Study finds less blood can be used in heart operations

November 13, 2017 by Andrew Trounson, University of Melbourne
Heart surgery uses high quantities of blood as patients need red blood cell transfusions to boost their haemoglobin levels. Credit: Paul Burston/University of Melbourne

Heart surgery requires more blood transfusions than almost any other surgical procedure.

But a major international study of over 5,000 surgery patients has now shown that surgeons can safely use significantly less than they have been. The potential saving is equivalent to around one blood donation (about 470 millilitres) per moderate-to-high risk patient.

During a heart bypass operation, a patient's blood is first drained into the heart-lung machine and then pumped back into the patient. The heart is then flushed with potassium to put them into cardiac arrest. Primed with 1.5 litres of mostly salty water, the machine pumps about 4.5 litres a minute of blood through an oxygenator and then back into the patient's bloodstream.

The fluid is needed to displace all of the air in the pump circuit. Within about 60 seconds, the pump prime dilutes a patient's blood by about a third, diluting the blood's oxygen-bearing and leaving patients anaemic.

"It is one of the most dramatic alterations to someone's blood composition in all of medicine," says Royal Melbourne Hospital heart surgeon and University of Melbourne deputy director of surgery Professor Alistair Royse.

It is why heart surgery requires high quantities of blood as patients generally need red blood cell transfusions to boost their haemoglobin levels. But the evidence is now in that patients can safely tolerate lower levels of haemoglobin during surgery, meaning less blood is needed.

"This study may significantly change clinical practice across the globe by supporting the ongoing trend towards using blood transfusions at a lower haemoglobin concentration," says Professor Royse who led the Australian arm of the study that involved over 620 patients across 12 hospitals in Victoria, New South Wales and South Australia.

"There is a philosophical mind-set towards using less blood and what this study shows is that it is safe to be going down this pathway," says Professor Royse.

Less blood, less cost

Using less blood during heart surgery would represent a significant cost saving to health systems globally. In Australia while blood is given freely by donors, it costs AU$412 per unit to supply red blood cells. On top of that there are hospital costs that Professor Royse says can take the total cost of a completed transfusion up to as much as AU$1,000 per unit.

Led by principal investigator Professor David Mazer from the University of Toronto, the five-year study, published in the New England Journal of Medicine, is the largest of its kind and monitored patients at 73 institutions across 19 countries. Australia's National Health and Medical Research Council provided AU$1.4 million in funding that was crucial in the study being expanded from an initially planned 3,500 patients to more than 5,000.

Over the last decade there has been a growing international trend among heart surgeons to use less blood, not just to save limited donated blood supplies, but also to avoid the rare health complications that can arise from blood transfusions. These include allergic or immune reactions to the introduced blood, and the risk of receiving disease infected blood.

But the safety of tolerating lower haemoglobin levels in heart surgery patients was thrown into doubt in 2015 by a study of just over 2,000 patients in the UK.

Professor Alistair Royse talk about the research into using less blood. Credit: Paul Burston/University of Melbourne

Ensuring it's safe

The study found that the death rate 90 days after surgery among those treated with lower haemoglobin levels was 4.2 per cent, much higher than the 2.6 per cent death rate among the group treated with higher haemoglobin levels. While the nature of the deaths didn't indicate a causal link to haemoglobin levels, the researchers concluded that the results were a cause for concern.

However, this much larger international study, which was focused on moderate-to-high risk cardiac patients who are more likely to need transfusions, found no significant difference in outcomes between a low-haemoglobin treatment regime and a more traditional regime.

"The UK study raised a lot of questions and this study was specifically designed to answer the question of whether a restrictive haemoglobin regime was as safe as the standard liberal regime, and the answer according to our study is yes, it is just as safe," says Professor Royse.

The randomised study recruited heart surgery patients aged 18 and over who were classified as being moderate-to-high risk, and then tracked them from the start of their operation until discharge, or 28 days, whichever came sooner.

In half the patients, surgeons tolerated a diluted haemoglobin level as low as 9.5g/100mls, representing a more "liberal" and traditional use of blood. That compares with normal haemoglobin levels of around 14g/100ml. But the other, more "restrictive" group were allowed to tolerate haemoglobin levels as low as 7.5g/100mls.

