Surgery is a viable treatment for pancreatic cancer patients especially after chemotherapy

Pancreatic cancer
Pancreatic cancer cells (blue) growing as a sphere encased in membranes (red). Credit: National Cancer Institute

Patients with stage II pancreatic cancer who are treated with chemotherapy followed by resection (an operation that removes the cancerous part of the organ, structure or tissue) live nearly twice as long as patients who receive only chemotherapy, according to a new Journal of the American College of Surgeons study published online in advance of print.

In stage II patients, there is a chance that can be removed by even after it has spread close to blood vessels. Although chemotherapy can improve outcomes, the risk of surgery is justified because the patients live longer even if the is not entirely removed, according to the study from researchers at the University of Arizona Department of Surgery, Tucson.

Surgery can improve survival

The researchers found that patients who received chemotherapy followed by resection lived an average of 19.75 months, while those who received only chemotherapy lived an average of 10.12 months. They examined data from the National Cancer Database (NCDB), a joint program of the American College of Surgeons and the American Cancer Society.

"Our results show that surgery is viable in more cases than we thought," said Amanda K. Arrington, MD, MHM, FACS, a at the University of Arizona Department of Surgery, Tucson.

Pancreatic cancer is the fourth leading cause of cancer deaths in men and women in the U.S. Survival rates for pancreatic cancer are low because it is a fairly aggressive, fast-growing cancer, Dr. Arrington said. Approximately 10 to 30 percent of these patients present with disease in which resection may be considered an appropriate therapy. Chemotherapy can improve the chances for successful surgery, as about one in three borderline cases are resectable following chemotherapy. Even after surgery, however, it is common for pancreatic cancer to return.

While the goal of resection is to remove all of the tumor tissue, it can be difficult to accomplish, especially if the cancer has spread to nearby blood vessels that feed the liver and small intestine. Margin status, or how much cancerous tissue is left post-surgery on the edges of the resected area, is a significant predictor of survival after surgery for pancreatic cancer. Patients with no cancerous tissue left after resection (R0) have improved survival compared with patients with microscopic amounts (R1) or macroscopic amounts (R2) of cancerous tissue left after resection. This study looked at R1 and R2 resection outcomes compared with chemotherapy alone.

Key findings are summarized by the study's lead study author Amanda K. Arrington, MD, MHM, FACS, a surgical oncologist at the University of Arizona Department of Surgery, Tucson. Credit: American College of Surgeons

Study details

Dr. Arrington and her colleagues searched NCDB data from 2010 to 2015 for stage II pancreatic cancer patients who underwent R1/R2 surgery with or without pre-operational chemotherapy to compare to stage II patients who received chemotherapy alone. They found:

  • Out of a total of 11,699 stage II pancreatic cancer patients, 9,521 (81.4 percent) were treated with chemotherapy alone, while 2,178 (18.6 percent) underwent and had positive margins (R1 or R2).
  • Of the surgical group, 1,836 (84.3 percent) underwent upfront surgery and 342 (15.7 percent) had chemotherapy followed by surgery.
  • The R1 or R2 patients that had chemotherapy before resection had the best overall survival at a mean of 19.75 months, followed by the upfront surgery group with a mean survival of 17.77 months, and the chemotherapy alone group with a mean survival of 10.12 months.

The data was analyzed in multiple ways to address potential bias; all analyses of the data delivered the same findings.

Surgery is a viable treatment for pancreatic cancer patients especially after chemotherapy
Surgery is an underused treatment for certain pancreatic cancer patients Credit: Journal of the American College of Surgeons

Study results confirm current recommendations for stage II pancreatic cancer, which note that survival improves when patients receive multimodality therapy, chemotherapy before and/or after resection. Further, patients benefit from surgery even in extremely difficult cases that end up with a margin positive resection, Dr. Arrington said. The researchers found even when the tumor does not shrink significantly in response to chemotherapy, there are still survival benefits to taking an aggressive surgical approach.

"Based on this study, surgeons can be a little more aggressive and offer surgical treatment more often than not to stage II pancreatic cancer patients," Dr. Arrington said. "There are ongoing studies looking at whether more patients, including stage I patients, would benefit from after ."

Explore further

Pre-surgery chemotherapy is possible for early stage pancreatic cancer patients

More information: Amanda K. Arrington et al, Survival After Margin-Positive Resection in the Era of Modern Chemotherapy for Pancreatic Cancer: Do Patients Still Benefit?, Journal of the American College of Surgeons (2021). DOI: 10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2021.02.020
Citation: Surgery is a viable treatment for pancreatic cancer patients especially after chemotherapy (2021, March 26) retrieved 14 August 2022 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors