Australia's healthcare system comes out ahead in global comparison

Australia's healthcare system is one of the best in the western world when it comes to elderly patient outcomes following hip fracture or heart disease, a new study reveals.

The International Collaborative on Costs, Outcomes and Needs in Care (ICCONIC) study, led by Harvard University and the London School of Economics, compared healthcare costs and death rates across similar patient groups in 10 OECD countries.

The Centre for Health Economics Research and Evaluation (CHERE) at the University of Technology Sydney conducted the Australian arm of the research. A special issue of the Health Services Research journal recently published a series of papers on the results.

The study revealed significant variations in health outcomes across countries, including England, Canada, Germany, France, Switzerland, New Zealand and the United States, which did not appear to be linked to health spending.

Deputy Director of CHERE, Professor Kees Van Gool, said comparing how other health care systems look after high-need patients can provide important insights on how each country's health system performs.

"International comparisons of health care costs, use, access and outcomes allows policy makers to benchmark and measure improvements in health system performance," said Professor Van Gool.

"A comparative analysis can also identify where improved performance could lead to better health outcomes and a more sustainable system," he said.

In order to assess health outcomes, the study focused on two groups of patients aged over 65—people admitted to hospital with heart failure who have diabetes, and those who had hip replacement surgery due to a hip fracture.

Australia had the lowest one-year mortality rate for patients with chronic heart failure and the second lowest mortality rate for patients with a hip fracture.

Following hospitalization due to heart failure with diabetes, 22% of patients in Australia had died of any cause after one year, while England had the highest rate at 43%.

A year after hip replacement surgery 21% of patients in Australia had died, with only France having a lower rate at 20%. England had the highest rate with nearly one third of patients not surviving the first year.

The researchers used data from 2014 to 2018, so the study did not include the impact of COVID-19 on health outcomes. Australia's contribution to the study was based on NSW data.

"Compared to other countries, Australia spends relatively little on primary care and relatively more on hospital care, however the lower cost of primary care was due to lower fees rather than fewer visits to the GP," said Professor Van Gool.

"Australian patients in the study were admitted to hospital more often than comparable patients in other countries but they had relatively shorter lengths of stay. The cost per hospitalization in Australia was high compared to other countries.

"This greater reliance on the hospital sector raises some interesting policy issues on the stronger role that primary care could play in managing patients with complex conditions," he said.

Australia and New Zealand reported a very low percentage of people dying in hospital. Australian patients were admitted fewer times in the last 12 months of life than patients residing in other countries.

In contrast to countries like the US and Germany, primary care physicians also took a greater role in end-of-life care in Australia.

The study also compared the use of prescription drugs and the price per script. The degree of variation across countries was quite low, with the notable exception of the US, whose citizens pay a much higher price per script.