Contrary to the smaller UK study, the death rate was actually slightly lower in the "restricted" group at 3 per cent compared with 3.6 per cent for the "liberal group." The proportion of patients that experienced either a subsequent heart attack, stroke, kidney failure or death was also lower among the restrictive group at 11 per cent, compared with 12 per cent for the liberal group.

"Given the large sample size we have, these results are more than sufficient to be confident that the restrictive practise wasn't inferior to the liberal practice," says Professor Royse.

A 'landmark' study

Dr Chris Hogan, a haematologist and transfusion medicine specialist who works with Professor Royse at Royal Melbourne Hospital, says the study represents "landmark" evidence supporting the trend toward using less blood.

"To date, there has been significant concern, and a lack of a very strong evidence base, to extrapolate this type of more conservative and restrictive transfusion practice to cardiac surgical ," says Dr Hogan. "But these research findings represent a landmark study in the contemporary transfusion medicine literature, and should now confidently inform transfusion practice in cardiac surgical settings."

The ideal next step says Professor Royse to undertake an economic analysis to quantify the cost savings of implementing a more "restrictive" haemoglobin regime. There is also scope he says to research the safety of tolerating even slightly lower haemoglobin levels.

"This study has been extremely successful, the whole system worked really well at the lower threshold and it was a great outcome. But from here we need to go the next step and investigate how low should we go," says Professor Royse.

"We also should be researching whether we have to dilute blood during as much as we do in the first place."

Explore further: When should blood transfusions be given after cardiac surgery?

More information: C. David Mazer et al. Restrictive or Liberal Red-Cell Transfusion for Cardiac Surgery, New England Journal of Medicine (2017). DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1711818

Related Stories

When should blood transfusions be given after cardiac surgery?

March 11, 2015
New research has shown that patients having heart surgery do not benefit if doctors wait until a patient has become substantially anaemic before giving a transfusion.

Genome therapy could lead to new treatment for life-threatening blood disorders

July 17, 2017
Genome therapy with beneficial natural mutation could lead to new treatment for life-threatening blood disorders

Clinical trial fails to disclose risk of death, repeat heart attacks, advocacy group says

August 2, 2017
A clinical trial testing blood transfusion therapies for heart attack patients may place participants in danger of death or a repeat heart attack without fully disclosing those risks, a Washington, D.C.-based consumer advocacy ...

International study proves old blood is as good as new

October 24, 2016
It's been long thought that when blood transfusions are needed, it may be best to use the freshest blood, but McMaster University researchers have led a large international study proving that it is not so.

Recommended for you

Marriage may protect against heart disease / stroke and associated risk of death

June 18, 2018
Marriage may protect against the development of heart disease/stroke as well as influencing who is more likely to die of it, suggests a pooled analysis of the available data, published online in the journal Heart.

Deaths from cardiac arrest are misclassified, overestimated

June 18, 2018
Forty percent of deaths attributed to cardiac arrest are not sudden or unexpected, and nearly half of the remainder are not arrhythmic—the only situation in which CPR and defibrillators are effective—according to an analysis ...

Tick-borne meat sensitivity linked to heart disease

June 15, 2018
University of Virginia School of Medicine researchers have linked sensitivity to an allergen in red meat—a sensitivity spread by tick bites—with a buildup of fatty plaque in the arteries of the heart. This buildup may ...

The molecules that energize babies' hearts

June 14, 2018
A metabolic process that provides heart muscle with energy fails to mature in newborns with thickened heart walls, according to a Japan–Canada research team.

Tobacco aside, e-cigarette flavorings may harm blood vessels

June 14, 2018
Flavor additives used in electronic cigarettes and related tobacco products could impair blood vessel function and may be an early indicator of heart damage, according to new laboratory research in Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis ...

Scientists identify enzyme responsible for vascular damage caused by aircraft noise

June 14, 2018
In a recent study, scientists at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU) have identified an enzyme responsible for aircraft-related vascular damage. The researchers were also able to show that nighttime noise has a particularly ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.