Change blindness animation captures top illusion prize

by Bob Yirka report

(PhysOrg.com) -- After discovering by accident through a quirk in his laptop that random dots arranged in a circle and constantly changing color, appeared to stop changing color if they began to move, Jordan Suchow a grad student at Harvard, in conjunction with his advisor George Alvarez, produced a video of the effect and wound up winning first prize in this year’s "Best Illusion of the Year" contest held by the Vision Sciences Society every year in Naples, Florida. The illusion showed that there exists a form of change blindness that until this example arose, no one knew about.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.

In the video there is a tiny red speck in the center of the screen, surrounded by white space and beyond that a band of colored dots three of four layers deep. When the video starts, the colored dots change color randomly, creating the effect of a twinkling Christmas wreath; but when all the dots begin to move as one in a circle around the red speck in the center, if you focus on the just that red speck, the dots appear to stop twinkling; but it’s just an that can be easily seen if you focus instead on the dots and see that they do in fact go right on twinkling the whole time.

Suchow and Alvarez have published a paper on Current Biology, where they describe how the effect was created and how it doesn’t matter if you change the colors, size or shape of the dots; the result is the same. They call the effect because of the fact that the illusion works even though the person looking at it knows it’s happening. They theorize that the illusion happens because the brain tends to ignore what is happening with a moving object, focusing instead on the movement itself.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.

Taking second place in the contest was an illusion called “Grouping by Contrast.” In this illusion by Erica Dixon, Arthur Shapiro & Kai Hamburger, there are four illuminated disks; on the left are a pair of disks on a black background that alternate between black and white as they are illuminated and then turned off; on the right is a similar pair of discs shown on a yellow background. The disks appear to alternate in going on and off. At the bottom of the screen there is a bar that reads “Click to add or remove background.” Clicking on that bar causes the background of both sides to become grey, and in so doing causes the disks to appear to change from alternating in their luminescence, to doing so in tandem.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.

Third place was captured by “The Lock Ness Aftereffect” which is a video by Mark Wexler, that also has a red dot in the center and a wreathlike object spinning around it. This time though, the wreath is comprised of many short lines of varying degrees of blacks and grays. As the viewer stares at the red dot, the wreath suddenly jumps followed by what appears to be the wreath spinning faster in the opposite direction; which of course it isn’t. The illusion gets its name from the well known effect of staring at a particular waterfall in Scotland that leads to Lock Ness, home to a certain, well known, mythological beast.

More information: illusioncontest.neuralcorrelate.com/

Related Stories

Best Visual Illusion of the Year: How a Curveball Works

date May 13, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Visual illusions sometimes seem to have a magical element to them, but they're actually just the brain's way of interpreting reality. In an effort to promote public knowledge of cognitive ...

Moon Illusion tricks the eye

date Jan 19, 2011

We’ve all experienced the Moon Illusion, where our own full Moon looks bigger when seen on the Earth’s horizon. But how about this illusion where you can’t really tell which of these two moons ...

Recommended for you

Men and women could use different cells to process pain

date 1 hour ago

We have known for some time that there are sex differences when it comes to experiencing pain, with women showing a higher sensitivity to painful events compared to men. While we don't really understand w ...

Pupillary reflex enhanced by light inside blind spot

date 2 hours ago

University of Tokyo researchers have found that the light reflex of the pupil is modulated by light stimulation inside the blind spot in normal human observers, even though that light is not perceived.

How your brain knows it's summer

date 18 hours ago

Researchers led by Toru Takumi at the RIKEN Brain Science Institute in Japan have discovered a key mechanism underlying how animals keep track of the seasons. The study, published in Proceedings of the Na ...

His and her pain circuitry in the spinal cord

date 22 hours ago

New research released today in Nature Neuroscience reveals for the first time that pain is processed in male and female mice using different cells. These findings have far-reaching implications for our ba ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Tangent2
May 19, 2011
My eyes hurt now.
mark0101
May 19, 2011
The first one doesn't work for me. Even if I stare in the middle and they start spinning I still can tell the colors are changing.
neiorah
May 19, 2011
Me too. Some illusions work and some others do not. Like one of the blind spot illusions. They never work for me. These are interesting though.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.