. This way, we find genes that we can target. Through our measurements, we can find out exactly what training changes at the cellular level," says Moreira.
The NTNU researchers are collaborating with Johan Aurwerx and his group at the École Polytechnique Fédérale in Lausanne.
More information: Jose B. N. Moreira et al. Exercise and cardiac health: physiological and molecular insights, Nature Metabolism (2020). DOI: 10.1038/s42255-020-0262-1